Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 July 2011

Google calls for patent reform, Apple judge ‘sort of’ provides it

There is a certain kind of madness going around in the patent business these days and this week’s news is saturated with it. In particular it seems that the future of handsets, or portable devices in general, are going to be wrapped up in 100s of patents controlled by perhaps fewer and fewer businesses. In a way it makes sense. More complex devices need to harness more and more inventions. At some point that same madness will come to the TV industry.

This week we have Motorola being pushed by an investor into selling off its patents, we have Qualcomm buying the 3D gesture based IPR from GestureTek and a US judge telling both Oracle and Google that the patents at issue are worth more than Google thinks, but a fraction of what Oracle hopes. And finally InterDigital has filed a complaint with the US International Trade Commission against Nokia, Huawei Technologies and ZTE alleging patent infringement.

Kent Walker, Google’s Senior Vice President & General Counsel, has also come out with a call for patent reform stating that innovation itself is in danger and taking the view that patent isn’t innovation. It’s the right to block someone else from innovating.

Google is now being linked to a bid for InterDigital or Motorola’s patent hoard, with Apple likely to try to thwart it. But would it love just such a company, one that already has a beef with all the handset majors? We’re not so sure.

It all seems to have got out of hand with all business now hostage to the courtroom. There needs to be a better way, but while $billions are involved, there seems to be no way around the constant uncertainty involved in a patent case. Patents, as we have said in the past, are not supposed to be ways to control entire markets without allowing anyone else to economically use a patent, which is the Apple view of its own patents. Instead they exist, as the Judge in charge of the Oracle Google case so reasonably points out, so that one company can get a payback on its inventions ‘ not all the other inventions which lie underneath that invention.

Judge Alsup of the US District Court for the Northern District of California rejected Oracle’s claims pointing out that patents in question ‘certainly do not cover all of Java or all of Android… It seems highly unlikely that Android derives its entire value from a small set of infringing features, given its breadth… The next report must apportion the total value between the specific infringing features versus the rest of Android.’ That’s someone revolutionary, but also simply clear minded.

Alsup has effectively sent Oracle and Google back to the drawing board in the Oracle case, and suggests they try to speak to one another about a sensible license. But what he has so rightly pointed out is that a few Java concepts which Oracle claims are infringed, do not make up all of Android. So he has instructed them to come up with a value for all of Android and then separately to come up with a value for the code that is claimed to be infringed, as a percentage of that value. The outcome should be a number that’s far smaller than the variety of claims Oracle has made, asking for up to $6 billion in compensation, but more than the $100 million that Google once talked to Sun Microsystems about for a full collaborative license to Java. Discussions should start at that $100 million level and then be inflated and discounted by subsequent events.

This is such a sensible legal attitude. Rapidly put the antagonists right on what is the basis for their claims, then make them sit in a room and cut a deal.

So what might happen on smart phones? We know that 3G has around 150 essential patents, and of course LTE has even more. ZTE alone says it has made 2,900 patent applications relating to LTE, and we have published estimates that it has around 7% of the essential LTE patents.

But a smart phone is defined as a phone which has a cellular communications technology AND an operating system. Essentially it also requires WiFi, Bluetooth and a host of other technologies including multi-touch, power saving, interference management, core chip processes, an accelerometer, camera, Capacitive Touch screen (to enable multi-touch), GPS, memory, a display, a media player, multiple antennas, it has speakers, proximity sensors and a battery to name but a few. There are close to 20 separate technology domains that come together on a handset.

Each of these segments has its own eco-system of IPR, and it’s the screen which we interact with more than anything, so does that make its screen patents more important than say its LTE patents? Or are its speakers more important than say the GPS if you happen to play music on it? Probably not, but who is empowered to decide? Right now it is judges like Alsup.

Do we have to ask the question of WHO invented the concept of an operating system just to ensure that Android has paid him or her some royalties? Does it matter that the entire thing is a phone and should the companies who invented phones get a piece of the action. Okay their IPR has expired, but otherwise they would all be coming in for the kill. The inventor of radio, of fast Fourier analysis, of OFDM, of basic electronic signaling ‘ they’d all be in for their share, but for the fact that for the most part they have expired beyond their 20 years or so of useful patentable life.

Except that in every case one patent relies on another, relies on another. The first patent instance may have expired, but the minor improvement may live on. Right now we have Apple pushing its claim to have invented a whole new way of using the phone using multi-touch gestures. But at the same time it is fighting off multiple suits from Taiwanese chip designer Elan which claims that it invented multi-touch, and ir probably did.

