Every time some companies make an announcement it is seen as bad news. Sometimes, for instance in the case of Apple, every time it makes an announcement, it is seen as good news. Neither are ever right, but there is a prevailing attitude, mostly among the individuals writing about it, which is sometimes also reflected among customers, that the negative slant is the only one worth picking out. That has become the ‘raison d”tre’ of all Netflix explanations of late.
And so Netflix is now widely seen as having failed already, or at least having a number of large obstacles to overcome.
So this week’s apology, and deeper explanation by the CEO Reed Hastings, along with the statement that Netflix will be renaming its DVD Rentals business as ‘Qwikster’ has been rapidly rounded on by consumers and commentators alike and investors continue to bail out of the stock.
What can we say? If investors keeping leaving the stock and commentators keep writing off the company, then it can be a self-fulfilling prophecy, but unless the company leadership begins to doubt itself and begins to reverse these decisions, there is unlikely to be any major customer fall off.
What Netflix needs to do right now is to continue to lead the debate about online movie viewing. It should keep all announcements to the signing of new content (see Worth Noting below) or new target device platforms and keep out of talking about the price rises, which serve only to remind everyone that Netflix took a price gamble back in July.
We all know that particular story, it’s been covered to death, as has the item about renegotiating the Starz movie contracts, even as Starz renegotiates its deal with Disney and Sony, for the supply of its movies.
Consumers have a choice. They can continue to get their VoD in a regulated environment, for instance from a cable company, over its QAM network, with all the restrictions of choice, and the payment terms that implies, or they can adopt the open internet streaming approach of Netflix and what is rapidly becoming a legion of would be Netflix’s.
Let’s look for a second about why Netflix won the Online DVD rentals war in the first place. First off, it came up with the idea, but more importantly it focused on the quality of its service deliverables. It wanted to get movies to customers quickly, it wanted to give them their choices, not just in a haphazard fashion, but in the order that they were chosen, it kept up its content purchases when all related rival businesses slowed them down. In other words it got where it was today by putting the customer first, and had to withstand the ordeal of being a lowly valued stock, with a low margin, because it appeared to be a business which was easy to copy and which did not really work without significant momentum. Nothing much on that front has changed.
It may have lost 53% of its share value, from a high when it was worth $15.4 billion at the end of July, to $7.24 billion today, but it has barely lost a customer so far, and each one of them is paying anything from the same, to 60% more in monthly fees.
US culture loves value for money. US people will drop one supplier for another, if the service and choice appear to be the same and the price is even a little bit lower, and the investor thinking is that US consumers are only at the start of cutting the Netflix cord, when two months ago everyone had been saying that it was the phenomena that was Netflix which made everyone consider cutting the cord with pay TV operators. Let’s face it, it’s quite hard for both of these to be true and there are fresh reports out this week saying that cord cutting is going to accelerate in the US. Netflix already had 24.5 million US customers and will still have 24 million by the end of the quarter (despite being misquoted by everyone saying that it has lost 1 million customers, it hasn’t, it’s lost 500,000).
With that many existing customers, even if someone emerges who offers a deal as good as Netflix had for the past two years, despite the fact that nobody has been able to so far, and even if that company could grow at the 3 million a quarter, the same kind of rate that Netflix grew at, it would take about two years before anyone has close to the number of subscribers that Netflix has. If you are going to cut the cord right now it’s with Netflix and possibly with Hulu as well, but it’s not with someone else. At the very worst a second placed online offering will be complementary to Netflix, not instead of, among probably 50% of new subscribers.
If you look at the Comcast figures to June it jumped its average revenue per household to $138 from $126, a jump of $12 and yet the US is ‘outraged’ by Netflix charging $8 for online, instead of $9 for both online and DVD rental, despite the fact that DVD rental was already falling off a cliff of its own accord. And let’s face it, if you cut $138 from your Comcast bill each month by cutting the cord, you have a lot of money to play with for new services ‘ Netflix is going to be at least one of them.
At Netflix DVD choices were more than 100,000 and online was growing rapidly but was last reported at 20,000 (so let’s say is around 35,000 today). DVDs offer far more choice, but the spontaneity of online was making them irrelevant. So a rise of $8, which is expected to make 10 million Netflix homes go to online only (so no rise) should be compared with Comcast’s increase in ARPU of $12, much of which is created by being the only broadband game in town and through price increases, not new service options being taken up by customers.
At Comcast they are charging $12 more and giving similar services to before, at Netflix they are charging $8 more, but you don’t have to keep that service. Meanwhile Netflix spent $612 million last quarter alone on making more online content available. But we are not seeing the knives out for Comcast (any worse than usual) despite the fact that its video revenues now make up 53% of its revenues, whereas a year ago they made up 55%. Investors don’t see the larger picture here.
Be that as it may, Neflix does not have a triple play, and if it loses too many customers this gives rise to the idea that it might even run out of money. If it needs investors to offer it debt or raised equity, in order to continue, that may be extremely expensive under current investor sentiment.
The issue is that not only the Starz deal, but all the other content deals it has, may need to be renewed, and all the studios out there feel cheated by Netflix, which got its content too cheaply last time. This is an important point. Netflix has always said that it expects to pay more for any content deal that it renews. But investors and commentators all seem to be thinking that this negotiation is one sided, which of course it’s not.
