The ease with which Sony became the default handheld game purchase has a lot to do with the price it was launched at. Sure Nintendo has made and sold more devices, but the appetite for the Sony PlayStation Portable is clear from every survey taken all over the world, and if available, it would outsell Nintendo’s DS and Gameboy Advance, in one fell swoop.
How it managed to put all of that function into a device which is sold for a basic price of $180 in Japan and $190 in the US is difficult to fathom.
But a piece that ran this week in the Games Radar portal may explain it suggesting that, in effect, both Sony and Microsoft are planning to subsidize their respective platforms the Xbox 360 and the Playstation 3, just to get them down to affordable prices. Perhaps the same principle has been applied to the PSP.
Both companies sell an awful lot of games and in order to provide the games makers with sufficient numbers of devices, it is in the interests of the games companies to contribute something back to the platform owner for each game it sells. That’s the basis of license contracts that each games company signs with the two platform owners, giving them part of the game revenues.
Sony usually takes revenue on something in the order of 260 million games each year. So it can subsidize the PS3 with its PS2 games revenue for a few years and then either reduce the price that it manufacturers at, based on better yields and a better understanding of the manufacturing process and the availability of cheaper components, or it can shift the subsidy over to the PS3 games that will begin to shift in volume.
Games Radar quotes Merrill Lynch Japan Securities saying that the manufacturing cost of the Sony PS3 will be $494 per console, but it will only offer it at retail in the US for $399, some of which has to go to the retail partner. Ouch.
Although we are inclined to think these numbers are pure fantasy, the concept is surely correct. Sony will use games revenues to subsidize the device in order to establish a huge base of devices as soon as possible. Microsoft is therefore forced to go below the ceiling price of the more desirable Playstation 3 and has to do the same.
Merrill claims it has priced the Cell chip and the Blu-ray disk drive and other components in order to come up with the price, but this is a complicated calculation which will relate to how long the device lasts or, what time period the R&D is spread over, the volume of the Cell chip outside the PS3, etc’
The same logic suggests that the Xbox 360 will be quite a bit cheaper, about $75 cheaper to make at around $375, but it will sell for $100 less, with the result being that Microsoft will be subsidizing its platform by $75.
We’re not going to rethink those calculations. Sony is far better equipped to manufacture things cheaply. It’s been doing it for longer, it can use the same components elsewhere in other devices and it is closer to its factories in China and other countries. It also will sell in greater volumes and the promise of that will make companies bid lower for components. So it should take Sony about $75 less to make the same thing as Microsoft, and we think the manufacturing costs would be close to being even, despite the PS3 being vastly superior to the Xbox 360 in pure performance terms.
While the article concluded that this puts Microsoft in a good position, suggesting that the Xbox can do everything that the PS3 can, we conclude that subsidizing devices puts both companies under temporary pressure, and of course the Xbox 360 cannot do a fraction of what the Sony device can. Microsoft has never made a profit at its games division (it claimed to for one quarter) while Sony almost universally makes a profit at its games division (except for one quarter).
The truth is that in the new market, as in the previous generation of gaming platforms, Sony can dictate the price it likes and its devices will sell, and everyone else (Microsoft and Nintendo) has to operate underneath that price line and we have to remember that Merrill Lynch Japan’s job is to shift Sony shares, not Microsoft’s, so it’s figures should be taken with a pinch of salt.
Just remember how low the PSP price was, when most commentators had expected it to launch around $350, and they reached that price on the same basis of adding up all the components that were in it.