Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

16 August 2006

T-Mobile, NextWave and satellite TV pushes up spectrum bidding

Auction 66 for the US AWS spectrum is turning into a shoot-out for the prime territories between the national and regional cellcos, looking to boost their spectrum arsenals for 3G services and advanced multimedia launches, and the would-be quadruple play giants, the satellite and cable operators (the other quad play companies, the top incumbent telcos, are represented by their cellular arms Verizon Wireless and Cingular Wireless).

Eight rounds of bidding have taken place already, and under FCC rules, three rounds, lasting 1.5 hours each, are held per day until no more bids are placed. There are 1,122 licenses on offer altogether, including 12 F-block units, large regional allocations of 20MHz each that together cover the whole continental US. In total, there are 36 regional licenses, 352 Economic Areas and 734 Cellular Market Areas. The spectrum is broken up into seven blocks, each with uplink spectrum in the 1.7GHz band and downlink in 2.1GHz. So far, 600 of the territories have received no bids.

The fifth round was dominated by the satellite and cable ventures, but in the sixth round, the cellcos hit back, in particular the regional players and NextWave Wireless, while in rounds seven and eight, T-Mobile emerged as the highest overall bidder. The final rounds will show how far the new challengers, especially the cable and satellite operators, will go to support their quad play ambitions at this early stage, and whether they are prepared to up the stakes against their more conventional rivals.

The outcome will have a profound impact on the shape of US telecoms, helping decide how quickly and broadly the media giants will be able to implement wireless strategies. If the spoils fall mainly to the cellcos, this will give the Bell incumbents a boost in the quad play race, but will ensure that the wireless world remains relatively undisrupted until the 700MHz auction next Spring – giving Sprint and Clearwire, the latter possibly in cahoots with DirecTV, an important headstart.

So far, round five has been the one that best showcased the cable and satellite ambitions to enter mobility. WirelessDBS, the joint bid headed by the satellite television operators, DirecTV and EchoStar, was in the lead after this round. The combination made almost $352.5m in provisionally winning bids (PWBs in FCC-speak, the highest sums offered in that particular round for a given license) for spectrum that covers more than 352 million people.

Second in line was the cellco with the most urgent need for spectrum if it is to make an impact on the pre-4G sector, T-Mobile USA. In round five it numbered $324.68m worth of PWBs, for spectrum covering 285m potential customers, although it has stepped up its game since then. Next came the SpectrumCo consortium, which includes Sprint Nextel, two of its cableco partners Time Warner Cable and Cox, plus Bresnan and Bright House. These bid $212.3m for licenses covering almost 160m potential customers. Cingular rounded out the top four with $123.7m covering 70m people.

Other major bidders, predictably, are the giant cellcos Verizon Wireless and Cingular Wireless, though they are being more selective about the regions they target, seeking to build up holdings in the choicest areas or regions where they have limited holdings. There is widespread speculation that Alltel, the largest regional cellco – which said it would stay out of Auction 66 in favor of waiting for what it regards as superior spectrum in 700MHz to be sold in late 2007 – is actually sitting out because it is expecting an acquisition bid from Verizon, and that the second largest cellco is actually bidding for both companies.

Other top players in the most attractive regions include Dolan Family Holdings – affiliated to Cablevision, the major cableco that remains outside the Sprint Nextel joint venture – which bid $24m in round five on a license to cover some of its home territories, namely the New York City/Long Island/New Jersey/Connecticut/Pennsylvania area.

In round six, the spoils went to NextWave, which emerged from bankruptcy protection last year, having been forced to sell most of its PCS spectrum – acquired in an earlier auction but never used or fully paid for – to Verizon and others. But the company held on to its 2.5GHz licenses and aims to create a WiMAX network, mainly for wholesale use. This plan is starting in California and Nevada, but the company aims to buy sufficient AWS spectrum to go near-national. Although AWS is not an official WiMAX profile, several vendors such as Siemens have already shown implementations of their 802.16 equipment tweaked for the band, and this could well be adopted by winners that have already favored WiMAX in 2.5GHz, such as Sprint/cablecos or DirecTV.

In round six, then, AWS Wireless, which is NextWave’s auction vehicle, emerged as the largest bidder in the round, with three of the highest offers. In particular, it gained the highly desirable Great Lakes regional 20MHz license, as well as a 20MHz license covering 31m people in the Mississippi Valley and another addressing 50m potential customers in the West. The three bids totaled about $344m and snatched the first two licenses, at least temporarily, from the quad play challengers.

The second and third highest bidders in the round were regional operators MetroPCS, which focuses on no-frills urban services, and Leap Wireless/Cricket, which offered a total of $244m and $230m respectively. Leap topped Cingular’s fifth round offer for 20MHz in the North East region, bidding over $130m. These three were followed in this round by Cingular, T-Mobile, SpectrumCo, Dolan Family and Wireless DBS, in that order, in terms of net total of high bids. Like T-Mobile, MetroPCS and Leap are heavily reliant on generous call plans, often with unlimited flat rate voice calls, and so need to ensure their capacity remains up to the task.

In rounds seven and eight, T-Mobile USA – which had been the frontrunner in the first round – came back fighting. In round eight, its net total of high bids was more than four times that of second placed Dolan Family. T-Mobile bid $1.1bn, compared to the Cablevision unit’s $227m.

To total revenue the FCC is expected to take from this auction is anywhere between $15bn and $30bn, though this could take several months. However, if the cableco consortium continues to bid aggressively, despite Sprint’s revelation of very serious plans for 2.5GHz, it may suggest these players wish to keep their options open in terms of future broadband wireless plans.

Top 10 highest bidders at end of round eight:

Bidder Net total of high bids

T-Mobile $1.1bn
Dolan Family (CableVision) $227m
SpectrumCo (Sprint, cablecos) $212m
Cricket/Leap $206m
MetroPCS $178m
AWS Wireless (NextWave) $146m
WirelessDBS (satellite players) $141m
Barat Wireless $47m
Cavalier Wireless $13m
Antares Holdings $11m