Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

11 October 2006

Round one to Broadcom in the Qualcomm royalty wars

Broadcom said this week that it has won the first round of its dust up with Qualcomm when the initial finding of US International Trade Commission ruled that Qualcomm is infringing Broadcom patents. Broadcom says that the Commission will now issue an exclusion order barring imports of the infringing Qualcomm chips and issue a cease and desist order.

ITC Administrative Law Judge Charles Bullock found all three patents to be valid and one, US Patent No. 6,714,983, was infringed in products including cellular baseband processor chips that make up the core Qualcomm chips in multimedia and convergence handsets.

In his ruling, the judge found that Qualcomm has violated US trade laws by importing chips that infringe Broadcom’s patent. “We are gratified that Judge Bullock recognized the validity of our claims with a ruling that helps us protect our valuable intellectual property and sends a very strong message to the industry that Qualcomm is not exempt from the rules,” said David A. Dull, Broadcom’s Senior Vice President and General Counsel.

This ruling is just the very first stage in a series of cases brewing between Qualcomm and Broadcom. Just last week Qualcomm was trying to get an injunction against Broadcom’s 3G chips, but failed, and now the legal fortunes are reversed.

The fight began when Broadcom tried to get a license to make 3G chips and claims to have found that the Qualcomm charges more for companies that make chips than it does to its own customers that buy chips, and that it charges once for the chip maker and then another separate royalty for the equipment maker and so gets multiple royalties.

This is all against a backdrop of hostility throughout the cellular community towards the high royalty charges that Qualcomm is renowned for.

Broadcom also threw its weight behind an anti-trust suit in Europe and a US anti-trust suit, which was turned down in early September. Broadcom in turn has also asserted that Qualcomm products infringe eighteen of its US patents, and Qualcomm has countersued, hence last week’s request for an injunction.

Broadcom said that it thinks Qualcomm infringes at least 15 more patents across its entire product line, says it expects to take those cases to trial over the next twelve months.

In the next step of the ITC process, the judge’s Initial Determination will be forwarded to the full Commission, comprised of six members. The Commission is scheduled to make its Final Determination by February 9, 2007.