The cable companies, ironically, had the idea first. They wanted access to a mobile network so that they could go after the most profitable margin in all communications services, cellular telephony. They thought of it 18 months or so ago and have been looking for a partner all that while.
At the time it seemed ludicrous. They have no cellular network, they have no wireless skills. How can adding mobile force more services on to a single infrastructure. Instead the cable operators would be forced to work with multiple infrastructures. It seemed crazy.
Now they have come up with Sprint in the US, as their partner, and things are starting to look like they might make sense after all, and in a few short weeks, with other initiatives such as those of Orange and Telecom Italia in Europe, it seems like everyone must now have a quadruple play, where before they had none.
It seems like a matter of weeks since we were all proclaiming mobile as the most profitable service type, and the triple play as the only way for fixed networks of any kind, to merely survive.
But already billions of dollars of share value are being determined based on just how well a telco, cellco, ISP or cable operator are positioned for a quadruple play.
So is this the next war on the horizon ahead, for the hearts and minds of cellcos, once they add wired or broadband wireless broadband services?
The Sprint Nextel decision to use 802.16e WiMAX certainly changes that equation and expectation. Although it has large swathes of 2.5GHz spectrum and not everyone else has this, it has set a new and separate route to quadruple play services, as well as being the most important milestone for WiMAX so far.
Other large carriers have made commitments to WiMAX technology, but none with the definite roll-out plan of Sprint, apart from those in Korea, where the technology was government backed.
WiMAX critics may claim the technology got lucky – because it beat the other majors into TDD spectrum, or because Intel offered such good financial incentives – but the fact is, even with those advantages, Sprint had to select a technology that it believes will work.
And if it works, it becomes a major possibility that other cellular operations will turn to building out a WiMAX network instead of buying an existing fixed line broadband service in their hunt for quad plays.
Sprint’s broadband mobile/wireless quad play strategy is risky enough without trusting to a network that may not deliver. But if it gets it to work to expectation, then every other cellular operator can risk it without being a pioneer.
So now WiMAX looks likely to attract a good handful of large operators – established or new – which are focused on advanced multimedia services. But those pre-4G services will be slow to gain mass, if 3G is anything to go by, and 802.16 also needs real volume. For that, one of its prime targets must be the existing GSM community, where in some markets it can offer an alternative future to UMTS.
And for any operator that has GSM spectrum, but no 3G spectrum, it is a second bite at the cherry.
Winning a large GSM operator over to WiMAX would be “even more profound” for WiMAX than the Sprint deal, as Motorola Networks’ CTO, Dan Coombes, one key architect of that deal, puts it. Uptake of WiMAX by a reasonable number of GSM players – which still control the largest portion of the service revenues of the mobile world – would not only give it the early volume necessary to deliver its pricing promises, but could also hurt the volume projections for UMTS in some markets.
WiMAX has chiefly been viewed with hostility by the GSM/UMTS vendors because it could support new competition to their client operators, in the shape of wireline or media companies that had previously been excluded from the cellular game. But it could be disruptive on two fronts with some key GSM successes – undermining UMTS as the default upgrade path for this sector as well as accelerating the shift of the more advanced markets from 3G towards a quad play world in which many new providers can participate.
Recent research by Rethink Wireless Watch, our sister service has uncovered a rising interest in WiMAX among GSM operators. By 2009, cellcos will account for 22% of WiMAX operators and 17% of capex investment in the technology, up from 9% and 4% respectively this year (Source: Operator spending on WiMAX 2006-9, published July 2006 by Rethink). Of those investing by 2009, over half are GSM operators, which already plan to adopt dual-mode WiMAX/GSM services, with or without a UMTS deployment. Africa will be particularly important in this trend.
Most are in markets where 3G licenses have not yet been allocated, and so they see 802.16 as a potential opportunity to achieve lower build-out costs, and/or to leapfrog UMTS in terms of capability, inching closer to ‘4G’ at an early stage. The Brazilian cellcos are a good example, showing strong interest in using WiMAX instead of, or alongside, UMTS, when their 3G licenses are auctioned. Unlike in Europe, most regulators are likely to follow the US FCC and make new allocations of mobile spectrum technology neutral.
Some more unexpected interest comes from GSM providers in markets where 3G is already underway, but which failed to gain a 3G license of their own. It is hardly a coincidence, then, that the UMTS community has accelerated its efforts to make products that run in the GSM bands, and to lobby regulators to permit these. Ericsson recently demonstrated UMTS running in all nine of its 3GPP-approved bands – the technology has largely been deployed just in 2.1GHz to date. With France likely to be the first European country to allow UMTS to be run in GSM spectrum, the 3G players are clearly seeking to pre-empt a move by WiMAX into those frequencies, as operators face the need to go beyond GSM and move to a next generation service.
Coombes argues that a GSM operator that moves to WiMAX instead of UMTS in 2007-9 will gain a head start in terms of next generation services, since the 802.16e system will be close in its characteristics to LTE (Long Term Evolution), the pre-4G generation of UMTS, which will lag at least two years behind in terms of market availability.
And the support of the consumer electronics industry will also be important to drive new access mechanisms. But of course, in terms of commercial justification Sprint needs to concentrate on cost per Mbps to deliver – a metric it can predict and control far more effectively than ARPU, as the Europeans have found to their cost.
In a world where users increasingly demand more bandwidth for lower rates, if Sprint achieves its aim and delivers broadband services for at least 50% less cost than on EV-DO, it will give another big reason for cellular operators to look to WiMAX. And any such cost efficiency proof would be particularly significant in winning that most coveted of user bases, the GSM operators.