Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

8 February 2006

T-Mobile relieved over European Blackberry patent trials

International law firm Bird & Bird wanted the world to know that it had successfully acted this week for T-Mobile in the UK in one of the many patent disputes that have been dogging equipment designed by Research In Motion.

This UK legal action was brought by Luxembourg based patent holding company Inpro Licensing relating to the supply of Blackberry devices.

The High Court decision, made public this week, went in favour of T-Mobile and RIM, and Bird and Bird claimed that this meant that Inpro’s UK Patent was now invalid.

Inpro’s patent (EP 0892947) covered a computer system which reduced the processing power used by portable computers and other devices in accessing servers on the internet. It described using a ‘proxy-server’ to download data from the web on behalf of the device. The proxy-server then ‘transposed’ the data to match the specific size and resolution of the device.

RIM applied to the English High Court to revoke the patent on the grounds that it was invalid for lack of novelty and obviousness. Inpro counter-claimed for infringement of the patent and added T-Mobile into the proceedings.

A parallel infringement action brought by Inpro in Germany against T-Mobile was also defeated last week in a German Court in Munich.

None of this relates to the litigation brought by NTP, which threatens to cost RIM upwards of $1 billion, despite the fact that there is a large body of opinion which says that a quite different set of patents relating to email on a portable device, are also likely to end up being invalidated.