Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

3 November 2011

Android’s Window is narrowing as fragmentation continues

By Charlie Hall from the Online Reporter
The iPhone 4S from Apple wasn’t what anyone in the tech industry predicted, leading to a very mixed set of coverage with one resounding thought: ‘that sure wasn’t an iPhone 5!’

That let-down, in spite of the iPhone 4S’ amazing early sales, has given Android an opening into more consumers’ hearts and more techies’ minds, but the window is narrowing almost immediately after opening. The latest update from Android could be its last chance to grab the influential voices in the market all at once.
Android 4.0, Ice Cream Sandwich, has been a big hit with developers for all the things it can do down the road and the promised spread of the platform to devices running older versions.

Google is stuck, however, because it lacks the credibility to convince customers, developers, carriers and manufacturers that it is not only ready for prime time, but that it’ll make sure all devices get on stage before the curtain goes down. Android has had fragmentation troubles for quite some time, and these don’t appear to be going away, but they need to, immediately.

Google pledged to address the fragmentation problem with the formation of the Android Update Alliance back in May. Google said it would be working with carriers and manufacturers to deliver quicker updates and make sure handsets would receive updates for at least 18 months after their launch. This was great news and got a lot of people excited. So far, the service has yielded a few small fruit, but it hasn’t been nearly the harvest Google promised.

For phones covered by the Update Alliance, there are still six running Android 2.1, 23 running Android 2.2 and 32 running Android 2.3, and not all of these devices running Gingerbread (2.3) are running the versions with the latest patches (2.3.3 and higher).

Of the Android manufacturers that have publically spoken about being part of the Update Alliance, HTC has the most mobiles running Gingerbread (2.3), with 13 different models. That, however, contrasts to four of its models covered by the Alliance still running Android 2.1.

Gingerbread was released in December 2010, but it wasn’t until this month that Froyo (2.2) dropped below 50% penetration of Android handsets for the first time. Google is getting good at defining slow burn.

There were also many delays along the way. Android Cupcake (1.5) was delayed on all T-Mobile devices. That was followed by Donut being delayed for Samsung’s devices; ‘clair being delayed on HTC devices; Froyo getting an overall delay; Gingerbread was delayed on some models and even caused the Nexus S to push its launch date back; Honeycomb forced tablets to launch very late (many were planning launches directly after the 2011 CES); and Ice Cream Sandwich was delayed a week and its SDK slightly longer.

The clearest demonstration of the danger of fragmentation isn’t how well the iPhone 4S sold, but how many customers jumped to a malicious app recently released.

Netflix needs a strong DRM platform to deliver content and said that Android’s fragmentation made this incredibly hard to build. Netflix finally got its app out to some Android devices recently ‘ first in May with five devices and then a slow and unpredictable rollout to a few more over the following months. Then an app for most devices popped up and people flocked to it in troves. This app was a fake and stole many users’ personal and billing information. Even Symantec attributed this to problems getting the real app to handsets in a timely manner.

Google’s Eric Schmidt promised that Ice Cream Sandwich (4.0) would be the great Android version that would bring unity to device makers’ spec sheets for devices, so future updates would be easier and available for all users.

If that sounds familiar, it’s exactly the same thing we heard with Honeycomb (3.0). Not only were developers told that Honeycomb would fix problems for existing tablets but would require certain hardware and software sets to make future tablets better. Let’s not forget to mention that Google also said it planned to develop a smartphone iteration of Honeycomb to bridge the gap between tablets and smartphones ‘ Google did do this with Android 4.0 but the smartphone-bridge was promised before Android 3.2 was released this July.

Unfortunately for Google, the consensus among developers is that Honeycomb furthered fragmented. Part of this was due to early tablets running Android 2.1 and being very limited, part due to Honeycomb’s problems and the final part due to many Honeycomb tablets being unfinished, uninspired products that just took up shelf space.

Ice Cream Sandwich may make things worse if Google continues to see a slow update for existing devices. Having that serious of a rollout issue would mean four or five versions of Android will be running on popular devices while they all could support a single OS version.

