Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 May 2021

Discovery/WarnerMedia will never realize ridiculous 400m subs target

Sometimes it doesn’t matter how much money you throw into a recipe, some things just don’t mix – like oil and water, or media and telecommunications.

While the recent decision by Verizon to bow out of media came as a shock to absolutely no one, the announcement that AT&T is preparing to spin out WarnerMedia and merge the business with Discovery is a shocking twist in US media consolidation.

AT&T has confirmed a $43 billion transaction with Discovery less than three years after setting out to create a TV powerhouse with the potential to achieve what no operator-owned content business had come close to doing before – competing with Netflix and Disney+.

Overnight, this deal makes John Malone – who sits on the Discovery board of directors and holds significant voting rights – one of the most powerful OTT businessmen on the planet, as well as one of the world’s most influential cable TV tycoons.

However, Malone’s statement following the deal downplayed this notion, stating, “After over 30 years of being involved in developing Discovery as a global information and entertainment company, the opportunity to combine with WarnerMedia to create the ultimate consumer offering in its space is compelling. The industrial logic of this investment grade, synergistic combination, under the leadership of David Zaslav, is appealing. I am delighted to fully support this transaction, without asking for or receiving a premium for my high vote shares. I believe we are creating real value for shareholders and a legacy investment for my grandkids.”

The announcement describes unification of complementary strengths of WarnerMedia’s studios and entertainment portfolio, with Discovery’s international unscripted entertainment and sports content. Discovery and WarnerMedia have a combined clout of cable channels capable of rivaling anyone, in a business that remains profitable but is facing serious headwinds as pay TV subscribers drop off.

AT&T has also considered attempting merging WarnerMedia with Comcast’s NBCUniversal, although that would prove significantly trickier to slide past regulators than the Discovery deal.

It may seem like a conflict of interests for a single media entity to operate more than one OTT video service, but HBO Max and Discovery+ really are apples and oranges in terms of content – together creating one of the world’s deepest content libraries with nearly 200,000 hours of programming spanning 100 brands. A proposed $20 billion a year will be invested in content, while there is definitely scope for an attractive bundling option for the two in the near future, before rushing to a conclusion that the two streaming services must be merged in order to survive.

HBO Max launched as a US exclusive with plans to expand internationally to some 60 countries by the end of 2021, while Discovery reaches more than 200 countries and territories – specializing in local-language content and deep regional expertise.

HBO Max had 64 million global subscribers on last count, although some of those are not officially on the new streaming service yet given the way AT&T counts traditional HBO subs, while Discovery has recently passed 12 million subscribers, up from 7 million in early 2021. A present day combined total of 76 million global streaming subscribers is nothing to scoff at, yet the proposed target of 400 million streaming subs in the long-term, to quote Discovery CEO David Zaslav, is a ridiculous target that we’ll be sure to remind him of. Unless, of course, he is counting users of the forthcoming ad-supported version of HBO Max.

AT&T has acted fast in its realization that challenging the SVoD royalty alone is a pipedream, even with HBO Max enjoying a fast start to OTT life. Deploying 5G and fiber networks are priorities numbers one and two for AT&T CEO John Stankey, who has been aggressively slashing jobs and any underperforming business areas.

After holding previous CEO Randall Stephenson to ransom over refusing to sell DirecTV, we have praised Stankey’s ruthlessness in trimming off the fat.

It comes weeks after AT&T confirmed it will receive approximately $7.8 billion from private equity firm TPG Capital for a 30% stake in the New DirecTV business, which the operator will use to pay down debt. The new business, which will include U-verse and AT&T TV services too, is being valued at just $16.2 billion – hardly sufficient to reduce AT&T’s total debt mountain of $180.2 billion as of Q1 2021.

A $43 billion deal with Discovery, meanwhile, will significantly reduce this debt burden and result in some very happy faces around the boardroom and among AT&T investors.

That includes activist investor Elliott Management, which surprised everyone by reinvesting an estimated $100 million in AT&T a couple of months ago, after previously pulling out. We saw the timing of Elliott’s return as highly suspicious, given its reputation for making its feelings publicly known, to influence share prices, and the Discovery transaction has Elliott’s fingerprints all over it.

AT&T shareholders will hold 71% of shares in the new company, leaving Discovery with 29%. The merged business is projected to create approximately $52 billion in annual revenue in 2023 and adjusted EBITDA of $14 billion, while creating cost synergies of at least $3 billion annually.

In all fairness to Verizon, the deals are hardly comparable. Verizon spent some $5 billion primarily on ad tech assets including AOL and Yahoo, which pales in comparison to the $85 billion AT&T spent on acquiring WarnerMedia. BT is probably a better comparison, as the UK-based operator is in the process of exploring a sale of its BT Sport arm. Amazon, DAZN and Disney are all rumored to be interested in a full or partial sale of the telco’s sports wing.

And with an ad-supported tier of HBO Max in the pipeline for next month, the Discovery deal will be an unwelcome distraction for the HBO Max team that has barely had time to come up for air in the years since AT&T took WarnerMedia under its ill-fated content wing. Zaslav should be conscious that any stalling puts that optimistic target of 400 million streaming subs even further out of reach.