Throughout IBC we had multiple discussions about our lead article two weeks ago that Cryptography Research has managed to get its CryptoFirewall onto two of the families of major set top chips, those from Broadcom and from ST Micro.
Broadcom tried to intimate that it has had 85 different security blocks and that they come and go. We don’t think so and we checked around with a few specialists who told us that there are quite a few hardware sub-blocks involved in SoCs’ security areas, but that these components aren’t analogous to what Cryptography Research has added, both in terms of what the blocks do or what it means to the market.
These security blocks fall into a couple of categories, for instance security encryption accelerators for a range of algorithms such as AES, 3DES, DVB, but this is just because software can’t easily keep up with the speeds involved in video decryption. This doesn’t actually provide any protection from attacks to the chip, they just help boost performance.
The other category are blocks placed there by major CA providers such as NDS and Nagra. But these only protect a single system and are proprietary and no-one else can trigger them except those companies. We have no knowledge of how powerful these are, but surely if they were as powerful as the secure execution environment that Cryptography Research has put onboard, then why would those two companies have continued for so long with smart cards, since they wouldn’t need them.
A few other vendors also have proprietary elements such as the Intel Insider which unlocks Blu Ray HD content on its Sandy Bridge family of chips, but once again, this isn’t something which is openly pushed so that operators can build their own service around it.
What the CRI engine does is allow all of the set top SoC chips to offer the same features so any set top maker, any DRM and operator can use them.
On the SoC’s which the CRI cores are on, there are two separate OTP (one time programmable) blocks, one for the CryptoFirewall and one for everything else. In short this is the only system we’ve heard of where you can still have the protection and still have a choice of DRMs and a choice of SoCs. And that’s what we found so significant.
Meanwhile this week DivX has also said that its DivX Plus streaming feature, for DVD quality streaming, has also been included on the same Broadcom SoCs and was on show at IBC on the Rovi stand. As we remember it, the DivX streaming is based on a third party streamer from Bluestreak, so surely it’s the Bluestreak technology that’s on the chip (someone correct us if we’re wrong here).
‘Broadcom’s plan to integrate DivX Plus Streaming emphasizes the flexibility of our embedded streaming solution, which is designed for easy implementation on a broad range of platforms,’ said Corey Ferengul, EVP Products at Rovi. The company says that it’s based on a flexible DRM framework, but we think that means that it uses Microsoft PlayReady under license ‘ so not that flexible. Just how PlayReady will be secured on the chip, the company doesn’t say. It will offer electronic sell through, timed rentals or subscriptions, using streaming, downloads, and side-load transfer to enable both online and offline playback. It will certainly need some more security underneath PlayReady to make those activities safe, but it hasn’t said what. We’ll have to ask DivX.