When TiVo worked with Microsoft on TiVoToGo, using the Microsoft DRM and Media Player to take programs from the TV screen to a portable player, it looked very much like TiVo was firmly in the Microsoft camp.
But with lackluster sales of Microsoft’s portable media players, this week TiVo took the step of making it possible to do much the same with both the video iPod and the Sony PlayStation Portable and eventually with mobile phones. Sony and Apple should ship at least 20 million video enabled devices in the coming 12 months, rising rapidly beyond that and video enabled color screen mobile handsets should ship in their tens of 1,000s once mobile TV services begin launch in the middle of 2006.
The move is primarily an update to the current TiVoToGo software and means that any TV programming, whether it is from cable, satellite or broadcast or even IPTV, can be taken on the road on either of these devices. The TiVo program can be set up so that the entire process is automated and can record programs, transfer them to a PC and on to a portable player overnight.
Currently TiVo is still testing the service, which should go live in the first quarter of next year for its TiVo Series2 subscribers. The company only reckons that about 300,000 customer would be able to benefit from this at first.
But TiVo is risking the ire of content owners once again, and potentially TV advertisers as well by the way it is achieving the transfer.
Jim Denney, Vice President of Product Marketing at TiVo told us, ‘We always try to balance the user experience with the opinions of the content rightsholders,’ shrugging off any likelihood of any major falling out with content owners.
What TiVo has done is bought in a generic MPEG 4 piece of encoding software (it won’t say who is the supplier) and written its own ‘watermarking’ system. Encrypted MPEG2 files that are stored on the TiVo digital video recorder are transferred to a PC running TiVo’s TiVoToGo software. Here it is converted into H.264 (MPEG 4 Part 10 AVC) format. The screen size is also altered by taking the resolution down to Quarter VGA.
As the system writes the new unencrypted H.264 file to the portable player, it also writes the DVR’s device specific media access key into the file, which acts like a secret identity number for the customer on every frame, otherwise known as a watermark. Since all of the qualifying TiVo DVRs are registered and online, if this key turns up in any pirated works on the internet, TiVo will know who’s door to knock on immediately.
Potentially TiVo could disable any online DVR that is used to pirate content, by overwriting the decryption key in the device, but it has not described this process and it may or may not have built in the capability of key renewal and revocation into its system yet.
Effectively, as far as the PSP or the iPod is concerned, it has an unprotected file to play and both will run H.264 files and TiVo has tested the system with these devices. However they could just as easily be run on any mobile phone which supports H.264 files. ‘It is written in generic H.264, so there’s no reason to think it wouldn’t work with a mobile hone, it’s just that we have tested that idea yet,’ said Denney. ‘this is an incremental improvement to TiVoToGo and we wanted to get this working on the iPod and PSP first.’
This method of watermarking is becoming more and more accepted and recently both Widevine and Verimatrix launched watermarking extensions to their Conditional Access and DRM systems that are very similar to this.
One concern we put to Denney was the idea that this process is widely available from security specialists, and that it is relatively easy to defeat, usually done by taking two or more copies of a TV program, made with different DVR’s and by subtracting one file from another, and removing any differences, i.e. removing the identifying media access key data.
‘That can only be done by someone that goes to a lot of trouble to set up as a professional pirate, not by the average TiVo owner,’ said Denney.
It is important that the content world agrees with TiVo on this point and it has been accused in the past of not operating with enough diligence towards the TV world. Most content owners now have contracts with companies such as Macrovision’s Hawkeye and Loudeye’s Overpeer, which will search the P2P networks and look out for pirated copies of their work. At the moment what they do when they find one is they block attempts to download the accurate version. Now what they will need to do is download the file and look at the watermarking to see if the copy was made using a TiVo.
But given that TiVo is the only company that knows how to identify these files, it will either have to offer up its watermarking system to content companies or offer a service to identify pirated content itself. If none of these things happen, content companies may begin to target TiVo itself with legal actions. Which is why TiVo should have gone to one of the generic security specialists to use their established techniques to build this system, then a third party could offer a P2P watching service.
There is also the issue of removing advertising from the portable files. ‘When our software makes these files it leaves the advertising in them. One of the nice things is that fast forwarding on these devices is actually quite cumbersome, so the advertiser is going to get his ad impression across,’ concluded Denney.
Well yes, but isn’t one of the first modifications to these devices gong to be to improve that fast forward feature, and isn’t some independent joker going to come up with an ‘ad cleaner’ for TiVoToGo files? I would expect it in a matter of weeks.
We see two key things in what TiVo is doing here. First it is cutting its primary allegiance to Microsoft on portable players, because there simply are not enough of the devices out there. Secondly TiVo is creating a way to bypass the DRM systems of Apple iPods and Sony’s PSP. There is little that Sony or Apple can do about this, unless it stopped bare H.264 files from being copied to them.
If the content community accepts this move by TiVo then the floodgates will open and this will move way beyond the 3 million strong, mostly US, TiVo community. Licenses for watermarking systems are not expensive or companies can invent their own, and all they need is a PC application that will handle conversion and embedding the key, and a portable player that can read files from a PC and a secure set top or other device identity, then all TV can go on the road.
Already lots of companies find themselves using far more complicated systems that take an encrypted file and re-encrypt it to work in the portable world. EchoStar outputs a conditional access file to a Microsoft DRM enabled Archos portable player. But to do that they had to buy a piece of the French portable device company and control the portable environment.
Similarly the News Corp NDS conditional access subsidiary is working on its Secure Video Processor alliance, doing much the same thing. Here it hopes to set a standard and then work with companies like set top maker Pace and portable player builder Samsung, for the devices. Comcast is known to be working on a similar system of its own, while Sun Microsystems is trying to work towards using the SIM card in a mobile phone as a federated identity management device, so viewers can own rights to content and prove it using their phone.
There are also attempts at DRM interoperability led by companies like Intertrust, Sony and Philips and the interoperable DRM company, the Coral Consortium, which they have spawned.
But in every one of these situations, control of the portable device is required either by designing it in or by creating a DRM standard or by at least placing a piece of software on the device, something that’s rather tricky in the case of the iPod and the PSP.
But if TiVo manages to get its new TiVoToGo to work without legal complaint from content companies, then all of these other efforts to bridge the gap from fixed TV connections to portable devices are doomed as overly complex and expensive, and an avalanche of similar systems will be launched.
The only key, but very important, difference between TiVo’s system and those proposed by others, is that for these customers TiVo has a retail relationship with the equipment user. In most other cases, such as with Motorola and Scientific Atlanta set tops, the customer is the cable TV company which has contractual obligations to content owners to protect their content. TiVo has no such obligations except if its acts were seen as breaking the law by facilitating copyright abuse. Of course, with the arrival of the broadcast flag, if it ever gets ratified, TiVo may well have a major problem.
One thing that this will do for TiVo customers at least, is remove the fee of $1.99 which Apple charges for viewing past TV programs on an iPod such as Lost and Desperate Housewives. If you have a TiVo, those episodes can be copied for portable viewing any time, but not after the program has aired, so iPod will still have an audience or that programming.
Earlier this month Sony added the ability for a PSP to capture TV programs over a wi-fi connection using its LocationFree TV device, so already the PSP can get TV, with some effort, but without a PC. This costs around $350 and it is designed for broadband streaming, although the programs can be stored in flash memory for later viewing.