Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 February 2006

Lazard report ads fuel to calls to break up Time Warner

The Lazard report that was commissioned by Carl Icahn to undermine the board of Time Warner, estimates that by breaking the company into four separate entities, it would be worth $145 billion. It recommends a share buy back of $20 billion, and the whole report might just as well have been dictated by Carl Icahn personally, because it agrees with every point that the activist investor has made publicly about the company.

The thrust of the argument is that Time Warner has been risk averse and has embarked on assets sales and debt reduction since 2002, a time when it could have raised far more money and gone after acquisitions and growth.

Hindsight is a wonderful thing, but Lazard’s says that it proves the biggest missed opportunities were in under-investing in AOL, not taking AOL into advertising and new technologies such as search. It also says that no new profit making magazine titles and no new popular TV series have emerged from the group in this time.

The report also points out that central overheads have grown by 40% in the past 4 years, despite much of the function being carried out by central departments being duplicated elsewhere.

Ironically, breaking the company into 4 will create 4 separate and possibly bloated HQ organizations, which might harm profitability, but the report doesn’t appear to address that.

The four companies would be Time Waarner Cable, AOL, Publishing and the existing Networks and Studio businesses. Also interestingly at a time when companies like Viacom are separating TV networks from content creation, Lazard hasn’t also recommended the same split at Time Warner, a missed opportunity in itself, we feel.

The report also doesn’t seem to address the synergies that could be operating already for the group between departments, and even if these are sadly lacking, the opportunity to fix that will also depart with a break up.

The key issue here is not whether or not Icahn is right, but how many US investors begin to lick their lips at the prospect of big share buy backs as well as stakes in 4 separately growing companies.

The detail of how Time Warner stock has underperformed every major index may prove persuasive along with the thoughts that it should have bid higher for both AT&T Broadband, which would have made it the biggest US cable operator, and MGM, which would have given it the biggest film archive. Tactically the Lazard report does deeply undermine the management. If Time Warner carries out any of the suggestions in the report, it will be seen to be doing it out of weakness and a lack of ideas of its own, and if it doesn’t, then these issues will be raised time and time again.

Time Warner’s shares began steadily rising after the announcement and its board is expected to come back with a bankers report of its own to answer some of these claims. Does a rising share price mean that Time Warner has got just what it needed from the Lazard report, showing investors that it is worth far more than was realized, or is it the sharks circling in the water, snapping up any spare shares because they sense blood.

Our own opinion has long been that Time Warner makes no sense as it is for the long term, but content creation needs to be separated from networks, and married to AOL, not divorced.