Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

17 January 2007

The iPhone ‘ by any other name, would sell as sweet

The iPhone has caused a kind of madness around the world, and we reckon it goes back to the first time each person used an Apple Mac ‘ some hated it, some fell in love, and that’s perhaps why the world remains divided about Apple.

The US stock markets made good mileage out of the iPhone finding it good enough reason to put $5 billion on the stock. But analysts have universally, on both sides of the Atlantic, shown their true colors. They fall into three camps ‘ those that hated the Mac interface when they first saw it, those that loved it and those too young to remember.

Those that hated it are heard saying ‘ ‘Ok it’s a nice phone, but at those volumes it’s niche and never going to dent the Nokia’s of this world, which is why it’s too expensive. And anyway, who’s going to run Apple when Job’s is too old.’

Those that loved the Mac are saying ‘I just want one. I’m gonna buy one.’
And those that were too young to have ever considered a Mac are simply saying, ‘It’s cool.’

Curiously the iPhone costs the same as a Sony PS3, except without the two year Cingular phone contract. The PS3 is being written off as too expensive, but every single one that’s been made has been sold within about three days of being delivered to a retail store. The question people continue to ask if ‘Ok it will sell 6 million, maybe it will sell 12 million, but after that it will never outsell the Xbox.’

But if the same is true for Apple, then it will be plain sailing. If it can sell anything like 12 million of these devices by the end of 2008, then it will easily have made, at these prices, all the money that it wanted to make from its ‘first’ handset.

Had any of us looked (and we did) at the iPod before iTunes had launched, then we would have wondered if it would EVER sell more than 4 or 5 million. But history shows what happened once iTunes came along.

So if there are 800 million or more handsets sold each year, Apple may only be shooting for a 1.5% market share at first, but you can be sure that it will eventually be looking at a ‘double figures’ market share, which would catapult it to 80 million to 100 million devices a year.

Our own sister paper asked the question, shouldn’t Apple do a partnership deal with Nokia to give it the sorts of volumes that Apple may one day need to make it a global handset success? But Apple is too dangerous for the next five to ten years while Jobs it at its helm even for Nokia to play with it in our view.

It has introduced a new handset operating system. Which Nokia can do without. It has made the device dependent upon attachment to a PC for its songs (temporarily), and it has gone for a touch screen interface, something that none of the other handset makers had dared consider, until now.

For all those that hate all things Apple, there is no respite. The day of the touch screen are about ready to arrive, Apple has dared call it first. The day of the switch screen has arrive, and Apple has been the most imaginative in how to use it. The day of 8 GB handsets has arrived, but outside Korea, no-one has shipped any.

So will everyone follow? We don’t think so. It will take Nokia, Samsung and Motorola 9 months before any one of them dare to copy the features of the iPhone. They can all see what’s wrong with each of the innovations, what they will be unable to see is the blind staring glare of the public chanting ‘I want an iPhone,’ not until Apple has orders for 6 or 7 million of them, and by then it will be almost too late.

Jobs is exceptionally impressive and will be monitoring the strategy. He knew that making a phone the same as everyone else would be madness, he didn’t have the volumes, the manufacturing clout or the global operator contacts. So he based the thing on risky elements of design, and of course in incorporating iPod capability.

By the time the rivals deign to respond, he will have introduced a 3G version and added more function and slashed the price due to volume ordering from around the globe.

This is not about Apple , in the next few quarters, denting Nokia, Motorola, Samsung or even Sony Ericsson. But it is about doing that eventually, by stealth, over time, and the Apple key weapon is going to be the ability to make people leave their cellular operator for another, just to get their hands on the iPhone.

But will it, in fact, continue to be called the iPhone. On the legal front Faultine got it wrong last week, when we said that presumably the documents that Cisco had admitted they had sent Apple as an offer to buy the name, had been signed.

Our take on that is fairly straightforward. A deadline for launch was looming and Cisco chanced its arm. It either asked for a lot of money, or it asked for the opportunity to have access to the famous Apple Fairplay DRM system. Whatever it asked for, it was a function of the looming deadline. Apple clearly consulted lawyers and thought that the risk of doing the deal outweighed risk of not doing the deal, and just went ahead and launched.

We think this was smart. Don’t commit yourself under deadline pressure but keep talking. Cisco claims to own the name iPhone, but has to prove that Apple is ‘passing itself off’ as Cisco. That’s going to be exceptionally hard to prove, since there are no Cisco devices actually called iPhone, only some vague references on advertising material, which aren’t exclusive at all, since other VoIP providers have also used the name and not been taken to court.

If Apple proves that, and its executives have been quoted in the press saying as much, then it would mean that Cisco cared nothing for the name until someone came along that had a better claim to it than it did. That’s not a basis for a big court win.

But on the other hand, Apple needs to keep its partners, such as Cingular, free from injunction pressure. It should pay something to Cisco for the name, but that amount should relate to how much Cisco has made of the name ‘iPhone’ in the past, not how important it is to Apple.

Think of all the people that you have heard saying how cool the iPhone is. Now imagine any of them NOT buying the device if it changed its name to the iPod Phone. Not many.

And the truth is that Apple might even be able to prove that the term iPhone, when used to refer to a cellular device, is unique, in the same way that its iMac is already used as a trademark for footwear and the iPod is already used for financial software. A clever attorney may even convince a court that the re-emergence of the iPhone brand name in the Cisco product line, so close to the iPhone launch and after 7 years of disuse, should be viewed as capricious and having no foundation in prior use. There’s probably enough doubt to push both parties for an early settlement and very little chance that any US judge would uphold a request by Cisco to halt Apple iPhone shipments

So the threat’s largely hollow, and the outcome will be a small payment from Apple to Cisco (small but in $millions), probably before the June iPhone shipment deadline, but largely it’s a non-event.

The other litigious outcome from the iPhone launch has been that already there are hundreds of iPhone mimics turning up on web sites, with devices that are being made to look like they are iPhones. Now that IS passing off, and Apple is already stamping on it. So far this is just bloggers making existing devices look like an iPhone for a cheap photo. We predicted that Apple would file for a patent on the look and feel of an iPhone, and it’s likely that it already has. That would mean that when copies begin to come to market from real rivals, Apple will be picking over the designs to ensure that no-one, not even companies twice its size, can benefit from the distinctive look and feel.

Because Apple is basing its device almost purely on design concepts, not new technology, it’s almost certain to actively seek a legal action to prove that it actually holds intellectual property around this design, so expect someone to be targeted just as soon as it clears the Cisco challenge to the iPhone name, if not before.

The name dispute aside, the iPhone has one clear advantage. By the inclusion of up to 8 GB of flash memory, Apple continues to be the biggest global user of flash memory chips and its agreements with 6 separate Flash suppliers last year, along with large advance payments, meant that Apple secured volume discounts for Flash memory beyond even those of handset makers that have the volumes of devices that Nokia has. And Flash can be a large part of the manufacturing cost of such a device.

It could be that when Apple rivals start to count the cost of building a phone that has most of the capabilities of an iPhone, that they find it’s not quite so easy to undercut the cost that Apple has for making these phones, even if it is, it may be child’s play for Apple to undercut its current price.