Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

21 June 2018

Disaster for Deutsche as disruptive StartTV canned

Even the greatest get it wrong sometimes. After just a year in operation, Deutsche Telekom has decided it’s curtains for the not-so-disruptive €2 a month disruptor IPTV offering called StartTV – summarizing a poor year for the German giant in all things video.

The 100-channel skinny bundle service, with a €2.95 a month set top rental fee, even came with a free one-year subscription attached – setting the stage for throwing the German TV market into disarray as Deutsche Telekom aggressively undercut everything else on the market.

So what went wrong? Deutsche Telekom is keeping tight lipped about StartTV’s failings, but we have reached out to Zenterio for any insights into the unexpected closure, the company which supplied the OS for StartTV and will provide an update if we receive a response. In the meantime, our best guess is that the operator entered a market already championed by Swiss internet TV service Zattoo, which has about 550,000 active subscribers in Germany, paying €9.99 a month, and 34 million monthly views on the ad-supported tier. Then there are the usual suspects of Netflix and Amazon.

Availability on multiple devices increases Zattoo’s reach considerably compared to StartTV, although there is also trouble in paradise at Zattoo, having recently pulled its direct to consumer operations from the UK, Spain and Denmark, leaving only its core markets of Germany and Switzerland.

Nevertheless, being forced to shutter StartTV after only 13 months is disastrous for Deutsche. The operator is probably scrambling to erase all trace of comments made by CEO Timotheus Höttges back in 2014, when he proclaimed the operator would reach 10 million video subscribers across TV, tablet and laptop by 2017 – a target which has been missed by 2.5 million with 3.2 million in Germany and 4.3 million outside it.

Strangely, Höttges never mentioned smartphone viewing as part of his target figure, of which there are 42.7 million subscribers in its native market, 74 million in the US and an additional 49.3 million elsewhere in Europe. Its EntertainTV service, which launched at the beginning of May 2016, includes mobile TV outside the home.

Our honest expectation was for StartTV to project Deutsche Telekom towards achieving its 10 million video subs target within the next couple of years and in the process hook customers into more expensive TV packages. Which, funnily enough, is DT’s panic strategy; approaching disgruntled StartTV subscribers with package offers for its full EntertainTV service – which ranges from €10 a month to €40, depending on bundles and triple play offerings. The Entertain set top costs €4.95 a month on top.

Failing to sell 100 channels for just €2 a month, with a very cheap set top rental, suggests there is a fundamental problem in DT’s content and/or marketing strategies.

Perhaps uncoincidentally, last month DT closed down its DTH-only service delivered via the Astra satellite platform HD+ and instead shifted to offering a hybrid combination of IPTV and satellite.

Users can switch between IPTV and satellite manually if they wish but DT suggests automating the process, allowing the set top to select the best option for them automatically. For example, the device will switch to satellite reception if a channel is only available in HD quality through Astra. Then if satellite reception was interrupted by weather conditions, the device switches to IPTV.

Perhaps the recent short comings at both Zattoo and Deutsche Telekom is representative of the wider disappointment of IPTV services across Europe in capturing a share of the TV market. In fact, Zattoo has confessed that OTT video delivery through a top CDN provider is a “compelling alternative” away from its direct networking peering which it refers to as unicast IPTV.

StartTV seemed to be DT’s way of moving away from its old Mediaroom system running on legacy hardware, in favor of cheaper set tops from Huawei, powered by a mystery chip which no one close to the matter will speak of.

The original StartTV release last year stated: “Deutsche Telekom Group, the second largest multinational operator in Europe, is working with Zenterio, on an ambitious project to modernize the TV subscriber experience in Germany with one of the market’s largest deployments of IPTV set tops.”

“In the view of the rapidly developing TV market, we are constantly adapting and realigning our TV portfolio. Therefore, we have decided to cease marketing our StartTV offer and to terminate sales from June 18, 2018. For customers signed up for StartTV, nothing will change until the end of their contract period,” a DT spokesperson told Broadband TV News.

A silver lining for Deutsche Telekom is that its IPTV and satellite subscriber base has grown by about 24,000 in Germany in the past year, although this growth has slowed significantly. The operator needs an aggressive mobile first TV strategy and it needs it now – although long-term content rights contracts may be holding it back.