The increasing alarm at Dish Network results is rising – four months ago the stock was $65, today it actually picked up, as the relief that the numbers were not worse was palpable, but only back to $46. It is now valued at $21 billion, in November it was closer to $30 billion. It seems that its spectrum assets are no longer seen as an upside, but are perhaps now a liability.
The number of genuine subscribers at its ARPU of $86.8 a month continues to be a secret. Most external estimates of Dish’s Sling TV numbers have it around a run rate of 150,000 a quarter, so some 600,000 customers, making its reported number of 13.9 million customers, look more like 13.3 million which remain still on the satellite network. All Sling TV customers are paying closer to $20 a month, so this should eventually show in the company’s ARPU, but currently it is concealed by other costs and revenues.
Revenue has gone up from $14.6 billion to $15.1 billion, there has been a price increase of around 3.5%, spread out over the year, and a rise in the number of broadband subscribers and there is some hardware revenue. Those last two add up to around $1 billion a year, and the other $14 billion are monthly subscriber payments.
Dish reported a fall of some 81,000 customers for 2015, compared to 79,000 in 2014, but in that year there was no Sling TV, the real losses are closer to 681,000, with revenue falls being arrested by the Sling TV monies and profits not falling quite so fast because of the excessive subscriber acquisition costs on DTH subs, at $723 per subscriber, almost wipe out the first year’s revenue anyway. The SAC of a Sling TV sub is far lower and artificially drops the company’s costs.
At this rate Dish will become a pure OTT player in 15 more years, with revenues of just $5 billion. Sure it may have less costs, and it may make money, but unless it can a) accelerate the uptake of its OTT service and b) charge more for it, that kind of pressure is going to continue to drive down its share price. Dish management needs to find some answers to this.
Dish somehow kept its operating income at $1.3 billion compared to $1.8 billion in 2014, but that was after the FCC auction expense of $516 million and an impairment of long-lived assets expense of $123 million, so it was roughly in line. Net income was $747 million compared to $945 million in 2014.
DISH added 46,000 broadband subs in 2015, bringing its total broadband subscriber base to 623,000.