Some shareholders, led by Carl Icahn, the investor that tried to browbeat Time Warner into breaking itself up, are still unhappy this week with the Micron takeover of Lexar Media, the US flash memory controller designer.
Most other investors thought the increase in the deal offered by Micron was more than generous, lifting its offer from 0.5625 to 0.5925 Lexar shares for each Micron share. Given that the Micron price has risen dramatically since the offer was announced, this now values Lexar at $796 million, compared to the $666 million it represented when it was announced.
Both boards have now approved the deal, and despite Icahn’s public disapproval, it is likely to go through.
Lexar is faced with running out of cash and it is only really getting this kind of price because it has key patents in controller technology that Micron and its new flash partner Intel can share, to strengthen their attack on the Nand Flash memory market, a process that began when Apple gave them each a big piece of the iPod Flash memory business late last year.
Lexar patents relate to programmable controllers that increase write speeds and reduce overhead, using what it describes as a proprietary, indirect mapping methodology.
The deal was probably triggered by a court decision in December to grant Toshiba a new trial for its supposed misappropriation of trade secrets from Lexar.
Lexar had been awarded $465 million, with potentially more to come, by the Santa Clara County Superior Court after a jury trial, but as of December the amount will go to another court to reconsider and Lexar couldn’t look forward to $465 million in its bank any time soon, and its ailing finances forced it onto the market.
Lexar holds 98 issued or allowed patents, and licenses its technology to companies including Olympus, Samsung, SanDisk and Sony.