Irdeto is boasting this week about being highly rated in a security audit by respected security service, the Merdan Group in California, and so it should. But this is no ordinary statement and we’d like to draw attention to just a few key lines and interpret them for you.
The Netherlands based conditional access firm was having its ‘software only’ DRM tested, and claims that it is the ONLY such system to complete the FULL Merdan audit.
The Merdan Group built its reputation on security audits of conditional access firms such as Motorola, Cisco’s Scientific Atlanta and Nagravision, all of which rely on hardware assists to hide all or parts of a private encryption key.
But for the past two years rival Widevine, with its Cypher software DRM, has been openly talking about being the ONLY software DRM that will get operators access to the most valued studio content, and in part puts this down to its passing of the Merdan Security audit.
Reading on in the Irdeto statement, ‘Unlike other IPTV security companies that have only undergone partial audits, Irdeto is the first to complete an audit of its full, software-based, end-to-end IPTV security system,’ which suggests that Widevine has yet to complete the audit, even though it’s been talking about it for some time.
We know this claim has angered companies like Verimatrix, Irdeto and Secure Media, all of which sell systems which have as much credibility as Widevine’s among the US studio community, not to mention Microsoft with its own DRM.
Irdeto SoftClient is a software only security client use to protect broadcast, on-demand and DVR content on IP networks and despite the fact that Irdeto has spent most of its 40 years of experience in pay TV using smart cards, and like NDS it has a culture of card dependency, it was developed for those operators that don’t want the extra expense of cards, in other words those with a return path like IPTV telco operators. Software only clients tend to be only accepted where there is a way to rapidly update the client in the field, and use multiple re-authentications, and so needs broadband access.
“Irdeto approached us to carry out a complete security audit on their IPTV software-based solution, SoftClient,’ said Gilbert Huey, president of Merdan Group. ‘The results of our security audit indicate that, based upon our professional opinion, all aspects of the system meet or exceed robustness at the sophisticated hacking level.”
Security specialists like Merdan Group do not give content security vendors their blanket ‘approval,’ nor can a company ‘pass’ such an audit. Nevertheless, Irdeto reminded us, content owners are applying extra scrutiny to the relatively new software-based IPTV security solutions and often use third-party audit reports, such as Merdan’s, as an important criterion when licensing content to pay TV operators.
Irdeto this week also said that it had signed a service delivery agreement with Nortel. The agreement empowers Nortel to incorporate Irdeto content security into its IPTV system and directly market it to customers worldwide.
Irdeto joins market leaders such as set top makers Amino and Tilgin and middleware firms Kasenna and Minerva Networks in being Nortel IPTV partners.