Sony has just trumped the Toshiba backed proposal to build the next generation High Definition DVD, by pouring its entire DVD operation into a joint venture with Toshiba’s HD DVD partner, NEC, which Sony will control.
The confusing deal sends very odd signals around the entire Consumer Electronics industry. Is this a case of Sony taking control of its arch-rival’s best friend? Or is it Sony making sure it has a foot in both camps to ensure it can make both Blu-ray and HD DVD devices?
We would strongly suggest it is the former and this should be seen as a desertion by NEC from the HD DVD camp. The two divisions will merge in a joint venture controlled 55% by Sony and it will come into being during April next year, just as Blu-ray ships in volume inside the PS3.
On the surface Sony says that it is good at making optical components and that NEC is good at making LSI chips for DVD players, and that’s probably the genuine key driver for this move, that and pure market volume.
In the end the disagreement over which blue laser technology to use in the next generation is probably a sideshow compared to a clever cost cutting, product improving, ramp up by Sony. The combined operation will make better products, and have bigger volumes, taking it to 20% of the global market, which puts it just behind the joint venture between Hitachi and LG Electronics which says it has around 28% market share.
It is logical that Sony increases its manufacturing capability in this way. The last thing it wants is to win the battle for Blu-ray, and then not have a significant market share in the manufacturing side.
The new Sony NEC joint venture will focus on planning, design, manufacturing, as well as marketing to manufacturers of DVD and CD drives for integration into products such as PCs
Sony can both claim that it has further undermined Toshiba’s bid to create HD DVD players, but it won’t be in any hurry to drop the development of the HD DVD technology development and can hold it as a trump card in case anything goes wrong with its Blu-ray efforts. Sony has been seen as betting the entire company on Blu-ray and winning the global standard for video storage for the next two decades.
As soon as HD DVD is dropped, Sony can cut any last pieces of R&D associated with it, but in the meantime it night be tempted to quietly keep the R&D going, but not launch any products. It may even find that NEC ships HD DVD drives before it takes control and then it would have delivery commitments that it would be difficult to get out of, with the embarrassing outcome that it makes both of the new formats, for a time at least.
The deal was announced as a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) saying the two companies would work together from now to reach agreement on a final contract.
In the meantime, back at the war for the next generation DVD standard, the Blu-ray Disk Association (BDA) this week turned down the request from Hewlett Packard, submitted last month, to drop some of the HP code from the specification, in favor of the Microsoft’s iHD and it also reused to offer Mandatory Managed Copy. These are facilities for interaction with the DVD and for copying files from the DVD onto a PC.
The Mandatory Managed Copy lets users legally copy DVDs, and store the digital file on a home network. The managed copy version used on Blu-ray is optional so that content owners can decide whether or not a piece of content can be copied. This really was never in the hands of the BDA really, as its content members have the right to decide if the format forces them to allow copying or just gives it as an option.
If mandatory managed copy was implemented, then Microsoft suddenly takes full control over all the security of the file, making everyone in the group beholden to Microsoft.
HP is supposed to have implied that if the change is not made, then it will support the opposing standard. But if it does, and it implements mandatory managed copy and the studios don’t like it, then no content will come available for that format and only HP will have lost out. So we suspect it’s an empty threat.
Finally, word leaked out from an interview with Sony CEO Howard Stringer, that the forthcoming Sony PlayStation 3 would come out at a price point between $300 and $400, and this would include a Blu-ray player. It’s likely that this is wrong and that the Blu-ray player costs extra.
But even so, this is seen as hugely undercutting the nascent Blu-ray DVD player market which was expected to start at around $1,000. Sony doesn’t mind selling its games players initially at a loss, because it can recoup its investment on its share of the games sold for the device and on the video content.