Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 November 2006

UK mobile TV spectrum auction put back and in doubt

The spectrum auction which was to catapult the UK into the forefront of mobile TV in Europe, setting aside up to 40 MHz of bandwdith, is at least delayed and potentially it might be off. The local regulator Ofcom has said that the lower 28MHz chunk of the spectrum has been promised to DAB applications iinternationall and that there are some technical issues of offering it on a technology agnostic basis.

It has initiated a review under the Masstricht agreement with the Radio Spectrum Policy Group to establish whether or not it should issues a license between 1452 and 1479.5MHz, and under what conditions and for use with which technologies.

One of the problems is how neighboring territories will address guard band issues between the 1.7 MHz DAB slices of spectrum, and how this may create interference especially where one authority allocated the spectrum in larger chunks, as Ofcom had planned to.

This raises a major issue about the future of this spectrum and its value. Bidders were encoraged to see the entire 1452 to 1492 spectrum as suitable for mobile TV and satellite radio, but it is roughly twice as expensive to set up a network in this spectrum as it would be in freed up UHF spectrum (under 700 MHz), once analog tv transfers to digital. However that might be as far out as 2012 since that is the European deadline for freeing up these frequencies.

An alternative suggestion has been to target Channel 36, used in the UK for radar which could potentially be moved to other suitable spectrum if some compensation were paid.

So there was already uncertainty over this spectrum to the point where perhaps none of the cellular operators were inclined to bid for it, leaving it to companies like News Corp’s BSkyB, which is trialling Qualcomm’s MediaFLO for mobile TV and might also be interested in it for Satellite radio.

But now the added disincentive of the spectrum license falling foul of international agrements, and potentially ending up with onerous intererence restrictions, makes it totally unbuyable.

Ofcom reckons that it should have clarification by the end of 2007, whereas the original auction date was to be the Spring of 2007.

This immediately puts a fresh complexion on the only existing mobile TV service in the UK, Movio, run by British Telecom and which is only currently being sold by Virgin Mobile. This in fact uses the existing national DAB multiplex, but only offers data channels of 96 Kbps, rather than the DVB-H data rates of around 400 Kbps.

We spoke to Movio this week, which explained that it’s strategy was both technology and spectrum agnostic and that it was more about building software on the mobile device which ensures that future video services, whether DVB-H delivered or carried with another protocol, or even sent over the cellular link, could all be integrated into a single look and feel that the customer could comfortably navigate. Movio insisted that its service might just as easily accommodate whatever ends up in this spectrum, on top of the five TV channels it has today.

Whether it is catch up TV, overnight clipcasts, Slingbox delivery of video from home, mobile TV, unicast cellular or DVR stored on the phone, Movio sees its job as controlling all of it, and staying on top of the user experience.

Now it can look forward to at least two years as the only mobile TV service in the UK, unless someone rapidly clears Channel 36, and auctions it to the satisfaction of the UK cellular operators, but even that would likely not make an entry before 2008.

There is even talk in the UK of licences for further DAB Multiplexes being issued by Ofcom, which would open up the potential for more mobile TV channels to be offered on Movio.