If anyone thought that the intellectual property player Cryptography Research Inc (CRI) would harmlessly rest on its considerable laurels after it was sold to Rambus, they have another think coming ‘ instead it has contented itself with virtually single handedly revolutionizing conditional access and DRM.
Founder Paul Kocher this week told us how the ST Micro 7108, ARM based set top superchip and the new generation of Broadcom 74XX top of the range HD set top chips, have both included a cryptographic hardware design from CRI which is designed to be used to entirely replace smart cards in conditional access systems. While Kocher says that doesn’t mean that Smart Cards will disappear, it certainly will eliminate most of the problems associated with them such as Control Word Sharing, which has undermined even hardware based conditional access systems over the past five years or so.
This achievement is remarkable more because CRI has convinced the two largest SoC set top chip makers (it will need to also convince Sigma and perhaps Intel to nail the whole sector) to embrace the design, rather than the cryptographic expertise that is embedded in the core.
There are probably a handful of other organizations which might have designed such a core, but CRI designs have been in play since 2002 and so far have never been ultimate compromised (broken) ‘ stretching from its famous Differential Power Analysis countermeasures and self-protecting digital content which is the basis of the most effective of the three piracy defenses in Blu-ray chips (that technology was recently sold to Rovi and then sold on to Irdeto) .
DPA involves monitoring the fluctuating electrical power consumption of smart cards and other secure cryptographic devices, to give clues to how the cryptographic engine works in order to find cryptographic keys. This is defeated with dummy power surges designed to confuse DPA hacking attempts, effectively random electrical noise. Today this system is featured on 5 billion chipsets, used to protect smart cards in financial, pay TV, mass transit, secure ID, handset and other industries.
CRI was sold earlier this year for $342.5 million to Rambus, a company that has turned into something of a patent holding company. Rambus made its name in RAM memory, but has become a patent holder in memory technology. We said at the time that some of the CRI assets related to video steam protection for pay TV in its CryptoFirewall core.
But we had no idea that the 6 year effort to bring this technology to market was finally going to make an emergence among the SoC chips which handle HD video in set tops.
The core designs were given away for free to Broadcom and ST Micro and as software is downloaded and used which can switch on the cryptographic engine inside, CRI will get a royalty of $1 a time. ‘This is much less than the cost of putting in a new Smart Card in a set top,’ says Kocher, the chip itself is about $1 to make and then it has to be embedded in a card, and delivered and later it may need to be replaced.
His argument, and it appears to have been persuasive, is that a smart card has to send a control word to the set top processor, and initially this wasn’t even encrypted, later it has been encrypted for the short hop around the device, but is still easily available for scrutiny by pirates due to the interconnection.
A control word is really the decryption key to a brief amount of content that is contained in what is called a crypto-period ‘ usually in pay TV a period of around 10 seconds of video, perhaps 300 to 600 frames. This key is actually sent at the front of the period, with the content, but is encrypted. On most set tops it has to be decrypted by the smart card and sent back to the decoder unit in the set top, because it is going to be used to decode the content.
Modern ‘trusted’ set top boxes all re-encrypt the control word internally for these short hops, but some older devices don’t. It is much easier to intercept a decrypted control word (sometimes called an entitlement message) than it is to actually break the decoding algorithm on a smart card.
Organized pirates then set up networks where perhaps a group of devices intercept the control word and in just a few milliseconds send it around the world over the internet. It has even been found rebroadcast on satellites, so that duplicate set tops can be set up to receive both the encrypted content and the ever changing illegal control word in two parallel streams. It featured at last year’s IBC as the major hurdle that conditional access firms were facing. involving 100,000s of devices. ‘In parts of the Far East,’ said Kocher, ‘there are 10 pirate devices to every paying subscriber.’
Other conditional access players, for instance Viaccess, introduced ways around the broadcast of control words last year, in particular binding a unique identity number on the smart card to the decrypted control word. When it then found this in the wild it could then either use it to identify the particular set top it came from and revoke its licenses virtually in real time, or lead Interpol to their door. The arrival of SoCs with this security core inside will almost certainly kill off the need for that kind of ‘ad hoc’ real time defense, but only once all older style devices are eliminated from pay TV networks, which could take 5 years or so. Of course these devices can have HD or early exploitation movie services denied to them immediately which creates a motive to upgrade.
The CryptoFirewall uses a robust, state of the art decryption process, not dissimilar to PKI (Private Key Infrastructure) complete with the DPA counter measures. All video is decrypted inside the CryptoFirewall and no keys ever leave it.
