Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

17 January 2007

The Venice Project becomes Joost, as more details, and rivals emerge

Reports have emerged this week, on both sides of the Atlantic about the precise details of the P2P internet TV service which is being built by internet entrepreneurs Niklas Zennstr’m and Janus Friis, who have already brought the world Kazaa and Skype.

In essence one thing has changed, the name, which has gone from The Venice Proect, to Joost, as the company that the two peer to peer specialists have built, gears up for imminent launch. And this week Friis has begun giving the odd interview.

Side by side, coming out of Ireland, is a rival to Joost in Babelgum, a project driven by Silvio Scaglia, one of the founders of the now famous Italian IPTV pioneer Fastweb, and Scaglia has also been giving newspaper interviews this week, after spending 18 months, and a small fortune, building his own internet TV system, also around P2P technology.

Scaglia was reported as having just sold €220 million of shares in Fastweb to continue to fund the project personally.

But Joost is the more anticipated of the two projects, and Friis and Zennstr’m are working on it in their spare time while still working at eBay which bought Skype from them last year for what should be $2.6 billion, if they hit all their numbers in their earn out.

Interestingly, when we heard it was called The Venice Project we put that into Google and came up with a film of the same name. Ironically Friis is quick to point out that none of the founding group realized this, and had simply named the project after the conference room it was born in.

Reports have the Joost system’s data rate at a lowly 400 Kbps downstream and around 100 Kbps upstream. It breaks video down into chunks of around 10 seconds of video for storing and uploading. The Babelgum system appears to run at closer to 700 kbps, which would cut out some of the lower end broadband lines, but perhaps it is rate variable and we will, over the coming weeks, try to get our own interviews to check out some of this detail.

Both systems have plenty of admirers in their betas, prepared to testify that the quality of the video is pretty good, almost but not quite TV quality, and fine for the slightly smaller PC screen, especially laptops. Now that it going to take some explaining at those download speeds, but essentially none of this video is being encoded in real time, which means that several passes can be made at the finalized stream to see if it can benefit from further compression and different encoding approaches.

Both systems seem to have DVR controls, so play, skip, fast forward, reverse, etc… and Joost features a translucent program guide which arrives when the mouse is moved and disappears when it is left alone.

Friis is saying that there can be an infinite number of channels, but quite clearly from the interviews published, he is really targeting the professional video owner and not User Generated Content. And of course a TV channel in this world is simply a playlist really.

The Joost system also has a palette of widgets which look more at home in a social networking arena, including buddy lists, the obligatory instant messaging, and options to rate the video you are currently watching as well as tools to share it with specified members of your playlist.

The area that he is less keen to talk about as yet is the ‘Content Owner’s’ area, but this has been certainly well targeted and is probably the reason why Joost will get a big hearing in the coming months and years, because of its approaching to advertising.

While companies like Google and Microsoft have said that they are chasing addressable advertising across multiple environments ‘ gaming, internet, radio, newspapers and TV ‘ Joost just does a good job of laying out the advertising possibilities for the future content owner. We get the impression that Joost can be used by content owners to offer paid for content with no advertising, and initially at least, Friis says it will be launched with a maximum amount of advertising (1 minute per hour, whereas most .tv services are 12 minutes per hour).

But it looks to us that Friis and the 150 people that he and Zennstr’m have working on this, see it as a huge transplant of the free to air model that national footprint broadcasters have always preferred. We’re not sure the exact demographics that Joost can work with, but the impression we get is that advertising can be regionalized, it can be targeted at specific age and sex demographics, it can be time of day focused, first or second ad of the day based or the adverts can be issued whenever a particular program or genre of programming is on. And the beauty of all this is that like some other advertising specialists before them, Joost has opted to send an anonymous encrypted profile of the viewer out onto the supernode held directories that run this, and advertising is fed on the basis of these profiles, none of which are ever viewed by humans, and none of which contain any identification details.

Presumably the nodes that serve the advertising keep track of how many they have sent, and to which profile definitions and when, and send a bulk summary to the content owner, so there’s not need for any Nielsen Media to report back on who is viewing what.

The content is served into this maelstrom of video snippets by a handful of mirrored servers, who’s job it is to put content onto the first requestors and into the supernode held directories of which TV is available. A supernode in the Joltid P2P speak is a PC with enough spare cycles and memory to temporarily store a piece of the critical data required to run a service such as Joost.

In this case it looks like it is handling all of the jobs of the ad serving network, which can require considerable weight of server power. In Skype it looks after the live directory of attached Skype users, spread over thousands of machines. It is possible that the Skype supernodes could already be used as a resource to do this and Joost may not require time to build up its own fans, in order to have powerful video services.

Eventually content owners will take their own decisions about uploading to Joost, and manage the process themselves without any help from the Joost team, but all of the beta traffic has been loaded by them so far.

The advertising side seems to be the main difference between Joost and Babelgum, in that the Joost team has thought in some detail about a business model, backed one they like, and enabled it, rather than only focus on making the PC look and behave like a TV.

In Faultline’s view all of these services are a bit late. There have been multiple attempts at hosting professional content ‘ BrightCove for one, Narrowstep in Europe for another ‘ but they have found it tough going and mostly niche content has taken up their services. Since then the big TV channels in the US such as CBS, NBC and Fox have each come up with their own, mostly server based strategies, while in the UK the BBC and ITV have partnered with their own P2P software supplier in Kontiki, now owned by Verisign.

Their lateness doesn’t mean that they will automatically fail, but it does mean that in order to get a large amount of relevant content, they will have to prove their worth with less than top grade content, and prove irresistible to the larger studios, somewhere down the road.

Just who owns Joost has yet to be fully established, given that eBay has a kind of policy to promote its people working on new and exciting things, but clearly will require that it benefits directly. Chances are that ownership will fall to the Skype twins, eBay and current talent on the project, in some balance, with perhaps an option for eBay to buy it out in the future.

But even if this is successful, we’d expect a slow burn, even Skype took almost a whole year to pick up the kind of momentum that got it noticed by all telcos, but then again it had a much smaller development team and limited resources and required a lot of coding. Joost is based, says Friis on the Joltid P2P architecture, plus a bunch of existing open source standards and programming, and a little extra hand crafted code.

Also no-one has yet talked about how the system checks whether or not the uploaded file belongs to the person putting it into the network. Certainly the servers will provide an audit trail to check, but will the system include content signatures and copyright filters. We’d bet that if it does, this work will also be done out there on the network by the universal workhorse for these guys, their supernodes. And if it doesn’t then their claims that this will be the most legal platform on the internet, won’t hold up.

Also it looks like Joost plans to sell its own advertising, and if this beta goes on to have the success of Skype in download numbers, that advertising amount could one day grow to represent something that Google feels is rightfully its own.

And also how exactly will the Joost team stop viewers holding permanent copies of the content that has played out on their PCs, by finding and holding onto the encryption key, so they have permanent copies. The best way to be sure of this is for the content owners to place watermarks on the video, so that it if re-appears on the internet file sharing networks, they know that the Joost system can be broken.

The first up content that will be used to snare bigger content will be sci-fi, rock videos, sports and comedy, which is aimed at the youthful male, and if Joost proves that it can attract them, the next thing you’ll see is a bid for movies on a grand scale, turning the internet into a global multi-screen cinema, paid for by advertising or entrance fees or both.