Over the past three weeks we have made a fuss about the inclusion of the Cryptography Research Inc (CRI) CryptoFirewall in the core Broadcom and ST Micro set top chips. Our view has been that it is effectively the only open security segment of set top chips that can work with multiple operating systems, multiple DRMs and on different flavors of chips ‘ effectively an openly available, cheap smart card.
Now it turns out that Sigma Designs, another of the major set top chip players, is planning to offer the CryptoFirewall in its own chips
CRI has a track record in open cryptography and has licensed hacking countermeasures which are used on 5 billion smart card chips. The company was sold to Rambus last year for $342.5 million, a company that has turned into something of a patent holding company. The other major CRI achievement is to provide perhaps the strongest of three piracy counter measures in Blu-ray disks, before that division was sold off first to Rovi and then on to Irdeto..
Sigma VP of Corporate marketing, Michael Weissman, told us via email, ‘We are excited about the Cryptography Research technology. As of today, Sigma has not implemented Cryptography Research in our chips. Our philosophy is to incorporate the technology our partners and customers demand. We are now seeing some real interest from customers. Therefore, as we move forward with new designs, we will incorporate CryptoFirewall into some of those designs.’
This is something of a turn around since our discussions with him at IBC, when he insisted that Sigma had its own on chip security measures and shows that things are moving fast.
There are other set top chip makers around, but given that these are among the top set top makers in the West this is likely to lead to a clean sweep of CRI inclusion, and the potential to revolutionize set top security in a dramatic shift away from a separate external smart card architecture.
The ST Micro 7108, ARM based set top superchip and the new generation of Broadcom 74XX top of the range MIPs based HD set top chips have both included the design, potentially to be used to entirely replace smart cards in conditional access systems.
Our bet is that one or two proprietary chip components from NDS and Nagra, will live on, and that the rest of the market will shift over to the CRI core once it is widely available next year. The critical step has been the 250,000 logic gates that the system needs, which is only possible at 65 nm designs and only practical at 40 nm, which is the current design target for next gen set top chips.
Broadcom told us that IBC that it has had 85 different security blocks in its chips and that they come and, go but we understand that these are mostly encryption accelerators. At IBC CRI, also announced that both MStar and Trident have licensed CryptoFirewall for integration into their SoC set-top box chips, so that makes 5 design wins in as many weeks.