Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

29 March 2006

Universal thinks that online films should sell at a premium

The Universal Pictures downloaded film service launched in the UK this week, in conjunction with online partner Lovefilm, is just another example of wrong-headed Hollywood thinking.

The service sounds fine until you reach the price, £19.99 or some $35 per DVD. In the US the average price for a DVD is just $11 to $15 in the UK it is around £13 to £15. The good things about this service, is that it has recent films such as King Kong on it and that you also get a DVD as well as a file that will play on your PC and another that will play on a portable player. But that’s actually where the thinking is muddled.

People either want to download a film for instantaneous play, or they can wait until Amazon can ship them a copy. Amazon UK has the King Kong DVD for $12.99 ($22.70) so if anyone wants to own a DVD long term that’s where they’ll go.

The whole idea of online delivery is that content companies can disintermediate from DVD manufacture and retail. They save themselves the cost of DVD mass production and cut the retailer out of such a generous margin (usually 50%) and the customers themselves can burn their own DVD if they need to. All they need is a file transferred to them that can be used right away on a TV or PC, which can be burned to a DVD, and that can also be slimmed down automatically (by a downloaded application?) to play on a mobile device.

By continuing to go through the DVD manufacturing process and adding the costs of online delivery, the studio is making online film delivery more expensive, not less. That might be fine if it was simultaneous with cinema launch of the film, but not when it is already out on DVD.

Most people wouldn’t care if the file they downloaded could only be played on the device that downloaded it or any devices that could attach directly to such a device. The same for the DVD, most people would be fine if a download and burn to a DVD could only be played on a player that had been registered, so that piracy could be prevented.

What they are not going to be happy doing is paying almost double the going rate to see a film just because they want it online.

The new Lovefilm Universal service starts on April 10 and we can tell you ahead of time that it will be a flop. This is the problem starting a download service with an online DVD company, they want to leverage from their existing business whereby the DVD can be delivered in the post.

A lot of experiments for US studios are now conducted in the UK, with a sophisticated audience, but with less exposure to the US public in terms of setting expectations.

We previewed an existing service launched in February by Lovefilm for online downloads, built around AOL traffic and LoveFilm’s new online content delivery service.

This relied mostly on a few hundred Warner Brothers classics and older films and had the look of an amateur experiment. A company like LoveFilm, which has 50,000 different DVDs available to rent, should not be offering just a few hundred out of date films and we said at the time we expected this service to evolve rapidly, and that one day it might hold a lot of content. Look how little content the Video iPod had when it was launched.

That existing AOL Warner service offered film rental only, not download to own, with the newest film being the oldest Harry Potter film (4 years old) and Batman Begins (available free on pay TV), with files allowed to be stored on a PC for a week and viewed for 24 hours once viewing has started them. Prices started at £2.99 ($5.20) for a full-length feature film and the films come in two download qualities, roughly one twice the quality of the other, which takes twice as long to download. Downloads on a 1 Mbps line are roughly real time, so a 1 hour film will take an hour to download.

Both this service and the new one from NBC owned Universal Studios service are protected by Microsoft’s Windows Media digital rights management software, again because everyone has the client bundled into a PC. The Universal content is currently limited to an initial collection of 35 movies and once again AOL UK traffic will be driven to the Lovefilm site.

Meanwhile Online DVD rental service ScreenSelect.co.uk is offering its members digital short films, including movie trailers, TV clips, viral videos and an exclusive collection of short films made for less than £50.
ScreenSelect.co.uk is offering the features free-of-charge to members.