Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

5 July 2005

Widevine exits SVP Alliance, saying it’s not good for customers

Very quietly and without a single periodical picking up the announcement, IPTV triple play DRM leader, Widevine, has dropped out of the Secure Video Processor Alliance, the Plug and Play content protection scheme proposed by News Corp subsidiary NDS.

In a statement Widevine said that what was coming out of the Alliance was not in the best interest of service operators, consumer electronics manufacturers, content owners or the consumer, which is pretty much everyone in the chain.

The statement from Glenn Morten, Chief Technology Officer went on ‘we joined the SVP alliance in order to foster low cost, non-proprietary solutions for distributing secure content beyond the set-top-box. Our goal was to explore the options for speeding retail availability of secure video player options.

‘After one year of membership and careful consideration, Widevine believes the SVP Alliance is ultimately not in the best interest of service operators, consumer electronics manufacturers, content owners or the consumer,’ Morten said.

Reading between the lines it looked like it is accusing NDS of wanting to dominate all security issues, and make them proprietary so that whatever else comes out of the Alliance it includes business for NDS and Widevine makes great play about it being the only ‘non-NDS’ digital television security member in the group.

While NDS has both its own conditional access systems used by both BSkyB in Europe, and increasingly by DirecTV in the US, and about 40 other operators the world over, its biggest customers are both part of the same group, its owner News Corp.

Widevine on the other hand controls the DRM system in one of the biggest IPTV rollouts in the world at Chunghwa Telecom in Taiwan, and has more local US and Canadian deals in companies like Sasktel in Canada and Utah Telecommunications in the US, and has some rights to its claim that it is the most widely deployed content security provider for the video over IP worldwide.

The SVP Alliance now has some 22 members and recently added cable operator Cablevision, set top maker Pace and Philips to the mix, along with Amstrad, Sky Italia, and Texas Instruments.

SVP was intended to be an open specification that can be licensed on fair and nondiscriminatory terms by industry players. However, Widevine concluded that the licensing, infrastructure complexity, and security renewal limitations are not appropriate for next generation content protection.

A weakening of the SVP Alliance is likely to mean that offerings such as TiVoToGo, and Comcast’s proposed go-it-alone service, are likely to move ahead of the SVP member offerings.

Two weeks ago NDS was preparing its ‘ready program’ with lead partner Samsung, to its XTV platform which will use the SVP Alliance technology to offload programming to consumer electronics devices led by those from Samsung.

SVP has always said that its outputs could interoperate with other conditional access and digital rights management systems and if this is not the case, Widevine is unlikely to be the only company that will leave the fold.

Other members of the SVP Alliance include AMD, Broadcom, Conexant, Humax, LG Electronics, Macrovision, NEC, Samsung Electronics, STMicroelectronics, Thomson and Twentieth Century Fox.