The largest US cablecos are becoming a significant competitive threat to the telcos, especially now Comcast and Charter Communications are entering the mobile and multiplay market in earnest. The two companies are working together on mobile R&D, deployment and services, since their territories hardly overlap, and may well pool their resources in future to buy more 5G spectrum. Comcast went commercial last year with its Xfinity Mobile offering, and now Charter has followed suit with Spectrum Mobile, which also leverages an MVNO agreement with Verizon, as well as significant investment in WiFi hotspots and homespots.
For now, Charter’s service is available only to existing or new customers of its Spectrum broadband offering. If their mobile businesses go well, both cablecos may want to offer mobility as a standalone service in future, though there might be implications for their current cooperation if they sell against one another in the same locations.
Spectrum Mobile customers have a choice of two plans – an unlimited option for $45 a month (throttled once 20GB is exceeded in any one month) or a metered option, which costs $14 per GB of data. There are instalment plans available for devices, but no iPhone yet – the initial choices are all from Samsung and LG (LG K30, and Samsung Galaxy S9+, S8, S9 and S8+), though more are to follow.
At Apple’s Worldwide Developers Conference in June, Charter joined the host company to pledge that the iPhone and iPad would come to Spectrum Mobile, in an unspecified timeframe. More interestingly, Charter will also market the Apple TV as a set top alternative, streaming Charter’s live and on-demand pay TV content via a streaming app. This highlights how the cablecos will hope to harness their combination of content deals, pay TV installed base and fixed/mobile convergence to differentiate themselves from Verizon and AT&T (and even more effectively, from the mobile-only T-Mobile and Sprint).
In the short term, the expansion into mobile is important to reduce churn in the pay TV and broadband bases; to bring in additional subscribers, lured by a quad play bundle; and to monetize existing customers more effectively. This is becoming urgent as the TV subscriber bases erode and broadband growth declines. Comcast, which launched in May 2017, added 197,000 Xfinity Mobile connections in the first quarter of this year, and had 577,000 fixed/mobile users as of the end of March.
The two cablecos, as well as Altice – which will launch mobile services next year via an MVNO deal with Sprint – are likely to have far grander plans in the medium term. They are keen to leverage shared spectrum, especially in the general access element of the CBRS band in 3.5 GHz, and also to buy their own airwaves, to reduce their reliance on the MVNO arrangements. This would reduce the money they have to pay Verizon and enable them to build localized or specialized subnets in 3.5 GHz, backhauled by their own cables, to support particular verticals, cities or high value services.
They are saving time and cost by collaborating on back office systems and other platforms, as well as 5G R&D, and may well share spectrum and infrastructure in future as they start to build more of their own networks in selected, high value areas. They are already the two largest players behind the massive shared CableWiFi network of hotspots and homespots and could apply the same roaming approach to cellular subnets.
Other areas in which Comcast and Charter say they will cooperate, as part of the mobile alliance announced last May, include mutual contributions to standards development and trials, device procurement and logistics, and emerging technology platforms. Customer support, marketing, sales, pricing and packaging will be handled separately.
While they, like other MVNOs and enterprise providers, will always need the MNOs for wide area connectivity and roaming, they have dropped heavy hints that they will build their own infrastructure for targeted opportunities such as smart cities or vertical sector IoT networks, which would make them threatening to the telcos in new ways – in high value emerging enterprise markets, not just in users’ homes.
Charter has been testing small cells running in the CBRS shared spectrum (and calling them ‘6G’), while both companies are active in R&D geared to a broader 5G platform than 3GPP and the large MNOs envisage.
CEO Tom Rutledge told an investor call earlier this year, “We are building our sales channels and service capabilities, including modifying several hundred of our 700 retail stores and setting up the call center environment. Ultimately, the goal is to use our mobile service to attract and retain cable bundle multiproduct customers.”
He also expanded on some of the future network plans, saying, “In addition to the continued advancements in WiFi throughput and latency, we’re testing in various bands including 28 GHz and 3.5 GHz, which are going well and support our thesis with small cells using unlicensed and licensed spectrum, including midband spectrum like 3.5 GHz.”
So much of the challenge of making 5G truly cost-effective will lie in striking the right balance between licensed and unlicensed spectrum, between different radio technologies, and between low cost boxes and cutting edge elements. The big telcos, with their hefty burden of legacy networks and processes, need to keep a watchful eye on the cablecos to ensure they don’t lose out in this race.
The deal may end up being the precursor to wider cooperation with other players, as Comcast’s WiFi hotspot tie-up with TWC expanded into the multi-operator CableWiFi alliance. Since the cablecos’ territories hardly overlap, they may join up under the same brand to take on the large US MNOs with one major cellular operator. They have tried that before, in the Pivot and SpectrumCo partnerships with Sprint, but the timing and the choice of partner were not good. This time around, the cablecos would not be beholden to an MNO – they have the dense fiber which will be as essential as new radios to 5G, and Comcast is building upwards of 16 million WiFi hotspots and homespots to shift the economics of attaining national wireless coverage.
Analysts at New Street Research said when the cableco deal was announced last year, that the closer cooperation would hasten a Sprint/T-Mobile tie-up – which is now back on the cards. They wrote at the time, “The emergence of cable as a serious new entrant significantly improves the odds of a Sprint/T-Mobile merger being approved. This announcement on its own may not be enough to convince regulators that we are in a five-carrier market, but it helps.”