France will become the second market in Europe to force a cable TV supplier in the form of dominant player Numericable, to offer access to its broadband capacity both wholesale and in what is called Bitstream access.
This is among the remedies that the Autorité de la concurrence, the French financial regulator, has agreed in order to allow the merger of SFR and Numericable. A previous law made in Belgium forced the two major cable operators there to offer broadband access to telco rivals, a decision affecting both Liberty Global’s Telenet and also local rival Voos, a move that will eventually let the local cellular Orange subsidiary Mobistar into the pay TV market there.
And this seems to be the way Europe in general is headed, as a way of allowing consolidation among fixed line players, but at the same time retaining broadband competition.
This was just one of a number of conditions applied to Altice’s acquisition of mobile operator SFR and its merger with its Numericable cable subsidiary. This move allows Orange, Bouygues Telecom, Free as well as MVNOs, to offer fixed broadband services using Numericable DOCSIS lines, as well as the fiber lines it has acquired when it bought Completel last year.
Interestingly Numericable has only 1.6 million French broadband lines – nothing like a dominant market share, but it has better and faster lines than any rival – except where those rivals offer fiber. France has always been keen to stimulate competition in this way and its unique telco environment has been created by the Telecommunications Regulator
Arcep, being the first to insist on unbundling the local loop more than 15 years ago.
Also as fiber was introduced to a country that boast 50% of people living in MDUs, by creating a rule whereby any of the telcos could bring fiber to a building, but only one. But that supplier was then duty bound to allow rivals to sell to people in the building, renting wholesale access from whomever built the connection. This is why France is the broadband capital of Europe and these merger conditions are in keeping with that history.
Numericable has also had to agree to sell the copper line network of subsidiary Completel, which could go to any of the other telcos and also has to sell off its Outremer Telecom’s mobile businesses outside of France in islands in the Indian ocean and off the coast of Africa, where it already dominates cellular access.
There is a real feeling with this move, of a shift in attitude to creating competition in broadband, not to unbundled loops, but to where a single fixed line business might maintain a copper/fiber telco network, but be forced to offer Bitstream access (a virtual amount of Mbps) to rivals. That way there can be only one network, but there can be many rival services. This idea was pioneered in the Nordic countries and last year Deutsche Telecom cut a Bitstream deal with Vodafone for access to its vectored lines in Germany.
By extending this to the major cable companies it would really keep broadband competition thriving in Europe, but that is something that needs to be done perhaps at the local level as each government uses this tool to bring back vibrancy into broadband competition, as it is needed. Belgium and France have pioneered it, and such a move by the Dutch government might also open up competition on the combined cable operator network there, formed by the merger of Liberty Global’s UPC and Ziggo. If the Dutch created such a wholesale or bitstream access law for cable, it would negate a lot of the harm it has allowed by letting that merger go ahead.
So is this something that could also be applied in the US? We don’t think so. Operators there feel unbundling is toxic and are prepared to go to the courts to prevent having wholesale prices levied on them from above by the regulator. It might be possible by making a major merger like the Comcast Time Warner Cable conditional upon the merged company offering unbundled access to its lines, but that is a move that we think would be a bridge too far and create outcry among US operators.