Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

28 July 2011

US proposals would seek to auction unlicensed spectrum

Unlicensed spectrum will be vital to the future of mobile broadband, bringing additional capacity into play and supporting new services and competition. Already, Wi-Fi has moved from being a ‘best effort’ back-up network to a strategic element of carrier deployments for data offload and indoor networks. Versions of LTE for license exempt bands are even discussed in some quarters, though the most prominent initiative is to put a Wi-Fi like technology into the white spaces in the 700MHz TV spectrum. Now all that could be put in jeopardy in the US by a bill that proposes that any commercial frequencies, including unlicensed, should be auctioned and paid for.

The draft bill is making its way through Congress, sponsored by Republican lawmakers. It would compel the FCC to auction various licensed bands within 10 years to free up more capacity ‘ notably parts of AWS-2, AWS-3 and some government spectrum. It would also support the FCC’s wish to conduct incentive auctions in order to reallocate broadcast spectrum for mobile data services, and would earmark 24MHz of bandwidth for the long awaited national public safety network.

Most of these ideas are well rehearsed but the proposals for unlicensed bands are new and controversial. Companies would have to pay for rights to use these bands, even though they would not obtain exclusive rights. The only way to gain an exclusive would be to bid such a high sum that it totaled more than the sum of bids from companies wanting unlicensed usage. Conversely, if the total value of bids for unlicensed rights exceeded that of the highest single bidder, the spectrum would become unlicensed.

If this confusing set of rules were to be passed, it could stymie the efforts of the white space advocates ‘ such as Google and Microsoft ‘ to use those frequencies for license exempt mobile broadband. Other technologies are looking to harness unlicensed bands too. One of them comes from xG Technology, whose VP of marketing, Rick Rotondo, told Telecompetitor: “It’s like saying ‘We’ve got some land, it’s in Central Park, we’re going to allow a developer to bid on it or you can bid on it if you want to keep it as a park’.’

xG’s platform has been through various repositionings during its history but is now focused on rural broadband and VoIP. It is now being tested by eight local telcos in the US, using the 900MHz band (unlicensed in the US and mainly used for video surveillance and cordless phones). Like technologies proposed for the white spaces, xG uses cognitive techniques to sense and avoid interference from other devices. A new version of the xG chip, scheduled for September, will also support communications in the 5.8GHz band, which is also used by Wi-Fi, and could also be targeted at the white spaces. The system will be able to shift between bands within 30 milliseconds, said the firm.

xG has been field testing its platform in a 32-square mile network in Fort Lauderale, Florida for a couple of years and has a trial with Texas local telco Townes Telecommunications. These are supporting VoIP services but the upgraded chip will also support simultaneous data. It expects to implement this initially in a personal router, which could then backhaul multiple Wi-Fi devices ‘ an approach also used in WiMAX and LTE to seed the market and provide a simple way to support in-home Wi-Fi networks without wireline connections. xG is aware that mobile broadband will be a patchwork affair, combining cellular and unlicensed standards, and it even envisages a dual-mode xG/LTE handset, allowing rural subscribers to roam onto 4G networks in metro areas.

The telcos evaluating the platform are Redi-Call Communications of Delaware, TelAtlantic Communications of Virginia, Cook Telecom of California, Silver Star Telephone Company of Wyoming, Venture Communications Cooperative of South Dakota, Smart City Telecom of Florida, and Public Service Cellular of Georgia, as well as Townes.