Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 June 2014

Patents must include an invention ‘ US Supreme Court persists

The US supreme Court has ruled on the first case brought before it since it said that just implementing an invention on a computer was not a sufficient differentiation to patent a simple concept in software.

In the past it was thought that under US law if you could put something in software, then you could patent it, and despite the Supreme Court ruling a few years ago that this was insufficient to define patentability, it has now ruled on an actual case, in this instance one that enshrined a business process in software ‘ one used in online stock trading.

We are grateful to UK legal firm Marks and Clerk for bringing this to our attention.

This is now being seen by legal experts to bring the US and Europe closer together on how they see software patentability and here at Faultline we would be fascinated if any of the patents that Apple has used to beat Samsung around the head over the past four years, could actually survive a similar challenge. We suspect that gestures cannot be patented, the basis for almost all of Apple’s successful claims against Samsung.

The US Supreme Court delivered its latest opinion on software patentability, handing down the opinion in Alice Corp v CLS Bank International, saying that the business processes patented, were indeed unpatentable. This is after an ‘en Banq’ review at appeal failed to give us a winner, with a drawn group of ten judges.

At this stage all we can conclude is that for a software invention to be patentable in the US, the computer must do more than merely automate an abstract business method. So just how the invention does this comes into play, with a requirement now existing for an improvement in an existing technological process and an ‘inventive concept’ to be shown before something is patentable. And this will now likely mean that far fewer software patents will be awarded and a lot more of them in future will be challenged.