By now everyone has seen the new Cisco Visual Networking Index out on Feb 5, and one thing we can say is that its earlier, sometimes crazy assertions, such as WiFi only accounting for 22% of mobile data traffic, something it mistakenly said early last year, are now out of the way and history.
But we still don’t quite trust it. So while it says that by 2018 more than half of all traffic from mobile connected devices, making up almost 17 Exabytes, will be offloaded, a later forecast makes us worried about its definition of offloaded.
Cisco says that the amount of traffic offloaded from smartphones will be 51% by 2018, and the amount of traffic offloaded from tablets will be 69% by 2018. Well first thoughts are that tablets are more than 80% WiFi only right now, which would surely mean that 80% plus traffic is currently ‘offloaded’ to WiFi. But to counter this the Cisco VNI says that by 2018 42% of all tablets will have a cellular connection.
Now IF that happens, it still means that 58% of tablets will remain WiFi only and if they are as active as the 4G attached versions, they should be responsible for 58% of all traffic, so that puts a floor on it. If you say that 50% of the cellular attached tablet traffic is also WiFi, then you still get a traffic number close to 80%.
Cisco seems to be saying that operators are going to sell more tablets and they are going to WANT most of the traffic on their 4G networks, unless they deliberately offload it. We just can’t see that happening. There is no way that operators will take away the right of consumers to ‘prefer’ WiFi and unless there is a dramatic raise in the cellular caps (in the US they are currently around 5GB a month) in LTE, then much of the tablet usage will be WiFi, because 5GB is not enough, but Cisco’s own admission.
Even if caps go as high as 20GB a month, people will still see the wisdom of viewing say 4K content on their tablet, through WiFi, because the streams are so massive ‘ and over the next 5 years there will be tablet 4K video services for sure.
All the usual Cisco VNI numbers are cited, how much data growth there will be, how much of that will be video and what the total number of Exabytes per annum will add up to (190 Exabytes), but we feel the Cisco VNI is a cheap trick to garner all the headlines for Cisco that should be with proper analysts, and as such it should be viewed mostly as a PR stunt, not a serious forecast.
There is also a big confusion ‘ and not just for Cisco, between what data is already offloaded through a decision of the tablet or smartphone owner, to their home or work WiFi, and how much is genuine data offload, requested by an MNO and arranged with a WISP. That distinction is vital and is largely ignored, because it is so hard to find reliable data on MNO initiated offload, and companies like Free in France operator a ‘WiFi first policy’ whereas we have to assume most MNOs would operate a ‘WiFi Last’ policy.
One interesting addition is the per device usage growth in the table above. This seems to suggest that a M2M module will produce about 61 MB a month in data, about 6 times what a normal phone does. This is daft, since most M2M apps sit and self-assess and only send exception data and even then, only in 50Kb packets, so unless it was doing this on a regular reporting basis, which certainly does not happen in a ZigBee style environment and would be pointless in say an energy management application (mostly one report per month for billing) this seems overkill on behalf of the Cisco VNI team. We certainly can’t see how this would erupt to 451 Megabytes a month by 2018, more than most smart phone users today, in a five year time frame.