Most news sources this week picked up the fact that Intel may be about to head into trouble with the European Commission anti-trust authorities, on the back of a complaint made last year by AMD.
Intel has always bent over backwards to avoid anti-trust legislation, and usually the claim is the same each time, that Intel has used its position to give PC makers bigger discounts if they promise not to use AMD chips.
Back in July last year AMD brought its own US anti-trust suit against Intel and there was a dawn raid at Intel’s European offices in connection with the continuing investigation within the European Commission into Intel’s rebate practices.
AMD has claimed that Intel gets around illegal discounting by offering rebates to those companies that end up not doing any business with AMD. We said at the time that if such rebates existed, they were clearly a step too far and Intel would find itself in hot water in Europe at least.
Much the same should be true of US law, but US anti-trust cases have a way of getting swept under the carpet, even when the accused party is found guilty, such as in the recent Department of Justice Microsoft case.
In the end rebates are all about hitting quarterly numbers and even customers the size of IBM, Hewlett-Packard, Dell and Sony must find it tempting to accept the Intel rebates if it means bringing down costs for the next quarter by cashing in a rebate instead of paying real cash for more inventory.
AMD said last year that these PC companies are going to go ahead and testify as they have come to realize that by not using AMD for PC chips, they have created a pure monopoly where pricing is totally dictated by Intel.
If the European Commission or a US court finds Intel guilty, the likely fine will have to be enough to be corporately damaging, because a healthy AMD would have created a much more level playing field and denied Intel much of its margin over that period. In other words it might make the Microsoft suit look small.
The truth is that three years ago if IBM had not bolstered AMD fortunes by taking its Opteron chip for one of its big servers, AMD might not have made it. Now it occupies a much more troublesome role as a direct rival to Intel at almost very level in microprocessors.
AMD is understood to be pursuing the same legal actions in Japan as well, where it focuses on supplies of chips to Sony and other, and millions of dollars in illegal rebates. Back in 2005 there was a ruling from the Fair Trade Commission of Japan (JFTC), which found that Intel abused its monopoly power to exclude fair and open competition, violating Section 3 of Japan’s Antimonopoly Act, again to the detriment of AMD.
At the time AMD said that Intel paid Sony millions of dollars for exclusivity and that its share of Sony’s business went from 23% in 2002 to 8% in 2003, to 0%, where it remains today.
The European review panel is about ready to decide on whether or not a case can be successfully brought against Intel and European officials have begun leaking the notion that it might go badly for Intel, which controls nearly 80% of the PC processing chip market.