Only last week we were predicting that Pace would end up posting a decent set of results for 2011, but we reckoned without the impact of the floods in Thailand, which have severely reduced global output of disk drives and other key hardware components manufactured there. It is little excuse that few other analysts foresaw the impact either, which in Pace ‘s case is almost entirely about reduced production of disk drives for its set top boxes by its supplier Western Digital. As a result Pace has warned that profits for the whole of 2011 may not even reach the $150 million set as the lowest bound in May after its second profit warning of 2011. The excuse than was that fallout from the Japanese tsunami had forced Pace to build up its inventory of various components in anticipation of shortages occurring. This meant that while deliveries held up, margins were squeezed by the added costs of having to hoard more parts than usual.
This time events have developed more quickly, allowing little time for contingency measures, so the impact is likely to be on sales as well as margins if it means manufacture is held up by lack of disk drives. Of course Pace cannot be blamed for rains of near biblical proportions in some parts that have severely disrupted Thailand’s transport infrastructure and therefore supplies in turn of components to disk drive makers. However the sequence of events affecting Pace during 2011 give the impression of a storm tossed company reacting to events without adequate contingency plans in place. While Taiwanese based PC makers such as Acer and Asustek are also exposed to the Thailand floods, other hardware makers including Pace ‘s set top box rivals seem more immune to these problems. It highlights both that Pace has a vulnerable supply chain and that it should improve its management of financial expectations.
The first rule of supply chains is that there should be no single link of failure, and Pace did indeed have two sources of disk drives, Western Digital and Seagate. The only trouble was both manufacture disk drives in Thailand, although Seagate was reportedly less affected by the flooding than Western Digital. As it happens, with the monsoon season ending as November begins, this year’s exceptional rains in the area around and to the north of Bangkok should ease, and it may be that Pace’s supply of disk drives is not much affected after all.
But damage has been done to Pace’s reputation not because of any loss of quality or disruption to supply, or even by poor results, but through failing to allow much margin for error in its reporting. If you are an airline or a train operator, you allow a little slack in the timetable to mop up small unpredictable delays. The same should be done in any business run on very tight margins that are susceptible to relatively small perturbations of various sorts, especially in the current volatile financial climate where any failure to meet expectations is punished disproportionately in the stock markets. Pace’s share price stands at 79p compared with a high of 233.9p over the last year, and yet its prospects are only marginally worse now than then.
There must also be a question mark over Pace’s supply chain strategy, given that this has been disrupted twice this year. It is true that the events were relatively extreme, but even more extraordinary would be a year without a major natural disaster somewhere. Pace was unlucky, but the outcome does reflect its Just in Time manufacturing strategy using low cost points of supply, which delivers excellent results in a good year but perhaps is less disaster tolerant.
Still providing Pace can get hold of enough hard drives it does at least have some decent orders in its book. News just in from Argentina is that Pace has shared an order with Technicolor for one million set top boxes from DirecTV for its pay TV operation there. DirecTV is the world’s biggest pay TV operator with almost 30 million customers, and also Latin America’s biggest, with just past 10 million there. The boxes are to be manufactured in the poor and sparsely populated region of Tierra del Fuego with the assistance of a government grant. This is an earthquake and windswept zone, but we hope that neither seismic nor meteorological activity disrupt Pace’s activities there in 2012.