‘Movies are moving to pay TV services closer to the theatrical exploitation window and closer to the theatrical price, and for that you need a strong security system. The CryptoFirewall will be able to protect HD content even if it comes out on the same day that movies go into cinemas,’ said Kocher.
Kocher only highlighted the fact that these chips are embedded with his security cores as part of an announcement that IPTV Conditional Access player Verimatrix, has licensed the technology. This will enable Verimatrix to offer its own DRM/CA powered by the core already resident on these chips. It is likely that many, if not all of the major DRM firms, will eventually license this technology.
‘This deal with Verimatrix will allow them to achieve the kind of content protection that a smart card would bring, but at a much lower price,’ Kocher said.
But as Tablets are becoming one of the key targets for video consumption, surely the conditional access system needs to extend to these as well?
Kocher confirmed that discussions are continuing with other set top chip makers and reluctantly confirmed that he was in advanced discussions with providers or Applications Processors for tablets and smart phones. We would assume by that he means Qualcomm, Nvidia and Marvel who are thinking about licensing the core, although we think it is unlikely that Apple would do so ‘ not unless it had already provided a competitive edge for rivals. As Tablets come to handle HD video content, Hollywood is going to insist that content protection is hardware based, not simply using code Obfuscation and authentication seen in software hardened, downloadable DRMs.
‘Most Over The Top content is low value, low resolution content,’ said Kocher, ‘streaming below the current DVD quality. Once this content is pushed to a software only protected device it could theoretically be stolen.’
Of course today the approved way of sharing content from an encrypted pay TV broadcast to a tablet, is using DTCP-IP, which is perfectly capable of protecting the stream itself, as long as DTCP-IP is not compromised, where it is processed, at either end. This is why Hollywood is trying to say that hardware protection is required to send DTCP-IP streams. However there have been a host of product announcements ignoring this fact, and there will be more at IBC, so right now the software fortification and hardening processes seem to have come into their own for these implementations.
But if the SOCs for these devices had a secure on-board secret crypto core inside them, then high value HD content could find its way to these devices – without Hollywood getting upset.
‘Content piracy and theft of service are major commercial concerns for our system operator customers, as well as the community of content owners. We are continually evolving our layered approach to embedded security to stay ahead of potential attacks,’ said Tom Munro, CEO at Verimatrix. ‘Cryptography Research’s technologies have an excellent reputation for securing content, and the CryptoFirewall core complements and reinforces Verimatrix’s full range of revenue security solutions.’
The CryptoFirewall is also available as an ASIC chip to offload security processing.
We think it’s smart that Verimatrix has embraced this approach, and we’ve known for some time that it has been jealous of the lead that traditional conditional access players have had by using smart cards, but it felt it never wanted to go down that route.
For someone as knowledgeable about cryptography to display such confidence as Kocher has in this new system, saying it represents a lot more than a speed bump, and is more of brick wall for piracy, is impressive. It is not the only secure IP core to focus on security, but the others on the market don’t have the impressive background and the SoC partnerships that this has. Which is what may lead it into a massive win and an entire market change.
We thought that perhaps companies like NDS and Nagravision would fight it tooth and claw, but Kocher doesn’t think so. ‘If there’s a piece of extra security on the processor, those companies will use it. They may continue to use their own smart cards, or use this on its own, or both within a single network. ‘There’s a lot more to conditional access provision than managing cryptographic keys, such as all the integration work they do,’ said Kocher, ‘and I think these organizations will continue to find ways to differentiate themselves and still use the CryptoFirewall if it’s there.’
This is one area where we would not agree with him. As these set top chips deploy in bulk and other chip players come on board, this will commoditize content protection. Differentiation will be harder and price will come into it more and more. This core of CRI’s has been built so that it can support multiple different software applications, for multiple services ‘ it basically is an offload region of the chip for all things cryptographic. From the cryptographic point of view this is built so that no service can interfere with another service on the chip, but if it turns out that an operator say 5 years from now can switch out his conditional access supplier overnight by downloading new apps in parallel to the existing DRM apps, then this will make a DRM lock-in impossible to sustain. And all that will compress margins and force conditional access firms to create new, additional revenue and product lines in order to preserve their business.
We have seen this already in the emerging strategies of both Nagra and NDS but also all the smaller DRM suppliers. So at the very least it is unlikely that Tablets will never have the same DRM service lock-ins that set tops have suffered from, at least once more key chip players agree to go down this route.