Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

14 July 2011

EU asks how to make our film industry great ‘ answers by video please

The EU has put out a consultation document that aims at finding out just how to go about turning the European video creation industry into a single market, which is easy for consumers to buy from. It aims to make any video available anywhere in the EU, at any time on any device, but raises so many questions that it is likely that any ideas that come out of it will take years to bring into action.

The effort though is a serious one and it is backed by some of the most powerful EU ministers including the Market Commissioner Michel Barnier, the VP for the Digital Agenda Neelie Kroes and Androulla Vassilliou, Commissioner for Education, Culture, Multilingualism and Youth.

And the prize is Hollywood’s crown. The Green discussion paper it put out should be read by everyone in the industry and can be found under market consultations at the ec.Europa.eu web pages. It points out that the EU is one of the largest producers of films in the world and it made 1,168 feature films in 2009 compared to 677 in the US. But so far the has led to European films making up 25% of cinema admissions within the EU (US films make up 68%) while US films take a 93% market share in the US and EU films get just a 7% share of the US market.

The questions that the Green Paper wants the answers to (among others) include
asking what the main obstacles are ‘ copyright or otherwise ‘ which impede the
development of a single market for visual content in the EU.

And the Paper wades through the morass of how should we go about arranging for rights to be cleared both in a single territory or across multiple territories at once, in Europe. Our biggest concern if that was made easier is that Hollywood would be able to take an even bigger market share.

The papers asks if copyright clearance is a matter for changing licensing rules, and should online clearance take a different route from say cable and satellite TV clearance. Can technology help? One area it suggests is in allowing a family to be able to access its own home TV when it is away from its home ‘ which is a call for placeshifting we suppose, but in the EU, if you move across a national boundary you may be breaking the law if you placeshift, so should those laws be changed and should this be encouraged.

Other areas for technology to help include the obvious setting up of identification systems for audiovisual works and rights ownership databases and it even asks if the EU should take a role in that. In the US there has been a clamor for the setting up of rights lockers but that’s an end user answer, and anyway could they work legally across EU boundaries? What the EU is on about is more about how to negotiate rights online, perhaps have online rights trading.

The paper suggests using the ‘country of origin’ principle, which is currently applied to satellite broadcasting, as a way of doling out online services ‘ if you have the rights to transmit to that region, then you have the online rights as well or they can be marketed territory by territory.

Could a copyright clearance system for cross-border retransmission of video be set up on a technology neutral basis? And should this be limited to closed environments such as IPTV or include open retransmissions over the internet?

And then the Green paper opens up the thorny issue of social networking sites, and asks if special measures need to be introduced to manage these. The document is beguilingly intelligent, but of course that doesn’t mean that all of the ideas expressed in it are intelligent. The reason that the US has one of the most powerful (if not THE most powerful) movie industries in the work is because it is lightly regulated to the point where it can carry out gross acts of anti-trust and get away with it. And here we are contemplating mass intervention on a European scale, the precisely opposite route.

Well perhaps the authors of the report are right, the only way to fix the studio industry in Europe is to protect it using regulation that makes things easier, but our concern time and time again is that if things are easier for the locals, they will be even easier for the dominant US studios. Making things fairer, might play into the hands of the already large.

Yes it would be nice if it was a cinch to clear video rights and associated music rights in one go, for all of Europe on a non-exclusive basis, for your specific network, but that very ease might devalue content and make it tougher to differentiate the services and in turn that might reduce the amount of money which smaller content producers could demand for their content (but then again they might find they are on more networks because of it, so perhaps revenue would go up).

The paper also talks about staggered film releases and questions the exploitation phases of films, based on staggered platform and territorial release options, asking if these methods are still relevant. Everyone knows that they are not and that they are only held in place by conservative US studios that don’t want to change for the sake of change.

If the EU really wants to do something for the local film industry it should take a long hard look at how US distributors operate. It is a shady and dark art. They spend tons of promotional money on about 100 film releases a year. The US themselves have thousands of films which could come out, and these are often excellent independent movies which fall the wrong side of these distribution arms.

This 100 or so films fight for seating space at Cinemas, without which their promotional spend in the tens of millions of dollars could not work. How do they secure this space? By saying that if you take my hot releases, you must take my rubbish releases, denying space for locally produced films to make money at the start of their exploitation cycle. Is that anti-trust? Well it’s certainly anti-competitive.

They those same studios ram this home with DVD manufacturing costs which suit the larger producers due to economies of scale, and then flood retail with DVDs and Blu-rays.

The entire process is run as a cartel without a single studio distribution arm favoring its own films, because it takes on more films that it can make, and even one distributor only holds around 20% of the market, so it’s not dominant. But collectively they are dominant, as we see by the 68% market share.

Cinema space leads to DVD sales expectation, leads to success which in turns leads to having the money for the DVD runs and next year’s promotional spend. You have to break that chain somewhere to give your home based industry a look in, and it’s not just money, but that control, sometimes illicit control, of the route to market.

So why doesn’t the EU get someone to offer a rights clearance arm just for home based content, complete with distribution rights across the EU and help in delivering it in each of the 27 languages, in the way local markets like it best, be that over spoken or subtitled or dubbed. In each country there is at least one small online distributor, cow-towing to Hollywood, which came into existence on the back of local independent film, but which can’t make enough money out of it because of the power of the US marketing, so ends up as an extension to US distributors.

The document is worth reading and worth responding to, but just what the EU can hope to achieve either in making life easier for ALL video producers or specifically for the disadvantaged local producers, we suspect that the answer is too difficult and likely unpalatable.