The concept of a decentralized internet has been pushed into the mainstream by the likes of HBO’s comedy show Silicon Valley and by Mozilla announcing a $2 million reward fund for any ideas that will bring the construct to life. The aim is to bring connectivity to deprived areas across the globe, while making bandwidth savings for OTT video providers.
With $2 million on the table, Mozilla has pointed to potential ideas like converting infrastructure such as old phone booths into WiFi hotspots. But what many aren’t aware of is that the technological foundations of this type of network are being developed and tweaked by start-up vendors which have already won deployments at some major media companies. Unfortunately for the vendors, the technology is called peer-to-peer (P2P) mesh networking, and that name has long since been tarnished by content pirates.
So when an email landed in the Faultline Online Reporter inbox from a small P2P CDN company called Peer5, claiming that Vivendi’s video sharing site Dailymotion was among its customers, we recalled that just two months ago another P2P provider had made the very same claim, a French OTT technology start up called Streamroot.
The two companies are direct competitors, but the method of using a serverless P2P CDN for delivering video means that a customer such as Vivendi can employ as many P2P vendors as it wants, or can afford, to manage.
Peer5’s Huan Le, who handles Business Development at the 5-year old firm, explained to us that there is no threat to Peer5’s deployment at Dailymotion, as both systems can sit on top of existing CDNs – adding more layers and therefore opening up additional lanes of traffic in peak times. It’s interesting then that Streamroot failed to mention this during our recent conversation, but the French firm has a bigger slice of Vivendi as it is handling CDN optimization of the CanalPlay SVoD service, as well as Dailymotion.
This global, serverless infrastructure works in the opposite way to a traditional CDN, in that it becomes more efficient at optimizing traffic during peak times.
If a million people are watching the same stream simultaneously, for example, Peer5 will group them into what the company calls “swarms,” with individuals in each swarm then distributing content between each other, each essentially mimicking a server, instead of all 1 million viewers making HTTP requests directly from the edge server and causing congestion. “No CDN in the world has a million servers, yet Peer5 has over a million,” said Le.
Le added that while Vivendi could indeed pull in some additional assistance, Peer5 and Streamroot are the only two P2P vendors in place at Dailymotion, for now. Le also revealed that parent company Vivendi runs an in-house CDN as well as using Limelight Networks, Level 3, and Verizon’s EdgeCast, and added that Dailymotion is more advanced than most streaming sites, as it has built an internal load balancing system for CDNs – allowing it to act as a sort of gatekeeper for how its content is delivered.
The main issue for vendors such as Peer5 is convincing major operators and media companies that P2P technology is perfectly safe, despite its reputation, as Le confirmed that prospective customers have many concerns that deploying a P2P infrastructure would lead to their own content being pirated.
Le said that because customers are already using traditional CDNs and are not replacing it with P2P networking, there is a multi-layer security approach already in place. All the geofencing, DRM, and encryption processes are agnostic – meaning nothing changes when technology from a company like Peer5 is brought in to do a job.
Peer5 and Streamroot are very similar, both offering P2P mesh technology based on the WebRTC (Real Time Communication) streaming protocol.
However, Le pointed out some differences between Peer5 and Streamroot. Streamroot told us its technology works by offloading most of the central management resources and workload to the end user, replacing it instead with a relatively small list of files and associated users. Le said Peer5 doesn’t offload resources, but as more users join a stream, there are simply more “swarm” permutations that it can create, giving it a better chance to optimize peers for any single viewer. End users simply continue to make HTTP requests for video segments as they did before Peer5’s implementation. Its client-side Javascript decides whether those requests can be fulfilled by another peer or should be proxied on to the HTTP server.
WebRTC is fine for browsers on desktop, with the additional boost of winning support for Apple’s Safari earlier this month, but the protocol has minimal support for mobile devices. To address this and keep up with industry trends, Peer5 is rolling out its iOS SDK in Q4 this year, to go with its existing Android SDK. Rival Streamroot also told us that it is planning to launch a mobile SDK later this year.
Unlike competitors in the space such as Streamroot, Peer5 doesn’t shy away from its routes by marketing itself as something different in an attempt to avoid being tarred with the same brush as the content pirates, such as distributed network architecture, which Le described as a euphemism.
Peer5 claims average bandwidth savings of 50%, but this figure can reach as high as 99% during major live events, while Streamroot claims to make savings of between 50% and 80%.
Peer 5 also boasts Sony as a customer, and investors include Foundry Group, Tank Hill Ventures, Hillsven, and Y Combinator. For an interesting live visualization of Peer5’s network in action, check out this link.