Elan registered multi-touch patents before Apple even entered the handset space. The ITC recently says that sure Elan patents are valid, but no Apple doesn’t infringe them. That’s a home court ruling in our view and were it the other way around, Apple would be claiming the spoils, and anyway it is being appealed to the full ITC and may get reversed.

The truth is that if you make touch chips and push for capacitive touch screens to be used, as Elan has, because it makes parts of them, then you will have played with touch and that includes touch of more than one finger, because it’s obvious that more than one hand has to touch such a small the device, otherwise how can you hold it. If you file a patent it will talk about using two fingers simultaneously and yes Apple’s multi-touch patents also do that. But of course what Apple has described is a far more sophisticated set of touch routines which take into account the entire menuing system and ease of use of an entire touch phone. But one almost certainly builds on another in terms of ideas.

So perhaps you don’t pay the man who invented batteries per se, but only the man that invented THIS type of battery, or the one who made the hyper efficient by inventing the Lithium Ion process.

But it is built into the nature of patents that where they were once not-obvious, after their invention, more and more similar ideas come along and they now seem obvious. It’s a tough task saying how revolutionary a battery was in 1800, when it was first invented, compared to how important the extra 15% is that we manage to eke out of batteries each year with expensive R&D programs.

And in a competitive market, where hundreds of companies have access to a technology, it still may be that only one major player holds the bulk of the IPR, so the IPR remains highly valuable.

If the obviousness today was a guideline, then Interdigital’s patents would now be worth nothing, in the same way that Gemstar’s EPG patents are now obvious in TV, because everyone in the world that has a pay TV service has seen an EPG. But it is the obviousness at the time it was invented that’s at issue.

So back to the case in point. Oracle has based its valuation for Android patent infringement fees on the entire value of Android, working it out from potential and current advertising revenues. And the judge is saying it’s wrong.

So how come Microsoft has been able to charge 5% of each handset to HTC for what is likely to be a far less open and shut case of infringement (the Oracle case relates to Java and the Google execs have openly said they needed Java)? While we have no particulars of the detailed claims of Microsoft, don’t you think that 5% is incredibly excessive as a total cost for one small part of only the Operating system, given that we listed about 20 different technologies areas that are essential for all smart phones. That’s only 5% each. Did Microsoft write ALL of Android? Not a chance. In fact there is every chance that it doesn’t infringe on its patents.

So under this Judge’s way of balancing out the royalty equation (and we think he’s right) quite a lot of the cases out there right now would evaporate. If Apple thought that Multi-touch was only worth 5% of the value of a handset, and that the infringed Apple IPR was only 20% of that, it wouldn’t be bothering to sue HTC, because there’s not enough money in it, and HTC would have happily signed a license anyway.

But we can look at this another way. What if each element does not have a value in and of itself, but instead we look at how much increase in value this particular invention gave to the overall device. Perhaps in the Oracle Google case these are the same thing, since Google gives the operating system away and makes money directly.

Apple might claims that it has changed the value of handsets with a combination of a touch screen with a set of multi-touch functions built in software, and an operating system which paved the way for an App Store. Interestingly the price of a smart phone is today probably some $150 per handset higher than the top end handsets prior to the introduction of the Apple iPhone. In a market where average handset prices are usually falling and so are the costs of the technologies inside them, that was a huge step in the opposite direction. But if Apple could argue that it has added a lot of margin to the device, Google could argue that its Android system has taken all that margin back out of the business by giving it away for free and making it easier to add those same facilities.

Could Apple argue that that loss of margin has removed opportunities from its own phones, using unlicensed copies of its own technology. We think that’s a fruitless exercise. Not only are we now in a period where what Apple added to phone design now appears to be obvious (and therefore not so highly valued) but also we would have to visit the exclusives strategy at the launch of the iPhone, which brought such a high margin to the Apple iPhone in the first place, itself a retrograde step to the entire market.

No the Judge has it right. The market will decide how much the phone is worth, and someone has to decide what your innovation on it is worth. And if that’s 20% (or 30% or 40%) of a single component that itself is one of 20 essential elements, then even if the ENTIRE device price is IPR (not counting the physical costs of the materials and price of making them) then the MOST you can ask for is 20% of 5% of the whole, and with HTC phones costing roughly $391 each on average, that makes the Microsoft settlement around 5 times too much.

