Two years ago we could count on the figures of one hand the organizations that really understood how threatened their existing business models were by the shift from analog to digital media markets. Today it’s not so much the lack of understanding or vision at boardroom level, as the time it takes to prepare for the promised land, that makes many organizations look like laggards.
The digital media market place is like a confluence of at least five rivers, all meeting at one place, and the resulting torrent (not BitTorrent) being too great for all of them to remain within the banks of the new, merged river.
The five segments are communications operators of all types, broadcasters, content owners, consumer electronics businesses and the technology and internet sector. They all have an eye on re-inventing themselves and their business models to take the largest chunks out of future digital media markets.
But the content industry has always appeared to be the furthest behind, perceiving digital formats to be more trouble than they are worth and feeling constantly threatened by piracy.
Content is king, goes the expression, and the content companies appear to have taken the stance that they can drag their heels, without consequence and fail to co-operate in the shift to digital media, unless they get an increased cut.
The low adoption of online films services, DVD burning, VoD licensing, the continuation of geographical DVD regions, DRM adoption, legal actions against file downloaders, failing to cut iTunes deals, the spat over High Definition DVD formats, are all examples of studios dragging their heels. While content’s responses have been to shorten the cycle from theatrical film release to DVD release, and to finally, after three years of thinking about it, allow web giants to offer some of their less important content in ad supported and download for sale experiments. The paid for versions of this are always consistently overpriced.
So if Content is King and it continues to behave in that fashion, then we know what history tells us usually happens to bad Kings, they are usurped and their heads are cut off.
We have always expected this to manifest itself in a number of ways. Cinema returns will get lower per film; actors, directors and other talent will increasingly have to ‘share the risk’ in a film and will no longer command great upfront salaries, and content will overall become less ambitious. After all, spend $200 million on a film, and it is a risk at the box office, but spend $30 million with a decent arrangement on cinema distribution, and with a good 33% of that spent on promotion and advertising, and then success is pretty well assured. On the other hand twenty films like that can’t replace one blockbuster, not without changing the way in which studios do business, their contractual terms, their spending controls, the way they monitor profit on a film, and making the entire management process more scientific.
The same pressures have been seen on TV series’ production. The big money is made by the broadcaster that commission them. The studios can spend $millions on a pilot, but because the TV broadcast networks are under so much pressure to get ratings to drive their hunger for advertising, they can chop a series on one bad episode. The result of that is that everyone in content is looking for shortcuts, cheaper production methods and guaranteed ways of making profit.
One way content companies can do this is to consent to broadcasters using their content on their web site, or to offer it up to internet use directly. Either way there is more money in it for them, and more chance of a guaranteed payback.
Already we have seen internet properties taking TV series that were deemed failures and making money out of them. In the distant past we must remember that Baywatch, one of the all time money spinners in the US, was canned after one series, and only after concerted international pressure was it re-instated in the US. Today it would just make a rude sign at the broadcaster and put the content on the internet and make a fortune.
That type of contradiction, will fuel the internet with some non-TV hits and open the door to better internet experiences in video.
All of this is a long pre-amble to explaining just how Viacom and Paramount felt last week when they refused to renew Tom Cruise’s $10 million dollar a year contract. In the past Cruise would have been finished, would take a few years off, and then come back at a lower tariff, humbled.
But this week, in retaliation, he has signed with an entrepreneur for the next two years, so that he can go on producing films. The problem with actors like Cruise is that no-one has any idea if he can act. Virtually every film he has ever made, and certainly those in the last 7 or 8 years, have relied on big production cost, high quality filming or on special effects.
It’s hard to tell if an actor can act when he is dangling from a 100 foot wire inches from the floor, or diving off the top of a building or sitting on a speeding train, ducking a helicopter. The facial close ups are brief and can be filmed a hundred times, until the actors gets just what the director asked for.
It’s even harder these days to tell if Spiderman, the X-Men or the Hulk can act, and certainly all those Orcs in Lord or the Rings, and both King Kong and Godzilla relied mostly on shock value and awe.
It’s been said a lot these past few years that Hollywood has forgotten about acting, and about people and is too busy making all the films that were impossible to make until it had supercomputers. Now it’s beginning to get almost as bored with this approach as its audiences are.
Last year the US box office was down 5.7% and it has never recovered the numbers of 2002. Even DVD sales are down 1.9% in value, while DVD rentals are through the floor down 6.2% last year, and down 10%, 9% and 3% the previous few years, hence Blockbuster’s plight.
Back in July Disney laid off 650 employees and revamped its Burbank studio to make fewer films, striking fears everywhere that the movie business was actually shrinking.
Of course global cinema audiences are up, but this is because some countries are still building out cinemas, but the number of seats filled per viewing has been going down rapidly the last four years. It’s not that Hollywood is shrinking, but that its old business model, reliant on the cinema, is suffering. Any given film might do okay, but there will come a time, if the trend doesn’t change, (and it won’t), when a film might make a huge profit and every cinema that it is shown in will make a loss. At that point Cinema is dead and the film studios will have no business model at all.
Of course once Disney does not have 25 films, complete with local advertising spend, to throw at cinemas, then those cinemas will have to find content elsewhere. The same applies to Paramount, Sony, Universal, Twentieth Century Fox and Paramount. If cinemas don’t have 100 films plus coming from these giants, then there will be more room for other distribution companies, and their output from independent movie production firms, all funded by private equity and venture capital groups. And the studios have more or less committed to that strategy.
These newer firms may already have their internet contracts in place, their ISP and portal outlet deals cut, their performance based contracts for their talent and cheaper production facilities from improved digital tools. A film can now be edited on a powerful PC workstation, and filmed on far cheaper digital cameras than ever before, complete with pre-edit facilities.
Also the price of animated filming comes down and down too, so that even films that don’t have a human star, like Shrek, are falling in cost to the point where independents can attack that market, and user generated content is now being adapted so that several hundred people all over the internet can work on a film at the same time, in their spare time, and end up making a film for virtually nothing, which means that they can undercut Hollywood.
So the studios are faced with losing their control of the route to market that was cinema, with DVD as back up, in favor of Google Video, Brightcove and YouTube, and at the same time having the price of competing with them lowered.
Meanwhile the studios, bellowing about piracy, insisting on sophisticated DRM, handing out their films at monumental prices for online services and in HD formats, are just undoing themselves. We’ve seen this time and again. The studios should set up their own competition, tiny little Miramax style, entrepreneurial offshoots, that can adapt their own business models and their own rules for what makes good content, and let them loose on the world. But they won’t.
The major studios are standing stationary in a the middle of what Al Gore nicknamed the Information Superhighway, and they’re looking up the track thinking there’s no-one in front of them. But of course there are hundreds of upstarts accelerating behind them. This is the image of an industry about to be mown down by history. The King is dead, long live the King.