Microsoft this week came out all guns blazing against yet another anti-trust decision, this time from Korea which was announced during February, following an outline decision in December. The Korean Fair Trade Commission had given Microsoft 30 days to appeal and it left it until day 30 to make its point.
In the ruling last year, KFTC said Microsoft had abused its market dominant position, violating the country’s Monopoly Regulation and Fair Trade Act and it ordered Microsoft to unbundle Windows Media Player from the Windows operating system, and slapped Microsoft with a $33 million fine.
The appeal is a lawsuit seeking revocation of the KFTC’s decision. Microsoft says nothing new except that the KFTC got it wrong, and the decision is not for the good of Koreans. This case was both about media players, instant messaging and server application integration, with strong parallels with Microsoft’s European anti-trust case.
Microsoft continues to say that since other companies offer their media players free for download, what’s the difference if Microsoft bundles its media player. Of course one of the only reasons that anyone gives software away these days is because Microsoft gave away Internet Explorer in order to bankrupt Netscape all those years ago and then turned the process into a habit.
The Korean case also makes the same point about Instant Messenger software and Microsoft counters that NateOn Messenger and GOM Player are flourishing in Korea.
Microsoft says that it would no longer be able to offer its existing version of Windows in Korea, unlike in the European case, where it was able to modify the version. Microsoft hints that Korean hardware and software manufacturers would find their products didn’t work in overseas markets, effectively hampering their competitiveness.
Microsoft touted its usual nonsense about industry and consumers being best served by the promotion of innovation, which of course Microsoft does its damnedest to stop, or at least own.
The commission began the investigation when local ISP Daum Communications complained. Microsoft has since paid Daum off with a $33 million settlement, and now the Commission is acting on its own.
As history unravels, the fact that Microsoft has bundled its DRM into Windows Media Player is also likely to lead to further anti-trust actions, as it becomes obvious that this has given Microsoft a huge advantage in the digital media marketplace which it threatens to dominate. At least one Microsoft customer has told us that the only reason that they chose the Microsoft IPTV systems was because PCs already had the DRM in-built for nothing.
It has been an underlying principle of anti-trust legislation from when it was first introduced, that a company may not subsidize a new market area from a business that is a monopoly. From that have come two rules of thumb, that bundling two business offerings together, one that is part of a monopoly service and one that it not, is illegal. The other is that it is also illegal for a monopoly to subsidize a new product area by pricing below cost.
Bundling anything for free with a monopoly PC operating system breaks both rules of thumb in one go and is the entire basis for much of Microsoft’s marketing.