Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

7 June 2006

Fujitsu buys into WiMAX patents

The dream that WiMAX might deliver the holy grail of a major technology free of patent royalties is increasingly unlikely to become real, as it seems clear that various vendors will not only assert their intellectual property rights as the network gains adoption, but may charge significant sums for them. This is making it important for vendors to acquire patents with which to bargain, and this is likely to be behind Fujitsu Microelectronics’ decision to buy the intellectual property division of Canadian OFDM specialist Wi-Lan.

Wi-Lan abandoned its equipment making operations, which were developing pre-certified WiMAX products, last year, indicating the tough job that small broadband wireless vendors will have competing in a standards-based market. But it hung on to its core asset, intellectual property related to OFDM, much of it acquired from now defunct WiMAX Forum founding member Ensemble. At one time, Wi-Lan had embarked on an aggressive attempt to create a Qualcomm-type business by asserting that its patents were essential to all OFDM-based technologies, including 802.11a and WiMAX. This led it to take legal action against Cisco and to sign various agreements, notably with Fujitsu, whose WiMAX chipset was codeveloped with Wi-Lan. But rumors that Qualcomm or Intel might buy Wi-Lan came to nothing and speculation mounted that the patents were not as essential or defendable as Wi-Lan had claimed. Had they been, Qualcomm might have snapped up Wi-Lan instead of, or as well as, Flarion in its quest to create its own OFDM warchest.

However, Wi-Lan did score some successes, notably at the end of last year when it came to a settlement with Cisco that involved the giant licensing all its patents and, significantly, acquiring some of them for itself, in the WiMAX and smart antenna areas. Although that transaction may have robbed Fujitsu of some of the assets it could have acquired with Wi-Lan, the Cisco relationship could also prove valuable to the chipmaker as Cisco builds up its own OFDM arsenal.

The Japanese-owned company has formed a new unit, Fujitsu Microelectronics Canada, to house Wi-Lan’s patents and the engineers it has also transferred.

Kazuyuki Kawauchi, CEO of Fujitsu Microelectronics America, said: “We have purchased the Wi-Lan IP related to WiMAX, extended the scope of our patent licenses from Wi-Lan, and retained an experienced engineering team to continue our WiMAX development. This will assure our customers that the products they buy from us will grant them the patent protection they need to develop their own products and systems. It also ensures that we can share all OFDM source files with customers who want to develop SoC (system on a chip) technology with us.”

This indicates how important it is becoming, as intellectual property issues raise their ugly heads in WiMAX, for vendors to reassure potential customers that there will be no sudden patent claims ‘ fears of this type of action have been heightened in the past year by, in particular, the RIM patent sagas.