The back and forth between SFR and Numericable is back on says the French daily financial newspaper Les Echos, and you cannot help but reach the conclusion that so many French and other technology analysts have, which is that the two companies belong together, and that this will happen as soon as someone comes up with the right price to make it happen.
SFR has a relationship with Vodafone in the same way that a parent has with a 25 year old child that has finally flown the nest ‘ it doesn’t want to see it starve, but it feels it has done enough. Vodafone might be a natural owner of SFR at some point, but after extracting a fine price for its share of the business in 2011 for almost €8 billion, Vodafone can be excused if it no longer wants to play in the exceptionally tough French market. France features the current lowest priced cellular offers in Europe, courtesy of market disruptor Free.
But the moment that Vivendi acquired the Vodafone half of SFR, it immediately found it did not know what to do with it. It put it up for sale, then mooted a merger with Numericable, then valued it way too high.
We can see from Vodafone’s activity that the new reality around Europe is to have both fixed and cellular lines, with the consumer revenue and revenue growth coming out of cellular, and the cost reductions for small cell backhaul and WiFi Offload coming from ownership of a fixed line architecture. The only other major requirement is that international roaming does not cost an arm and a leg, and the paternal and continuing relationship with Vodafone should see to that, and the European Commission is anyway making that less of a problem.
If Vodafone owned it, it might feel that it has to bid for Numericable or one of the other French ISPs, although unlike other Vodafone properties around Europe, such as in Germany, where it felt it had to buy Kabel Deutschland to secure fixed lines, SFR has 4 million telco fixed lines courtesy of its Neuf Cegetel acquisition.
All across Europe, cable companies currently survive without cellular assets, but many of them are tempting tidbits for cellular operators to acquire on the understanding that eventually telcos and cellular operators will squeeze their margins ‘ so Numericable is perhaps the company that wants such a deal the most ‘ without a cellular arm it fears that it has no quad play and somewhere on the horizon it suspects it shall need one.
The latest move is that Vivendi has been approached once again by Altice the private equity firm that continues to hold the largest chunk of the shares in the freshly public Numericable. This time it is more interested in an alliance than a merger, but in our view there can be no deals between equals in this type of arrangement, as one of them will make all the profits ‘ in the end if it is not a marriage it is after, it is at least a trial marriage.
The problem with French assets in a volatile telco market is always a matter of price, and with SFR due to be split away from the bulk of Vivendi, it will get its own share price and an independent valuation, so perhaps it will start to see sense in a Numericable deal.
Les Echos reported that Vivendi has, in fact, already struck a deal and that drew the response from Vivendi that although they are talking, no such deal has been agreed. The newspaper is suggesting that Altice could hold 50% of the shares and Vivendi could become a junior partner with 32%, with the rest public.
If a deal can be done, Vodafone may well end up sniffing around the public entity that will emerge, especially as it already has ties, and the new entities share price can rise and fall and Vodafone can then pounce when it is ready.