Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

30 October 2014

FCC chair displays joined up thinking to open OTT floodgates

We applauded the clarity and certitude with which Tom Wheeler the FCC chairman blogged this week, regarding changing MVPD status to one that is technology neutral. It opens up the US to many new points of competition, in particular sending linear and VoD TV over the internet.

The cable industry can switch to IP delivery in safety, which is the smallest of our fears; DTH rivals can create OTT services without fear of them being blocked; new OTT start-ups can emerge without placing the cost of the network build onto the price of television – that’s the best bit.

Wheeler referred to three pieces of legislation or ruling, the first was the Cable Television Consumer Protection and Competition Act of 1992, which effectively did much the same as this, but for Satellite.

This is really critical, because this was a complex 500 page piece of legislation that said a lot of things, mostly that the must carry rules for local broadcast TV applied to satellite DTH too, that these broadcast channels could opt out in favor of retransmission consent. So if the local broadcasters are of narrow interest and highly local and few want it, it still gets carried, and if it’s worth a fortune and drags viewers with it, the TV station can set its own rates.

But there are elements of this Act (which President Bush senior tried to kill) which relate to charging “reasonable” rates to the newcomers both for broadcast channels, but also for cable channels. This is really necessary to get around the threat that a company like Comcast might wish to prevent OTT providers getting content and promise to drop that content if it goes to a rival. Now this is really important, because that has definitely been going on.

Why else do we think that Apple, Microsoft (before Apple) and Intel (and probably less conspicuously Google), as well as Verizon – could not license sufficient content to take on the cable companies. And here is the nub of the delay in the FCC proceedings to say yay or nay to the Comcast Time Warner Cable merger. The reason the FCC stopped the clock in its 180 day approval period for this merger, was  because it was getting nowhere. While the official reasons ostensibly given, are that there are confidential content contractual terms in deals between Comcast and content owners, and they are trying to work out a way that these won’t become public, there might be other reasons.

For instance many of those deals might explain why there has been no competition to cable, because of the bullying, one sided rules that it has managed to get cable networks to adopt. It may also show that on recent negotiation, on retransmission consents, just what cable can do with the content and what broadcasters can do, something that may reveal vital elements of what broadcasters are planning.

Another piece of the puzzle which has still to be completed, is at the rulemaking stage and is referred to as the FCC Open Internet Proceeding which began in May after a previous FCC ruling was partially struck down by a US court. Essentially it has asked the world which route should it go in regulating the internet, either section 706 of the Telecommunications Act of 1996 or the enforcement om ISPs of Title II of the Communications Act on 1934. In essence it wants to know what stakeholders feel is the best way to define, prevent and punish breaches of network neutrality, so that it can prevent blocking by ISPs of rival video services.

But the best way of establishing these rules is staring the FCC in the face. If the largest provider of broadband in the US was to promise that it would not have any clauses, written or implied, that prevented a content owner from selling to another company, then effectively that would be a universal US rule. If you added that it promised not to block any content for at least ten years or slow it down or charge extra for carrying it, then you would have net neutrality by consent decree.

Any other rival that wanted to block content would just lose customers to Comcast-TWC. Any rival that said “You can’t sell that content to anyone else or we will stop carrying it,” would be ignored, especially if Comcast-TWC was happy to carry it.

It is regulation by the back door and this is just what the European Commission has just achieved by allowing the Liberty Global – Ziggo merger in the Netherlands.

But one way or another, with its Open Internet Proceeding or by turning Comcast into a dutiful citizen or blocking its merger, the FCC will get Net Neutrality.

And if we bring all that prior law together with the rulemaking that the FCC has announced this week, the puzzle is complete.

The US hopes to solve all of its broadband pay TV issues in one go. But will it? The idea is that anyone who can pay for content, can apply for MVPD status and that they will not, in turn be asked for too much money to buy that content. That they can get it to the customers OTT without it being slowed down and that this gives a new bright future to broadcasters into the bargain. Wheeler even mentions this as being a cure-all for an a la carte

channel unbundling outcome, which consumers say they want.

At the same time new broadband suppliers (local ISPs) will not have to ask local municipalities for permission to dig up roads or to offer TV. And they can also bundle TV with wholesale broadband, just like all four French Telcos do in France – a practice that is being rapidly copied around the globe. So the FCC hopes that this will also solve the lack of competition in broadband in the US.

Or to put it another way, if Apple or Amazon or Google want to offer local fiber and WiFi, and bundle it with linear and SVoD video services – they can. And companies like Roku can go into OTT linear channels and companies like Aereo can do its thing too.

Of course Aereo, as we always said, was easy to put out of business. The broadcasters simply had to become MVPDs themselves, and charge for the internet version of delivery – and about five years after Faultline suggested it, that’s precisely what they are now proposing to do.

But building a new world around new regulation is all well and good if the protagonists play by the rules. If there are Net Neutrality breaches by the back door (as there have been with Netflix being charged for interconnection agreements) then the whole chain of intended consequences comes crashing down, and yet more legislation has to be laid down to fix it.

So what happens from here. Well quite a lot. We pointed out about 5 years back that TV Everywhere was anti-competitive and should have been stopped. The owners of old networking infrastructure were saying, you can only get OTT content if you pay for us to continue to keep our outmoded QAM delivery running, while we move slowly to IP and without offering you any reduction in your monthly bill.

TV Everywhere strategies were an attempt to hijack the OTT future. These will suddenly “innovate” and break into tons of bundles, as the cable companies try to get a handle on the best way to do things OTT.

We have seen one such experiment this week, not so original, since it has been tried right the way across Europe, but nevertheless effective in that Verizon plans to give all new FiOS customers in the US a free one-year subscription to Netflix if they subscribe to its FiOS triple play service. This is a purely defensive maneuver, but it is the type of move that shifts more and more people to an OTT service in the first place.

We think there will be attempts at unbundled channels and smaller clusters of channels. This will first come from new players and then be offered cheaply by the older players. At Faultline we think and have said many times that OTT and especially VoD delivery, leads to people watching what they want, and the idea of channels breaking down, which in turn leads to the end of content that no-one watches.

Put that into perspective – that means that out of a 300 channel TV service, something like 270 channels of programming WILL STOP BEING MADE. And there will be MORE investment in better programming.

That’s probably an unintended consequence, and it’s still way off and erosion will take place over ten years, but this is what consumers need and want. We already see more original programming getting made for OTT VoD, and that will accelerate. Goodbye cheap reality TV, hello complex, well-acted, well-written, psycho-dramas.

While the FCC chairman thinks that making OTTs into MVPDs will actually stimulate more linear channel delivery (because MPVD status has this mandated), in the long term we do not agree with him here.

We now expect Sony, DirecTV and Verizon to launch OTT services. We already know that HBO and CBS have announced they are in the hunt for direct business, outside of cable subscriptions. There may also be moves from Starz, Disney, ESPN, Verizon, AT&T and Dish to take into account. Not to mention Apple at some point.

And cable will have to have its own creative backlash – and begin investing in original material – or forget about the TV part of the equation and just be better at broadband. TV Everywhere was the holding pattern, now what can cable come up with?

But the oft-quoted stat that in the US 75% of American homes have either zero or one broadband supplier that can deliver speeds of 25 Mbps downstream, we do not see going away with this set of moves. But it creates a political environment where companies like Google may decide that the time is right to make its “carrier” move.