Sigma Designs, one of the keenest protagonists in the home networking war, has chosen IBC to lay claim to the high ground in HomePlug AV chips, eschewing for a moment its constant push behind G.hn to remind the world that it is also a major HomePlug player.
Sigma acquired Coppergate, one of the key designers and chip players of HPNA back in 2009, seen more or less as one predecessor to G.hn. But it also bought the Conexant’s HomePlug division over two years ago, giving it a stake in both camps.
Qualcomm Atheros, which acquired the most active chip vendor in the HomePlug space, Intellon, also two years ago, has recently been aggressive in the HomePlug market, launching its 7400 chip and also making claims that it is (almost) as good already as G.hn, and trying to sideline the G.hn technology.
One way this has been done is to use IEEE voting power to ensure that the P1905.1 standard for making multiple home networks work alongside one another, does not include G.hn. This standard allows swapping of packets from one network to another and back again by building an abstraction layer which effectively makes it possible for a home network to route over HomePlug, Ethernet, WiFi or MoCA.
The success of sidelining G.hn out of this standard, at least for now, has perhaps invigorated Sigma’s interest in HomePlug.
Regardless of the motivation, Sigma reckons it has now trumped the Atheros 7400, which claims a 500 Mbps PHY, and is close to a year old. Curiously the 7400 deliberately opted to use some spectrum above the 30 MHz bandwidth which most HomePlug players use, which is how it gets much of its 500 Mbps claim. The Atheros aim was clearly to convince operators that the step to G.hn is too risky, it’s new, and for those who have an investment in HomePlug, it’s a complete technology swap out.
The Atheros 7400 uses 75 MHz of bandwidth which means that all the performance from 30 to 75 MHz of spectrum is incompatible with HomePlug AV devices and all the performance from 50 to 75 MHz is incompatible with most P1901 devices. P1901 is a new standard for HomePlug and it has a charter to use spectrum all the way up to 100 MHz but most device makers haven’t explored the higher spectrum areas as yet.
Sigma now tells us that some of the regulator imposed power requirements, in Europe in particular, means that any the device using this extra spectrum offers little more than a 200 Mbps PHY HomePlug device using just 30 MHz and has proceeded to work strictly within the original HomePlug AV spec to show that it can perform just as well, if not better.
The new Sigma chip is its CG2210, built in 65 nanometer process, and half the package size of previous Sigma Homeplug chips. As we say it operates at a 200 Mbps PHY, but Michael Weissman, Vice President, Corporate Marketing at Sigma says it offers a 15% throughout improvement over its own previous chips.
The power consumption has dropped from 1 watts to 0.4 watts, adhering to the stringent new EuP 2013 energy conservation guidelines and the chip supports TR69, which is a an increasingly well-established remote management protocol. The CG2210 significantly reduces the bill of materials says Weissman,
‘When we use Clearpath with this chip (the MIMO version which uses all three power cables simultaneously) it runs over 70% more outlets and runs 31% faster over surge protectors versus competitors.’ The reference is oblique but we’re sure by competitors he is referring to the Atheros 7400 chip set.
‘In the real world we measure how good a Homeplug chip is by how fast it goes when attached to all the power outlets in a home. This chip will offer 20 Mbps on 70% more outlets than our closest rival (Atheros).’ When Clearpath is added that number skyrockets says Weissman.
Other advantages Sigma says the CG2200 has over other HomePlug AV chips is that they work faster when handling small packets, giving lower latency, which it suggests is good for gaming apps in the home.
‘The rival Atheros 7400 is supposed to be a 500 Mbps chip, but when we tested this against the CG2200, in 75% of outlets it outperformed it and in 10% it equaled it. The extra bandwidth which the 7400 uses doesn’t buy them much, mostly due to power regulations. And anyway it’s very hard to combine high bandwidth with high signal strength.’
Atheros takes the position very publicly that there are lots of existing customers for HomePlug technologies and G.hn offers no upgrade path to allow co-existence with HomePlug on the same power grid. It cites operators such as France Telecom, and Iliad’s Free in France and Deutsche Telekom in Germany, who all use HomePlug to deliver IPTV. It’s hard to ask customers of these throw away their existing home network. Which is perhaps why Sigma has chosen to re-iterate its position in both camps. This way Sigma has shot at those customers as well, but does Atheros have a shot at the merging G.hn markets? Not yet it doesn’t.
We can’t see much wrong with the Sigma approach of keeping a foot in both camps, although it might confuse the odd potential G.hn prospect, which is very much seen as a three way technology, travelling over powerline, coax and twisted pair, and as for talk about being able to co-exist in HomePlug markets Weissman has an answer.
‘Homeplug has 0% market share in China, and so does G.hn, so it’s a level playing field and China Telecom has already had its own G.hn plugfest. The Chinese may decide to hijack G.hn and make it their own. We already have Metanoia and Xingtera there making G.hn chips.’
So HomePlug for HomePlug markets and G.hn for brand new markets isn’t such a crazy strategy, although neither side would suggest that this is straightforward. HPNA customers have to have somewhere to go and the likely destination is G.hn, with potentially a few desertions to a revitalized HomePlug camp.