Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

3 November 2011

LTE TV deployment accelerates as performance concerns subside

A recent TV over 4G LTE mobile network trial in the US appears to have shown that broadcast quality ‘HD like’ services can be delivered successfully at bit rates that are now becoming available. This should help allay concerns that even LTE may not provide enough bandwidth for HD services. There are however a number of caveats. Firstly we should note use of the phrase ‘HD like’, which implies that the trial delivered an acceptable Quality of Experience to small devices including smartphones and possibly tablets, but not necessarily good enough for big screens.

Small devices are much more forgiving, with greater tolerance among users for observable artifacts and glitches such as frozen frames. So while the trial may represent a step forward for mobile TV, it does not establish that LTE can yet provide an alternative transmission medium to satellite, digital terrestrial, cable or IPTV for primary TV services.

The trial by MobiNet, a new business unit of Texas based Etex Telephone Cooperative (based in Texas), demonstrated the “HD-like” broadcast television, VOD and over-the-top TV, at mobile broadband speeds from 3 Mbps upwards. It used US TV over IP vendor Minerva’s xTVFusion 5 for Broadband TV platform, exploiting adaptive streaming to improve the consistency of service. The trial does represent an important step forward for mobile TV, not least because so far bit rates achieved by LTE services have often been disappointing and failed to match theoretical predictions. But if 3 Mbps is enough, then perhaps LTE will not have to come up to scratch, although even then there is the issue of backhaul.

Indeed ever since the first commercial LTE service launch by Swedish operator TeliaSonera in central parts of Stockholm and Oslo early in 2010, real download speeds have fallen well below the hype, although this is also true of most fixed line broadband services. TeliaSonera wisely declined to get into arguments about bit rates at the time, although perhaps in that case should not have made so much of the promise of ‘up to 50 Mbps’ download speeds. In practice this was rarely approached.

More recently in May 2011 the UK regulator Ofcom said it believes LTE will deliver 3.3 times more spectral efficiency in its first generation and 5.5 times by 2020, pointing out that this would still not be enough to meet increased capacity demands, without other measures, such as making cells smaller. Since then some surveys have found that so far spectral efficiency improvements achieved by LTE can be as little as 1.5 compared with UMTS.

But this is all right in the sense that LTE was always intended as an evolution that will deliver progressive improvements, and is not just about headline access speeds. AT&T is demonstrating this with its LTE roll out in the US, which is increasing throughput and picture quality for existing 3G phones, such as Apple’s iPhone 3GS, as well as new LTE handsets. This is because AT&T’s enhanced backhaul infrastructure for the 4G LTE also serves the existing HSPA (High Speed Packet Access) 3G service. While an LTE phone is needed to exploit the additional spectral efficiencies, these are as we have suggested, fairly slight at the moment, so that greater performance improvements are being achieved as a result of the new backhaul infrastructure. Perhaps AT&T has learnt from its ‘iMess’ saga of early 2010 when its network was brought its knees by proliferation of data generated by iPhones. This was a comeuppance for AT&T, which had been delighted to secure exclusive rights to the iPhone in the US only to find itself unable to cope with the deluge of data.

Now it is pursuing a more cautious approach to LTE roll out, having just expanded LTE coverage from five to nine US regions taking in Athens, GA, Baltimore, Boston, and Washington D.C, in addition to the larger cities of Atlanta, Chicago, Dallas-Fort Worth, Houston and San Antonio already covered. AT&T plans to bring on six more metropolitan areas by the end of 2011. At the same time the carrier is now introducing its first 4G LTE phones, the HTC Vivid and Samsung Galaxy S II Skyrocket. This comes at a time when the range of available LTE capable handsets is increasing rapidly, according to research just published by the Global mobile Suppliers Association (GSA). Now there are 27 different LTE smart phones, three times as many as three months ago.

While momentum does seem to be growing behind LTE for mobile TV, we are still a long way from global unanimity in this area where various initially promising standards have already come and gone. Only Korea and Japan can so far be said to have made a success of mobile TV, but this has been via satellite and digital terrestrial transmission. Meanwhile cellular TV standards have flopped elsewhere, notably DVB-H in Europe, and MediaFLO in the US. Even now it is by no means clear whether Europe will rally behind LTE or whether digital terrestrial will be adopted at least in some countries, for transmission to mobile devices. Such doubts have been amplified by the warm welcome accorded to the T2 Lite mobile broadcast standard unveiled in July 2011 as a stripped down version of the DVB-T2 second generation digital terrestrial standard, which is likely to be adopted in Europe as well as in parts of Asia and Africa.

The T2-Lite profile, included in Version 1.3.1 of the DVB-T2 specification document, is designed specifically for smaller handheld receivers rather than TVs, and for low capacity applications, in particular mobile broadcasting. This has been accomplished by avoiding modes that require the greatest processing complexity and memory, so that T2-Lite receivers can be constructed from smaller lower power chipsets that can be embedded into smart phones and tablets. Power saving is achieved by exploiting the T2 bandwidth to package signals up in bursts rather than continuous transmissions, reducing battery consumption. Above all, T2 Lite works within existing broadcast spectrum, and can be delivered alongside TV services as part of DVB-T2 deployments, requiring only small changes to existing DVB-T2 modems.

So while the US is now steering a clear course towards LTE, the future of mobile TV in Europe is still uncertain, like so much else in the continent.