Your browser is not supported. Please update it.

1 October 2015

TiVo’s legal defense already planned out for SkipMode

Let’s make no bones about this, US national broadcast channels NBC, CBS, Fox and ABC, just have to sue TiVo over its new ad-skipping feature, just like they tried to with Dish’s DVR AutoHop – although TiVo might have a few defensive tricks up its sleeve.

If you missed it, TiVo’s new Bolt set top has some interesting new features and most notably, aside from its crooked shape, is “SkipMode” – the ability to skip entire sections of ads with the press of a button.

Yes, it sounds virtually the same as AutoHop, which quickly came up against legal barriers in the form of Disney’s ABC, CBS, NBC, and Fox, claiming “unauthorized use”, and is partly responsible for the demise of TiVo’s old rival, ReplayTV, many years ago.

A potential advantage for TiVo is that when Dish did this, it was also a broadcaster which had to negotiate for retransmission rights with each of its antagonists, hence the accusatory networks threatening to scrap Dish’s ability to broadcast their shows. Dish eventually agreed to make its ad-skipping feature available a week after the original broadcast for CBS and three days after the air of ABC content.

It may sound like TiVo is entering dangerous territory, however, TiVo says its own ad-skipping feature complies with the law as it is essentially a more efficient way of fast-forwarding. By this, we assume TiVo means that SkipMode requires human involvement; instead of programmatically reading signal meta-data and automatically evading ads, a team of staff will view the top 20 networks, from 4pm to midnight, to flag the beginning and end of ad breaks. Then, while watching a flagged show, viewers can click the D button to activate SkipMode.

TiVo also has its audience research and measurement (ARM) technology in its arsenal. ARM was originally designed to offer advertisers second-by-second data and analysis on DVR viewing of advertising content, but TiVo also records all the data on fast forwarding and will be able to present this in a court of law showing that it was merely supporting a consumer behavior that was entrenched.

TiVo’s legal team is pretty clued-up when it comes to patent cases – with TiVo winning a case lasting from 2004 to 2011 against EchoStar for DVR technology patent infringement, and more recently filing infringements against Samsung. Also in the past, its patents have tripped up AT&T, Verizon, Cisco and most especially Dish, to the tune of about $1 billion in payouts. If the likes of NBC and CBS do launch their attack, it will be interesting to see how TiVo’s legal gurus fair on unfamiliar ground.

OTT market leader Netflix is what has changed consumer expectation on advertising in the OTT video market. It has always maintained that it will never add advertising as part of its monetization. Of course, if Netflix decided to change its mind this would reduce the subscription cost, but consumers would rather pay the extra fee for the convenience. Faultline recently published results of a survey that found, of 60,000 respondents, 45% would prefer to pay just to avoid seeing ads.

Many more people have DVRs now from when the legal battle between Fox Broadcasting and Dish Network began two and a half years ago, and when word spreads of ad-free TV, broadcast channels will need to find more revenue streams or they will die out. The irony is that wealthy people are the target population for the majority of ads, but are the same people who are to be first in line to buy the latest piece of technology – such as ad skipping.