Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

27 October 2011

The job of turning Cablecos from dinosaurs into dynamos

A retrospective with Paul Liao, CEO CableLabs
We noticed a brief announcement last week that Paul Liao, President and CEO of CableLabs would be standing down some time in 2012, and so we called him and asked for a chat. ‘I’m not going yet,’ was the first thing he said, ‘we’ve got to find a replacement first and that could take some time.’

But everyone that meets Paul is overwhelmed by how enthusiast he remains about the cable industry and he said, ‘I’m really glad that CableLabs has been able to support the cable industry in its move to adopt the technologies and protocols of web services and free the industry from the limitations of the traditional set top. Actually it’s amazing to see how quickly this is happening.’

And he’s right, when Faultline began writing about this industry, the set top conditional access lock-in was still being discussed at length, and since then we’ve had the emergence of CableCARD in the US, and CI modules in Europe and now the TV seems to have been joined by tablets and smart phones as targets for all cable TV.

So was CableCARD pushed for by Cable Labs? ‘Cable Card was designed as a response to a regulatory requirement – the FCC wanted to enable multiple providers of receivers to cable companies ‘ but we did lobby in favor of that I suppose.’

‘There will always be a set top for some people, but freeing up the industry has always been a clear target. You know, the original concept of a set top was simply to offer more channels on a TV than a broadcast signal ‘ before that there were just VHF receivers, beyond that broadcast channels in UHF and the large guard spaces between channels. We made the first receivers as cheap as possible but they needed better rejection characteristics ‘ it all took a while’

‘Now TVs have increasingly powerful processors ‘ Intel has just pulled back from providing chips for TVs, but it will continue pushing them to service providers and all the other chip companies have to keep pace with that kind of power, because there is room for a general purpose chip to run applications, but in a CE device the most efficient way of building specialist chips is for the CE manufacturer to design it themselves.’

So how are relationships with set top suppliers like Motorola and Cisco now that cable companies are a little more free to select a broader range of devices? ‘Well they industry never saw them as bad people who locked us in deliberately, they were our suppliers and we relied on them. It was a little bit of both love and hate I suppose. But today there is a broader range of set top suppliers and that came about as players like Pace and Samsung began to get business.’

‘And now not all companies need to do soup to nuts in a set top, one can provide a recommendation engine, another a widget platform. Look at the Horizon device that UPC has ordered. That’s made by a conglomerate of suppliers, it has Yahoo Widgets, Adobe Flash, this is a very different situation from US cable operators ten years ago. CableCard has helped free the industry from being aligned to a single supplier, and now companies like Comcast have pulled a lot of the engineering in-house, and there is a general trend towards using ODMs – create your own reference design and give that to ODMs to bid on.’

To some extent that has been much of what CableLabs has been doing for the wider, generic cable industry, putting out over-arching requirements, getting suggestions from the technology suppliers, putting it into a workable reference platform and then getting handfuls of suppliers to go and build their own. This was certainly the results of the first DOCSIS specs which brought the internet to cable operators, and it is doing the same thing in trying to make cable more of an IP friendly world.

‘I can’t give you details, but in Xfinity, Comcast has taken a recommendation engine from one company and other parts from other companies, this is probably the first time that has happened in the US and it’s happened so fast.’

The middleware in Xfinity is an open source reference design built by CableLabs which each of the set top makers will re-write when it comes to building devices. Liao talks at length about how it relies on a data format called EBIF which stands for (Enhanced TV Binary Interchange Format) and which is designed so that even the very oldest set top boxes, can return a signal to make all cable networks bidirectional. EBIF is part and parcel of the Comcast Xfinity box, which is understood to be built around an Intel CE chip and a custom built user interface from Vividlogic, now a subsidiary of SeaChange International and using the Nokia QT cross-platform application framework and widget engine.

