The announcement this week that Vodafone is now involved in a trial using LTE Broadcast adds another heavyweight to the operators that are going down this route. It is still only a trial, but that now means that Verizon, Telstra in Australia,
KT in Korea and KPN in the Netherlands are joined by the largest mobile operator in the world, outside of China.
It adds weight, but these are still all only trials, and the single selling point, once again, appears to be a move around arena delivery, as the Vodafone trial is being conducted at the Borussia M’nchengladbach’s football stadium. Ericsson has been pushing this idea as one of its main proving points, and it once again raises the question about whether or not sports rights will continue to offer separate mobile rights, alongside TV rights. If you add AT&T, which has also declared its interest in LTE Broadcast, then you have four of the most sophisticated MNOs in the world taking an interest, with the two US operators, KC and Vodafone.
Having spent five years watching the rise and fall of the DVB-H in Europe, we remain skeptical that this is a revolution that will be fully embraced by the larger cellular community, and wonder if this is not, in fact, a temporary landgrab for arenas, rather than an interest in broadcasting per se.
First let’s look at the trial and compare it to the Verizon service around the NFL in the US. For Vodafone it was installed, supposedly only for one game held on February 22nd, a Bundesliga soccer match and it involved the usual suspects, Ericsson supplying the software and probably some extra hardware such as DAS antennas, Samsung supplying handsets, with Qualcomm chips inside them that carry the logic for decoding the evolved MBMS signal, plus one operator.
The key statement from Vodafone may be when it said, ‘LTE Broadcast could soon be available in further German stadia,’ as the multi-territory operator revealed it as part of Project Spring and Vodafone Germany’s network modernization program.
The details on Project Spring are sketchy ‘ but fundamentally it’s an acceleration towards LTE in all of the major Vodafone markets, costing an extra £7 billion on its existing capex bill, and paid for out of the proceeds of the sale of its Verizon holdings in the US, a deal that has just gone through. Most of the money went back to the shareholders, some is still held in stock, Vodafone paid down a bit of debt and it has Project Spring. This week it has awarded a 5 years deal to Ericsson effectively to carry out these upgrades along with their tuning, integration and optimization. It is no coincidence that Ericsson is then pushing LTE Broadcast ‘ through a combination of its 3GPP base station software and the Qualcomm Snapdragon chipset, as that slowly rolls out into more and more handsets.
The idea is simple ‘ a faster, better integrated, more advanced LTE network will attract more customers and this should include LTE Broadcast. We might be excused for thinking that actually most LTE operators will reach for LTE broadcast when they are ready, and it’s purely that Vodafone is now going to have the kind of network profile that Verizon has in the US, as the most advanced network around, and that makes it ready for LTE Broadcast earlier.
To a certain extent the most advanced network will employ the more advanced devices and more and more of these will come ready made with LTE Broadcast capability, built into the latest App Processor chips. But somehow we don’t buy that this is the whole story.
We think the arena push is very different in Europe to the US, in that sports rights are held very differently, and also that sports video is simply a Trojan Horse on behalf of Ericsson, to justify getting video on the agenda for the leading MNOs.
Back in the noughties, Vodafone ran something called Vodafone Live! A content portal that included early video services. Today that portal no longer exists, and has gone the way of many walled garden services in cellular. But we think there is a rationale and a dream of bringing back walled garden services, but through content partnerships with existing contents owners.
The key difference between sports content on different sides of the Atlantic is that in the US each sports tends to be nationwide, with a potential reach of over 300 million people, whereas in Europe the 500 million plus people have sports which are broken into smaller countries and smaller sports leagues. On average per fan the sports rights in Europe are far larger than the US, but it is broken into far smaller sets of rights among more companies. One European entertainment entity is unlikely to be able to afford soccer rights in the UK, Germany, France, Spain and Italy, but might partner with the broadcasters that do.
As a result of this structure free to air advertising networks such as ABC, NBC and CBS, and more recently Fox, tend to own all the US sports rights. These do not have their own internet networks or satellite delivery. They use pay TV operators as distributors, rather than them being primary rights holders. But in Europe each sports right is a key part of any pay TV strategy and these companies have rather more potential to compete directly with the MNOs.
Even so there are some strong relationships already building and Vodafone has had a long term set of separate deals to bring content from what was News Corp, now 21st Century Fox, (think Sky in Germany, Italy and the UK) to its customers. In fact at its recent 4G launch in the UK, Vodafone was offering Spotify Premium and Sky Sports Mobile to tempt users to upgrade to 4G.
So we expect that some of the larger MNOs will have a safe position where they act as a distributor for an existing sports rights holder, rather than in the US, where Verizon was forced to shell out $1 billion to get the mobile rights. An operator might add to the pot, y supporting a bid in Europe, but not lead it.
The NFL on TV is costing around $3 billion a year by comparison and if Faultline is right, that more and more TV will be watched on tablets and smartphones than on a TV, then at some point the mobile rights will cost more than the TV rights. In the UK alone the TV sports rights for 3 seasons of soccer were $5 billion, and each of Italy, Spain, Germany and France would cost the same again. Given that Vodafone is only spending £7 billion on Project Spring, we cannot see it ever spending to buy sports rights across all of its territories, although as we said, it might pitch in with a sweetener.
