One of the reasons US radio is in such a state these days is the fact that many of the 13,000 or so radio stations do not yet use digital signaling. We figure this is as much due to the cost to the stations of upgrading their equipment to the not so new HD Radio standard, as the gradual shift by consumers to new radio sets that use the standard.
One of the biggest owners of US radio stations, Clear Channel, this week said that it has managed to bring up to 300 the number of stations that now use HD radio, which transmits a digital and an analog signal side by side. Modern radios lock onto the analog signal and then switch to digital if the signal is good enough, and a huge increase in radio quality is reported in the US where the technology is used.
Clear Channel says that it expects to offer HD broadcasts on 95% of its stations in the top 100 markets by the end of 2007. Given that it currently owns 1,182 radio stations, around 10% of US radio, that gives it over 800 more stations to upgrade, although admittedly not all of them are in the top 100 markets.
HD Radio technology was approved by the FCC in 2002 as the digital broadcasting system for the US HD Radio and is built around iBiquity’s radio technology using COFDM (coded orthogonal frequency division multiplexing). The rest of the world or at least the top 30 countries or so rely on Digital Audio Broadcast, another COFDM system, which was invented in Europe, and presumably the US didn’t want because it might have put its equipment suppliers at a disadvantage. Although the reason given is that the L Band spectrum DAB uses collides with US Military allocated spectrum. DAB has higher bit rates, and uses a single frequency network, so technically this should mean that it is superior in sound quality and uses spectrum more efficiently, but they are both significantly superior to analog systems.
Both of the digital formats also provide a platform for new wireless data services that, combined with display screens on receivers, can deliver additional data such as song titles, artist names, traffic updates, weather forecasts, sports scores, and the like.
In part the slow speed in updating to digital audio technology explains why satellite digital radio companies XM and Sirius are slowly capturing the entire market for new radio, although that’s a bit chicken and egg really. If the improved sound of HD radios had been out there from the start, and radio stations had switched their signal, perhaps satellite radio would not be such a shoo-in for the car companies that lead their sales.
US radio is being attacked on all sides. Satellite radio, iPods, music phones, internet radio and alternative ways to advertise, such as on the internet, all eat into its pocket, but it remains resilient despite this.
So far, despite huge valuation falls in all radio stocks including Clear Channel and CBS, Clear Channel has continued to flourish, with increases in revenue this year around the same 5% to 6% that all advertising is experiencing across the US. The reason for this is perhaps because although a significant number of listeners are deserting to the new satellite radio channels, and many of these are the more affluent listeners that advertisers target, the advertisers don’t yet have anywhere else to go.
Most of the satellite radio channels do not carry advertising and the localness of the advertising has been hard to replace by internet initiatives, although this is now be affected by advanced search advertising and some of the wi-fi municipality contracts that Earthlink and Google have been chasing. But if US radio arrives more rapidly at digital coverage, it will at least have a fighting chance.