Okay there are a lot of approximations in that sum, and a lot of what ifs, but we think that’s the real problem here ‘ too few judges and juries in the past have thought like Judge William Alsup, and directed the players in how to go about the valuation process.

And make no mistake here, our own area of television and pay TV services is going down the same route. A TV could have everything (except GPS – we KNOW where the TV is usually) that a telephone can have. So that patent issues, are not going to be so very far apart. TVs have been the sole technical area of a handful of Japanese and Korean conglomerates. But add an operating system and they are the province of Oracle and Microsoft. Add an App Store and they are in the area of Apple and Android Market. Add a touch screen to the remote and they are tablets with all that this entails.

The patent wars will move to wherever the money is being made. Digital Home connectivity might be one area, the overall TV home may be another, and the integration of these entertainment experiences into the portable device ‘ the ultimate.

Google’s new outcry was published in gadget blog TechCrunch, and a very timely intervention it is. In essence it is pointing out something that is very true ‘ companies like Google should not have to own lots and lots of patents in order to defend itself. Google has the money to spend on lawyers, but smaller innovators don’t. Very true. But what’s its answer?

Patent Reform. Well okay, but what does this mean exactly? Kent Walker seems to be saying that not enough time is spent examining whether or not a patent should be issued, and that as a result there are lots of frivolous, obvious patents out there. He’s right. One way to fund a better patent system would be to give up 10% of all your royalties to the US patent office to staff up to do a great job. We’re sure he’s not suggesting that, it would create an unworkable bureaucracy and a new center for lobbying.

Or does he mean that patent values and royalties have to be decided upon issuing a patent? We’re not sure that the USPTO is expert enough to see the future and know how valuable a patent is.

His complaint is that the patent process is used in the way Apple is using it, to stop everyone else from copying it, when the right way is to get everyone to copy you and pay you a little bit.

‘A patent isn’t innovation. It’s the right to block someone else from innovating,’ says Google’s Walker.

And he says this idea is new. Which is why the US legal system has to disabuse Apple of this notion and award sensible, not silly, penalties to Apple in any cases where it wins. Extinguishing HTC from the US market is not a desirable outcome for the average American. Down that path iPhones continue to cost $600 each even when its manufacturing price falls to $100.

But it is also why the Nortel patents were sold for so much, bankrolled by Apple to the tune of $2.6 billion of the total $4.5 billion) which continues to live with this misunderstanding that the role of the patent is to prevent innovation by stopping people from copying you.

Walker points out that the Nortel auction was the biggest patents sale in the history of the world. It should have been, but not at 5 times the stalking horse price, maybe more like 1.5 times that price. All that has done is suggest to the wide business audience that patents can be used the Apple way and make everyone with patents re-value them. That in turn will lead to more Nortel style patent sell offs and also to even less innovation, as only the buyers will be allowed to use those patents.

And if Interdigital, which is thought to have 13% of LTE patents, is put up for sale, it could effectively remove those patents from the general licensing pool. What if Apple bought them? They might simply sue every handset maker, even those with an Interdigital license, and simply up the stakes.

All of this makes the purchase this week from GestureTek of key IPR assets by Qualcomm all the more interesting. By jumping to the next generation of handset interface Qualcomm has effectively secured the future of Android devices from gesture based litigation. Okay multi-touch patents may still be an issue, but if HTC wants to get Apple off its case it could shift to Qualcomm SnapDragon processors, running Android, controlled using next generation UI, making gestures an inch from your screen, rather than touching it. Apple can’t actually patent the gestures themselves, though its lawyers might try.

As a chip maker Qualcomm has a history of extracting ‘full value’ for all of its technologies, but at the same time, it understands the role of ‘arms dealer’ supplying rivals as well as equipment vendors, without breaking the bank and without making gesture devices unfeasibly expensive to make.

The deal was carried out for an unspecified payment, and GestureTek will continue to work in the space, but will focus on the technology’s application in public display, digital signage and health.

GestureTek technology relies largely on cameras and object recognition, and this is all about ensuring that when devices make the next step ‘ being controlled by gestures which are not movements on a surface, but which are movements above or in front of a set of cameras ‘ that Qualcomm will grab more than a fair share of the chip spoils.

Many news sources says that this is Qualcomm going after Microsoft’s Kinect, but it’s really bringing a Kinect class interface to all Android Apps. It may also be a sure fire way of getting Qualcomm chips into future iPhones.