What we think will happen in Europe is that existing pay TV networks who have the rights, will partner with cellular operators to bring those rights, one territory at a time to a cellular service. It is true that two sets of profits have to come out of the service from this approach, but it can be coordinated with TV rights, so as not to impinge on them, and Vodafone will mostly get its extra profits by stealing rivals’ customers.
For instance the arena system is a service that can be offered to the individual sports clubs, no mobile coverage would be offered inside that City unless that stadium was sold out, and then the games could be shown there on mobile phones. Outside of the city the mobile version could complement, rather than compete with the TV version, and acts only as an alternative version for people who cannot get to a TV.
The European Commission is currently pushing for all content rights in Europe to be non-exclusive and Europe-wide. It wants this so that Sky will compete with Canal Plus etc.. At present Sky dominates sport in the UK, while Canal Plus dominates it in France ‘ and in each country no-one has sufficient clout to compete with either of these (although BT Sports has just been started in order to do just that in the UK). To the European Commission it makes more sense that both of these broadcasters compete with one another across multiple territories, providing further choice and better consumer price protection.
Under these conditions instead of the UK football League selling UK rights to one company and the rest of Europe to another, it can sell multiple licenses to European wide consortia. One way for them to differentiate themselves will be to offer such an Arena system with a cellular partner that operates in the same territories ‘ Sky operates in Italy, the UK and Germany, and would make a perfect European wide partner for Vodafone.
Vodafone could also fit other broadcaster services from other arena owners in other territories onto the same LTE broadcast. It could offer Sky AND CanalPlus on different channels, working in different parts of Europe, with different broadcast partners. In a way it would allow multiple content partnerships with multiple MNOs, but the first mover advantage in this would go to the MNO with the most advanced LTE network, in the most territories, which makes it a straight fight between Vodafone, Telefonica, T-Mobile and Orange, most other operators being more localized.
All of this put simply is that instead of LTE Broadcast being a rival to existing broadcast systems, in Europe we expect it to be just another version of the same thing and the same broadcast war.
And once Vodafone has first mover advantage, that will stimulate the other operators to catch up when they can, in the process accelerating LTE Broadcast capability. And it will start where it has a ready-made sports rights partner, in the three territories of Sky. In Germany the Bundesliga rights are already held by Sky, whereas at present it has been outbid for them in the UK by BT Sport, so perhaps BT Sport will be the first channel on LTE Broadcast there. CanalPlus will perhaps do the same with Orange in France.
The Vodafone announcement made the point that eMBMS puts no additional load on the network, enabling smartphone users in device dense locations to watch TV channels in high-quality create a Single Frequency Network in the process, for any given station.
One of the reasons we say that the world is suddenly focused on arenas is that not only are sports rights for broadcast an important trend, but people are starting to realize that both cellular networks and WiFi completely fail when they are around arenas with huge concentrations of people all trying to get a signal at once.
Another announcement this week comes from TE Connectivity and Alcatel Lucent at the show, which suggest they can cut the cost of broadband at an arena using a new Distributed Antenna System in stadiums, one that can be shared by all of the MNOs that operate in the region.
We have come across very specialist WiFi suppliers in the past that have played with how rapidly the system connects to each device, and where it simply connects everyone and subsequently asks them for credentials, as an alternate log in process, for fear that 30,000 devices at once looking for connectivity all the time will eat up most of the resources. One company with a strategy like that was Signal Share, a specialist that now makes its own equipment and ferries it around to pop concerts and stadiums. It calls its system Live Fi and it can also support sponsored messaging and advertising, ticket and merchandise sales, and future event promotions, and mailing list sign ups as well as offering WiFi. It can run its own caches including iOS app caches.
Cisco already has its own version of much the same thing, in both cellular and WiFi and it even claims to be able to support multicasting in WiFi (we’re not sure you can really do such a thing).
If it can be done for WiFi we have no doubt that it can also be done for the broadband portion of an LTE or 3G signal, and that’s what TE Connectivity and Alcatel-Lucent have devised. It will also suit train stations and business parks and amounts to a common digital interface between the Alcatel-Lucent Light Radio and the TE FlexWave, digital Distributed Antenna Systems (DAS), available for commercial deployment inQ2 2014.
But if this is a push for the hearts and minds of European and US stadia, it will take some time to bring fully to market, as there are over 200 stadiums in Europe which each have over 30,000 capacity.
We would question what kind of experience a sports owner wants its customers to have ‘ one where the sport owner dictates what the multimedia deliverables are, in a coordinated in-app broadcast, for instance like the 6 camera angles that the Verzion system is famous for, as well as the additional system messages ‘ in which case the answer is LTE Broadcast, or one where the consumer can move to sites of his or her own choosing, outside of an app and through a browser. The chances are that nearly all of the people would want both ‘ one for when they are totally engaged, if not engrossed, by the action, and the other for when they are bored, between pieces of action. In which case the fight for stadium broadband and broadcast will be fought on two fronts, and take some years to complete.