Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

18 February 2016

The rise and fall of music streaming; Pandora to take easy way out?

Reports emerged from The New York Times recently that executives of internet radio streaming service Pandora had met with Morgan Stanley to discuss potential buyers, following the company’s poor Q3 2015 results. This led Faultline to ask ourselves whether music really has a route to market anymore?

Pandora’s financials showed Q4 2016 revenue of $336 million, and full year 2015 revenue of $1.16 billion, but a net loss of $169.7 million for the year. Pandora also spent $143 million in license payments, as well as the acquisitions last year of online ticket site Ticketfly for $450 million and rival Rdio for $75 million. Pandora said at the time it was set to offer Rdio’s personalized radio-style platform, as well its on-demand streaming service to its existing users by the end of 2016 – with a library of more than 20 million songs. Pandora, which dominates internet radio in the US, ended 2015 with 81.1 million active users, down 400,000 from the end of 2014, and only around 3.3 million paying customers.

It may seem unlikely that Pandora would put itself up for sale having so recently splashed out on acquisitions, but behind closed doors it’s clear that the industry is struggling. Spotify, for example, has around 25 to 30 million paying subscribers and some 85 million active users, but doesn’t have piles of cash because some 70% of its revenues go straight into the pockets of labels and publishers, of which a massive 80% comes from the advertising in its free version. This sounds good for the music industry, but the rise of streaming services has resulted in a collapse of download sales, and a resultant loss of income.

Pandora chief executive Brian Andrews, who is ironically also the director at The New York Times Company, has responded to rumors by saying, “It’s just not something we are focused on. We are focused on working as an independent company and driving our business. We are a public company and all that it entails.”

All it takes to paint a picture of the consolidation of the music market is a look back through history, from when the big six record labels (Warner Music Group, EMI, Sony, BMG, UMG, and Polygram) ruled the world from 1988-1999, and now today where we are left with just three in Universal Music Group (which absorbed most of EMI’s recorded music division), Sony Music Entertainment (absorbed EMI Music Publishing and BMG), and Warner Music Group (absorbed EMI’s Parlophone and EMI/Virgin Classic).

This consolidation has continued with the birth and struggle of music streaming services, one prime example being the founding of a startup called OD2 in 1999, which provided white-label music stores to ISPs and big brands. OD2 was acquired by music streaming firm Loudeye in 2004, and Loudeye was then bought by Nokia in 2007, which went on to eventually became MixRadio which was sold to Microsoft in 2014, and then bought by Line Corporation in 2015 – and this week it has been announced that MixRadio will too be closing down. This is just one instance of many that depicts industry consolidation and evolution – a company changing hands many times throughout its lifetime, with each new owner having positive ambitions of making money, but eventually, or rather soon in Line’s case, realizing it doesn’t know how to make money from it – before eventually meeting a grisly end.

As with Pandora’s acquisition of Rdio in November 2015, and Spotify’s recent move to include video clips in its mobile app, the industry is shifting to include multiple services on one app – with the ever growing trend that consumers want access not ownership. Combining services will increase ad revenues, because with no free ad-supported service, no service would survive very long (unless its name is Apple). On the other hand, if services such as Spotify had no paid, ad-free version then consumers willing to cough up would become frustrated, and companies can’t risk charging more than around $10 for this privilege. Tidal in the US, for example, started out with a $20 per month offering but then decided to add a $9.99 option.

Pandora’s share price has dropped quite significantly since the original post went to press, and Spotify is currently the bookies’ favorite if Pandora does decide to up and sell, but it would be a strange time to sell considering its market value has fallen from around $7 billion two years to around $1.8 billion now. Despite this market valuation plummet, it’s unlikely that Spotify will have the funds to finance such an acquisition – this leaves Apple, Amazon, Google, and Facebook. Apple Music could easily finance the absorption of Pandora’s radio assets, but it only recently shut down the free version of its iTunes Radio service. Satellite radio broadcaster SiriusXM and Ticketmaster are other names that have been suggested. Of course, it is entirely possible that the New York Times article is not true.