Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

20 June 2014

FCC begins investigation into Netflix-ISP interconnection deals

The Verizon and Netflix cease-and-desist confrontation we covered last week may have been the final straw for FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler, who released a statement after Faultline had gone to press. In it, he said that the FCC would begin collecting information on the under-the-hood behavior of the content providers like Netflix and the ISPs. This is in direct response to the swirling allegations of throttling and uncompetitive behavior that have dogged the FCC complaints department for several months now.

Wheeler said that the FCC had received copies of the agreements made by Netflix with both Verizon and Comcast, but added ‘to be clear, what we are doing right now is collecting information, not regulating. We are looking under the hood. Consumers want transparency. They want answers. So do I.’

He goes on to quote an email he received from a member of the public, who said that the consumer was suffering and wanted to know who was at fault and if the FCC could do anything. Wheeler noted that ‘consumers pay their ISP and they pay content providers like Hulu, Netflix or Amazon. Then when they don’t get good service they wonder what is going on. I have experienced these problems myself and know how exasperating it can be.’

The FCC wants to reassure customers that they will get their money’s worth out of the ISPs, and to that end Wheeler has given the order to his staff to go forth and find out ‘whether consumers are being harmed.’

‘The bottom line is that consumers need to understand what is occurring when the Internet service they’ve paid for does not adequately deliver the content they desire, especially content they’ve also paid for. In this instance, it is about what happens where the ISP connects to the Internet. It’s important that we know ‘ that consumers know.’

Wheeler stated ‘if adopted, the new Open Internet rules would prohibit bad acts such as blocking content or degrading access to content. This kind of activity within an ISP’s network has traditionally been the focus of net neutrality. But there is another area of Internet access, and that is the exchange of traffic between ISPs and other networks and services. The recent disputes between Netflix and ISPs such as Comcast and Verizon have highlighted this issue.’

Both Comcast and Verizon have previously said that they are asking Netflix to pay the industry standard for peering charges. However, both seem to have missed the point that Netflix has already paid other ISPs to get its video onto the internet in the first place and that Netflix itself runs its Open Connect CDN free of charge to ISPs looking to address the bandwidth issue that peak-time Netflix consumption introduces to a network. It should be noted that both Comcast and Netflix refused to use the Open Connect service, unlike Cablevision, Clearwire and Google Fiber ‘ all of which have enjoyed significant increases in performance in Netflix’s rankings, unlike the performance nosedives that Comcast, AT&T and Verizon have managed since October according to Netflix’s graphs.

The information collection should influence the FCC’s next step in the wake of its court defeat and overturning of its Open Internet rules. Back in January, the 2010 Open Internet rules were shot down by an appeals court judge, who ruled that the FCC had no authority to prevent internet traffic discrimination until broadband is classified as a common carrier service ‘ something likely to take an incredible amount of lobbying and politicking.

In the wake of the January ruling, the FCC must go about finding some teeth to leverage against the ISPs, as it effectively has no legally enforceable tactic with which to proceed and prevent traffic discrimination. It can try to reclassify broadband under Title 2 of the Communications Act as a last resort, but this will begin an incredibly heated and drawn-out process that might take years to complete, if it ever is.

Instead, the FCC will pick the smaller fights to try and win, such as the interconnection deals currently active between Netflix and Verizon and Comcast. Winning these smaller engagements might go some way towards securing the objective of better consumer experiences, but the FCC will want to avoid all-out war until it is the only option left ‘ a guerilla approach rather than marching head-on into the meat grinder and hoping the fight will be over by Christmas. The lobbyists’ pockets are deep enough to drag that process out for years to come, and there are already bills in progress to counter such an attempt by the FCC.