Google has promised that the first updates will begin within ‘weeks,’ but the company has no credibility here so many users and journalists are expecting their updates to be months away.

The other issue is apps for 4.0. Google has the architecture in it to support apps that can determine screen size and do some adjusting for the device they’re on, but don’t expect most to do that. Not only are such adjustments difficult, but Google has said they’re not needed. Google’s Android boss Andy Rubin told ThisIsMyNext that ‘the Twitter phone app runs fine on a tablet’ and many others won’t need updates. Unfortunately for Google and its customers, apps made for smartphones hardly ever look good on tablets because of stretching and unused space. A mental shift needs to happen, but it may have to come from developers first.

So far, Ice Cream Sandwich supports a single mobile phone. Google’s Gary Cohen said the new OS version is ‘theoretically compatible’ with any device running Android 2.3 or later, but Google’s developer services highly advise against loading the 4.0 code on any such device. No worries there though, since the full source code is likely going to have a delayed release as Google promises to make it available once all devices are updated to 4.0.

Android also has another problem related to updates, they consistently harm devices. We used a Droid X for our testing of Android apps up until the end of last month, so we ended up visiting the Motorola Owners’ Forum quite often to report issues, look for fixes and make sure we weren’t the only one in a rant-worthy mood.

Gingerbread, remember it launched in December 2010, hit our device in June 2011 and initially crippled it. A few factory resets and lots of tinkering later we got the device up and running again, but working out all the kinks on our own took weeks.

Some of the problems we and others encountered include (courtesy of the Owner’s Forum):
– Mobiles randomly rebooting throughout the day when Gingerbread 2.3.3 automatically installed.
– Mobiles potentially restarting after being turned off.
– Battery-saver options actually used up more battery due to phones restarting, programs locking up instead of closing and other apps being activated.
– Devices repeatedly froze up on the welcome screen, but users had to remove the battery to be able to reset them.
– 3G connectivity disappeared or was dramatically reduced. For us, this was the reason for multiple factory resets.
– Phone calls would not end unless the device was powered off ‘ this occurred even when the other party ended the call.
– If called during listening to or leaving voicemails, the new call would automatically be answered.

The Android Market has reached a milestone by reaching the 500,000 submitted apps mark, research firm Research2Guidance (R2G) said in a new report. While this is still behind Apple’s 600,000, it is a good sign for Android. The only issue it has to contend with is that it doesn’t curate and approve apps, so some may say that Apple’s approval process is a better protection system.

The news gets even better as ABI Research said that Android has surpassed iOS in terms of monthly downloads as of Q2 2011. Android accounted for 44% of mobile app downloads while iOS accounted for only 31%.

‘Android’s open source strategy is the main factor for its success,’ said ABI’s Lim Shiyang. ‘Being a free platform has expanded the Android device install base, which in turn has driven growth in the number of third party multi-platform and mobile operator app stores. These conditions alone explain why Android is the new leader in the mobile application market.’
R2G also looked at developers for the different platforms and found that Android developers are more prolific, averaging six apps published to the Android Market. The average iOS developer has only added four apps.

In August, R2G predicted that Android will catch up to the App Store in the number of submitted apps by the end of 2011, and the company did not revise that prediction now.

Just as a quick note, this is for apps submitted not necessarily apps with staying power. As of September, 37% of all apps on the Android market had been removed at one point, Apple’s App Store had a 24% return-to-sender rate. This gives Apple about 140,000 more active apps than Android but it has at least a year’s head start.

– Android smartphone shipments increased to 36% of the global market in Q2, up from Q1’s 20%.
– iOS devices were only 9% of shipments in Q2, down from Q1’s 15%.
– Global app downloads for 2011 are expected to reach 29 billion, and Amazon should be able to keep the lion’s share of that.

Google owns lots of stuff and it also helps develop lots of other stuff, but so far leveraging some of these brands and services has been tough. Google has done a great job with its Google-branded apps on smartphones but its other platforms aren’t doing well.