‘To get interactive advertising like that provided by Canoe Ventures, you need a substantial footprint of set tops to be addressable, and they need to have a bi-directional capability. EBIF puts it all in the program stream, which ensures that it gets right the way across any cable network, even if some parts of it are analog, as they often are, and it traverses these and turns back to being digital.’

‘The major cable operators have just finished making sure that all their networks have been cleaned up to accept the EBIF protocol and are secure and they do things like automatically set the right MAC Ids for travel back and forth ‘ we called this process ‘cleaning the pipes’ and for 25 million homes it was completed last year, so it can now start being used.

‘We have trialed a bunch of things using it ‘ an iPad app selects a channel from the guide, and then it routes the selection through the internet to a central server and then an EBIF signal is sent across the network to change the channel ‘ but its faster than Infra-Red even though it travels a lot further,’ said Liao.

It has also been used to display Caller ID on the TV screen, something that IPTV did a while ago and cable felt it needed an answer to. And that works the same way. The EBIF format was chosen because it works on a legacy set top which has almost no processing power or graphics, and runs just 16 or 64 colors, but there are a total of 40 million legacy cheap boxes out there, especially in a lot of analog homes, and it has to work with those too.

‘Now it’s there, we are finding all sorts of uses for it, for instance some viewers remember channel numbers by the name of the channel ‘ so number 4 is NBC and 7 is WADC in some places, and people simply press those numbers. They may have the rights to watch the same channel in HD, but it’s on channel 705 or something, so the EBIF return channel sends out a pop up asking them if they want to switch to the HD version of the channel, and all they have to do is confirm with the select button to make the change. We have to ask them, because they may be recording it and not want to take up HD space, and prefer it in SD.’

Will the cable companies all go IP one day? ‘What’s really intriguing is the amount of computing power that is in every device these days, it’s so dramatically improved and the network connections are so fast and it’s the combination that lets us think about delivering content using IP. But if that was done unicast, in HD, to everyone at once, over DOCSIS, the cost per bit would be enormous – way higher than it would be by the existing MPEG Transport stream.

‘Switched Digital Video is an interim step ‘ it doesn’t broadcast until someone requests it, but there are no advantages of statistical multiplexing that way. We can achieve that with minor changes to set tops, but it doesn’t bring all the benefits of full IP, that will come in two further stages.

‘Right now we see the first phase as offering data over the IP stream, for instance an EPG guide, access to a recommendation engine, but not actually send the video by IP. Typically a hub serves between 100 and 500 homes, if they were all wanting IP video that’s an awful lot of bits. The first steps are interactivity and customizing the experiences of each subscriber and adding IP to CE devices.

‘The second step is to deliver the whole thing over IP but for that the data requirements make those used by Netflix pale by comparison and the service providers would have a serious issue, but also you would need a whole new (expensive) set top.

‘The Comcast Parker box (Xfinity) uses OCAP and normal MPEG video, if IP programming is delivered, it is sent down from the CMTS (Cable Modem Termination System). One of our jobs right now at CableLabs is to reduce the cost of the CMTS to make full IP video possible. We do this by putting various components together, cutting down the space and power usage, we’re currently writing the specs and requirements and between us at CableLabs and with the help of a lot of engineers from the suppliers, we can get the specs down so that it can work.

Will there be a role for Cable Labs ten years from now? ‘I think we’ll be more important than ever, it makes no sense for each of the cable operators to take on the costs all on their own. There are US laws which stop the cable companies from buying each other up and consolidating too much further, and anyway the top 6 companies already have 80% to 85% of all the customers

Paul Liao has been the President and CEO of CableLabs for just 2.5 years and before that he was the CTO for the US end of Panasonic.

So we asked him, ‘So you designed Televisions?’ ‘Not me,’ he said, ‘Any TV designed by me would be awful, it was more that a lot of clever people used to work for me back at Panasonic.’

And finally What does cable think of Google taking over Motorola’s set top division? ‘Google is a tremendous company ‘ overall it could be a boost to our innovation – but the company (Motorola) is being run at arms-length for now, so there has been no input from Google as yet.’