Which argument would be the more powerful aimed at you. ‘I am going to cut you off from all our lovely content unless you pay me ten times as much’ or ‘I have 24 million customers in the US, and more overseas, and if you don’t give me the content at rock bottom prices I shall feed them someone else’s content.’
The truth is that US studios have to charge everyone the same for their content, or they would be accused, as they have been many times in the past, of anti-trust. There IS a basis for charging Netflix less than anyone else, because of its dominant online video market share, there is NOT a basis for charging it more. Studios must be very careful here. They have tried to set the price for online movies in the past, and it has led to no-one watching them except pirates. The Netflix deal with Starz has led to Sony getting upset and telling Starz that it has had all the online deliveries that its contract allows for. Starz never expected to be in that position, and Sony never expected to feel that low resolution, low priced, online deals would threaten its DVD revenues ‘ but they have.
So sure there is an opportunity to renegotiate the price, but that renegotiation is for everyone. This is not a matter of replacing Netflix with someone they like better who will continue to go to market at a lower price than Netflix. The studios are annoyed that Netflix was SO low priced. Payments to studios will come up, but if they make Netflix raise its customer prices once more (and this entire price dispute at Netflix can be laid at the door of the studios, for making it clear that they were fed up with Netflix having a ‘free ride’ on Starz), then the studios will do what they are so good at, raising the pricing on ‘old’ movies which are mostly beyond their exploitation phases, and killing another golden goose.
If the prices are too high for Netflix, then no-one who has NOT got 24 million customers is going to be able to put a subscription out for the same price, unless it is a gamble. Blockbuster, under new ownership may match the price, but it won’t be able to beat it, and even then it will have to subsidize pricing while it ramps its numbers.
What the studios CAN do is try to license as many other suppliers as possible so that Netflix does have competition, but this in itself is likely to fall fowl of at least two things ‘ confusion in the market with a proliferation of services ‘ that will work in the favor of the biggest brand ‘ which here is Netflix; and the fact that Netflix has shown in the past that it is customer oriented and will just do a better job.
We understand that Rovi is in this market and can offer the Sonic Solutions RoxioNow white label store and has done so for many larger brands, and that its subsidiary DivX now uses Microsoft Playready DRM along with BlueStreak’s MachBlue steaming system, with a number of its content partners and offers white label systems, including some content, through a number of the SmartTV suppliers including LG and Samsung. Rovi didn’t spend $720 million to snap up Sonic Solutions without it planning to go into the online movie business aggressively and Bluestreak is known to be powering up a number of international operators, as well as Time warner cable’s OTT TV Everywhere service.
If you add to that the Apple and Amazon product lines, and what Blockbuster is promising to do, you might easily get the feeling that Netflix’ days are indeed numbered.
But all of this only means that there are fewer hurdles facing studio direct involvement in online movie services than when they introduced their own Movielink service, which was in fact the basis of the Sonic Solutions and Blockbuster stores as they are today (Blockbuster bought Movielink, and Sonic Solutions bought CinemaNow and merged the technology and rights platforms).
But if the US studios think that after ten years failing in online films they want to kill the only ever business that was successful in it, they are going to be sadly disabused, as the shadow of the anti-trust guillotine comes down on them.
Our own feeling is that Reed Hastings knows all this and that’s why he is adding more and more exclusive content rights. So Netflix is in a position to play hard ball when content owners come with their hand out demanding higher prices.
The sentiment is that the studios can play with whomever they want and that every studio is already playing around with end-running third party OTT aggregators as well as Pay TV operators ‘ as seen in experiments with delivering paid content on Facebook and in first run format on cable. Remember this is the tawdry end of the market, when films aren’t worth much, so studios can spend time working on getting more from movies up front. We have said we see Facebook (and Google+) as a potential replacements for the Cinema phase of movie exploitation as a launch platform for films ‘ but that is in an experimental stage right now, and there still remains no good reason to ruin Netflix in order to gain that.
In our view Starz has to renew with Netflix . There is no other game in town where it can get access to that many clients. It renews, or it loses revenues, and in turn the studios lose revenues which could be there for them.
But a deal with Starz no longer has to be exclusive for Netflix and that could potentially lower the price, not raise it.
As we say Netflix spent $612 million on licensing new content last quarter against $788 million of revenue. It has $376 million in the bank, no debt and it generated $86 million in cash from the business last quarter after buying back $51million in shares. You have to ask what the $612 million was spent on, and the answer is that it was a ton of exclusive material and although if it continues at that rate Netflix may well need more cash, anyone trying to compete with it will need that level of spend too ‘ say $3 billion a year on content. That cuts the field down a bit.
Finally everyone is now saying that because Netflix has separately named its Online DVD Rental business, that it must be preparing to divest it, even though it is openly and strongly saying that it won’t. In the end this is a US business and the streaming business is on the verge of going global and in order to pay for that global adventure all that Netflix has to do is deliver strong revenues next quarter and customer gains the quarter after that, and its share price will be more or less back on track.
The only thing that stands in the way of that is if Reed Hastings spends the next 6 months crying into his beer apologizing for this and that, when he should be boldly signing new content deals.