Our disappointment with the beta version of Google TV being sold to the public is pretty obvious, but a recent goof made our blood boil when looking at Google TV and Android.

Logitech is prepping the next round of its Revue with Google TV, featuring an updated version of Google TV (originally expected in September but so far a no-show). The company has accidently had some of its new devices (or at least new boxes) hit shelves with a sticker that reads: ‘New & Improved. Google TV now with Android 3.1 and Android Market.’

Logitech said it’s a stick that’s only on boxes, not necessarily a new product, so this appears to be an update for the device. We’ve searched our brains not come up with a single reason that this should not have Android 4.0. Not a single one.

If, according to Google, any Android device that has hardware to run 2.3.3 and up can run Android 4.0, there’s no way the Logitech Revue can’t handle 4.0 so there’s no reason not to have it. Ice Cream Sandwich was previewed in May, so Logitech should have had plenty of time to test it and make a good build for its Revue.

Google has setup its Google+ social network to allow for amazing interactions, content sharing and even sharing MP3 through some features that will soon be extended to Google Music. That’s a platform whose usage numbers are dropping faster than Netflix subscribers. In many countries, Android is the most popular smartphone platform. This would be like Facebook slowly upgrading its main service and giving priority to the ‘poke’ feature’s development.

Here’s an odd thought, Microsoft isn’t as upset as you’d think when users buy Android mobiles, they like it a lot more than when people buy iOS devices.
The reason for that is Microsoft collects licensing fees on 50% of Android devices available. Charts that Microsoft made available after a recent licensing deal show that 55% of Android devices (when measuring by global revenue) fall under its licensing deals and that 53% of purchased Androids in the US are models that Microsoft makes money off of.

While this is said to typically be between $2 and $10 per device, Microsoft is raking in hundreds of millions of dollars each quarter without selling a single product of its own. These dollars also came at zero current development expenses to Microsoft.

Walter Isaacson’s biography of Steve Jobs mentions Android a lot, with Jobs never being fond of the rival believed to be a ‘stolen product.’ The book quotes Jobs saying, ‘We thought about whether we should do a music client for Android. We put iTunes on Windows in order to sell more iPods. But I don’t see an advantage of putting our own music app on Android, except to make Android users happy. And I don’t want to make Android users happy.’

After the 2010 launch of HTC’s Android smartphone lineup, Jobs allegedly said he’d work to crush the theft of Apple’s innovation: ‘I will spend every penny of Apple’s $40 billion in the bank to right this wrong. I’m going to destroy Android, because it’s a stolen product. I’m willing to go to thermonuclear war on this.’
Apple is sticking to these guns; just ask Samsung and its Galaxy line of smartphones and tablets that are in courts all over the world.
The worst news is that now Apple will be coming for every single Android device under the sun. Every single one.

Apple has been awarded a patent for the ‘unlock gesture’ used to get access to your smartphone by a swipe of the finger. Yeah, it’s the gesture that you use to unlock your smartphone, whether it is an iOS, Android or recent BlackBerry.

Patent 8,046,721 is for ‘A device with a touch-sensitive display may be unlocked via gestures performed on the touch-sensitive display. The device is unlocked if contact with the display corresponds to a predefined gesture for unlocking the device. The device displays one or more unlock images with respect to which the predefined gesture is to be performed in order to unlock the device. The performance of the predefined gesture with respect to the unlock image may include moving the unlock image to a predefined location and/or moving the unlock image along a predefined path. The device may also display visual cues of the predefined gesture on the touch screen to remind a user of the gesture.’
The patent appears to cover a gesture to unlock phones, an image to explain to users how to unlock their phones by gesture, an image telling users they need to unlock their phones in general and any visual cues needed to remind users which way the gesture goes.

Yes, that’s every smartphone maker around the world cringing right about now.
Android needs some patent protection and some innovation of its own, and quick. While all the other issues may just limit the beautiful side of Android that arrived with 4.0, it’ll be patents and royalties to Microsoft that bury Android and its devices deep in the ground.