Google’s aggressive pursuit of world domination has taken a knock. It turns out the giant search engine has rivals after all, and a Russian one leads the way.
An investigation by the Russian Federal Antimonopoly Service (FAS) found that the US powerhouse required manufacturers of Android devices to preinstall Google applications and use its search engine by default if they wanted the devices to have access to the Google Play app store. Subsequently, it has ordered that Google is to change its stance on pre-installed apps on Android devices by November 18th, or face fines of up to 15% of sales made from the apps.
Russia and China are the two markets where Google has genuine competition – so naturally Yandex, the Russian search engine, filed an antitrust complaint against it back in February, which found Google guilty of abusing its dominant market position.
This is a path that led Microsoft nowhere and cost it more than a billion dollars in fines.
Google has a mammoth share of the European search market with more than 90% in most countries, so the investigations led by antitrust regulators seems logical. In Russia, Google’s search share is just 32%, while Yandex has 57% – this market share had a big influence on the success of the Russian enquiry, the outcome of the EU’s own could be very different, but we expect it will learn a thing or two.
In April, the European Commission opened a case against Google to investigate if Android as well as its other apps and services for tablets had breached EU antitrust rules. Google will be assessed on whether it has illegally hindered the development and market access of rival mobile operating systems, mobile communication applications and services in the European Economic Area (EEA). This case is an entirely separate entity to the Commission’s investigation into Google’s behavior in internet search. We toyed with the idea of trying to count, compile, and summarize all historical and on-going cases against Google, but swiftly back-tracked, as there are too many.
Last year it was reported that Google had also forced manufacturers such as Samsung and Huawei to preinstall 13 of its apps, prominently display them, provide access to Google search from the home screen and make their own engine the default in browsers. The Android OS is given away for free, which explains why, in the three months ended June 2015, 82.8% of all smartphones sold globally ran Android. Revenues come from advertisements on Google services used by consumers.
However, back in 2013, an investigation in South Korea found that Google’s requirement of smartphone manufacturers to preload its search engine was not in violation of its antitrust laws.
Yandex founder Arkady Volozh explained last year how Android has changed the market, “It’s impossible to create an ecosystem around you if you’re a local player. Yandex has 3% of the global market. It’s impossible to persuade developers to write applications for your platform.” Despite offering virtually the same services as Google.
In 2014, Google closed down its engineering offices in Russia due to a controversial law requiring internet companies to store the personal data of Russians within the country’s borders.
A defensive response from Google’s general counsel, Kent Walker, said, “We don’t think this format is anti-competitive. On the contrary, showing ads based on structured data provided by merchants demonstrably improves ad quality and makes it easier for consumers to find what they’re looking for.”
Earlier this week, the European Court of Justice declared that the legal agreement by which personal data can be moved from the EU to the US for processing is now invalid. Google, Facebook, Apple and Microsoft are among 3,000 companies that use the 15 year old law, called ‘Safe Harbour’, to transfer data to locations in the US for analysis.
“It’s quite a huge thing to say that one region’s set of laws is superior to that of the US,” said Carly Nyst, a lawyer and privacy consultant. “That’s the bigger implication of this – the EU exerting its might over the US. They’re saying our standards are higher than yours, and you need to step up your game: the EU is not going to stand for the US doing whatever it wants.”
This ruling puts further strain on EU-US relations. This can be seen as a big step forward in data protection, but disputes over net neutrality and the right to be forgotten continue to fly back and forth across The Atlantic.
Discovery Communications partnered with Russia’s National Media Group (NMG) this week, forming the Media Alliance. The joint venture allows Discovery to start reselling ads in Russia after its ban on non-terrestrial channels.