Connected TV is disrupting the business models not just of content owners and pay TV operators but also public service broadcasters, threatening to deprive them of income. This has led the UK government to consider requiring a fee just for watching catch up services such as BBC iPlayer. At present UK TV viewers have to pay an annual £145 ($230) fee if they want to watch TV content ‘as it is being broadcast’, although this does not distinguish between a TV set, PC, or mobile platforms. The payment is one per household.
However the line between linear and catch up has become increasingly blurred as the latter has become available on TVs as well as PCs, with iPlayer for example now available on connected TVs from Samsung and Sony among others. At the same time the catch up window has shortened, so that more viewers are watching scheduled content in catch up mode just minutes after it has been broadcast. This has created the situation where people can avoid paying the license fee just by claiming they consume all their content in catch up mode, and the UK government wants to snuff out this loophole before too many people realize it is there.
TV license fees are charged in many European countries and some elsewhere such as Japan, and has become a sensitive issue during the current period of austerity. It looms largest in the UK because of the strength and reputation of the BBC, and the fact it relies almost entirely on license fee income for domestic programming inside the UK, including iPlayer. The license fee has been frozen at its current £145 ($230) until 2017, which will effectively reduce it by around 16% in real terms, depending on inflation.
There will be growing pressure to relax the ban on advertising within BBC channels in the UK. Most other European countries allow public broadcasters to advertise, although this does not always mean the license fee is any less. In Ireland public broadcaster RTE does accept advertising and derives only 50% of its revenue from the fee, but that is still €160, almost as much as the UK.
In France the fee is somewhat lower, €121, with a significant proportion of France Television’s revenue coming from advertising. However this country is perhaps bucking the trend and moving away from commercial advertising in public broadcasting, which is being gradually phased out under a law introduced by President Sarkozy in 2009.
In Germany the public broadcasters ZDF and Deutschlandradio, as well as the nine regional broadcasters of the ARD network, are allowed to advertise but even so the TV license is actually higher than the UK at €215.76. However this will change from 2013 when Germany plans to reform the system and levy the fee on every household irrespective of whether they own a TV or not, exempting only the very poor or disabled. This will at a stroke address the issue of catch up, which Germany already acknowledges by charging a lower fee of €69.12 for people with just Internet access to TV services. Since 2007 people with Internet access alone have been liable to this fee, but now Germany has decided the difference between the two license fees can no longer be justified. After all, the distinction between a smart TV and a PC with a big display is fast diminishing, and in the UK the arrival of the YouView platform in February 2012 supported by the BBC, BT and others will erode this gap further. Then people will be able to watch a lot of scheduled content near live on the big screen via a set top box connected to the Internet in just the same way as they do on a PC.
Some other countries already in effect levy the TV license on every household on the assumption that the TV is now as ubiquitous as the kitchen sink. The motive for doing this has been largely to reduce or eliminate the cost of collecting the license fee, which is significant in countries such as the UK where it is levied as a separate item outside normal taxation. This factor led the Netherlands to abandon the TV license fee altogether in 2001.
France has got round this by collecting the license along with local taxes, although still only from households with a TV set. However Greece adds a license component to every household’s electricity bill on the assumption that if you have power you must have a TV. This has been criticized for being unfair on the very poor who are most likely not to have a TV set, but is the least of that country’s problems at the moment.
In Japan the license fee has come under pressure for a different reason, loss of credibility of the national broadcaster Nippon H’s’ Ky’kai (NHK) following a series of scandals. This led to widespread evasion of the fee, with over 1 million TV owners not paying.
Yet despite all the problems, including persistent complaints from commercial broadcasters, the TV license fee long considered anachronistic in the US has survived in a surprisingly high number of other countries. Now though connected TV is creating new stresses which look like having the effect either of ending the license fee for good, making it compulsory as in Germany, or subsuming it completely into general taxation as may happen in France.