People often talk about German efficiency. One of the many things in Germany that appears to be efficient is what we tend to call its Cartel office, which Google translates into Federal Cartel Office, and who’s precise name is the Bundeskartellamt.
We say this because it actually understands a) what a cartel actually is, unlike many global authorities, and b) actually tries to do something about them and it has now stepped in to investigate plans from public broadcasters ARD and ZDF to launch a joint online video on demand platform. Just a few days earlier a final no has been given to a similar online video platform for RTL and ProSiebenSat.1, which originally got a once over by the Bundeskartellamt back in March.
ARD and ZDF are public service broadcasters in Germany and have about 39% of the free to air broadcast viewing hours across all Germany, while stations owned by RTL, itself controlled by the influential Bertelsmann Group, and by ProSiebenSat.1, control approximately 43% of viewing figures. Between the four groups they have in excess of 80% of all free to air viewing in Germany.
Not only that, but they have all been pushing a new online standard HbbTV and have been actively broadcasting HbbTV content since 2009. So they have pushed a standard, which they effectively control, in order to control the online world of video. An investigation into that could be next.
ProSiebenSat.1 has recently announced a new HbbTV video center, providing 2,300 short highlight videos, and its vanilla online web video service Maxdome has far more content. ARD and ZDF are public services organizations which receive public funding through a government mandated license fee.
ZDF has said earlier this year that the number of users of its three video web sites was six million at the end of March this year. But again there is no indication anywhere of the number of unique visitors which are from HbbTV services. The Bundeskartellamt really does have our sympathy on this one and it may have more work to do before it dissuades the four from trying to illegally control the market.
The actions of the US authorities, by comparison, appear timid. For instance in their behavior relating to AT&T and its rise and rise back into another US nationwide ‘almost monopoly.’ The Justice Department has been educated by too many reversals in court, so that now it feels it has to gather evidence, not only in order to make a decision, but in order to defend that decision in court, once it is made.
We would ask the question (and we did in an article at the time) is Hulu actually legal? It is put together by a broadcaster content group that controls close to 75% of the original, non-local, broadcast content in the US. And yes it is this near monopoly which actually has the temerity to block Google? While no-one in the US has done anything about it, primarily because Google is feared as a monopolist even more than this group. Meanwhile in Germany the Bundeskartellamt, is all over the two separate 40% clubs.
Hulu is owned by broadcasting favorites Fox, Disney’s ABC and NBC ‘ only CBS is missing from among the major broadcasters ‘ except that its content is not actually missing, and if it asked to join in, it would no doubt be allowed, except that it might make the cartel nature of Hulu a little too obvious.
Of course this content is not only dominant in the US, but because US content is dominant in other TV channels across Europe (and much of the civilized and not so civilized world), Hulu should never have been allowed to be shown in Europe. In fact European success has been blocked by the fact that its US broadcast parents have already licensed their content exclusively in each of the major European countries, and local broadcasters have refused to relinquish that content or go into partnership with Hulu. In the end this has led to the business’ demise and it was put on the block, only to find that its value was not high enough for the broadcasters to sell it off, so they continue to sit and ponder its future. But still it’s content IS on show in Japan and till reach god knows how many other countries.
In the UK this might have happened too, but not in Germany. The existing broadcasters always want to make their club a very exclusive one, expensive to join, one of the very definitions of a Cartel (actually the definition is a combination of independent business organizations formed to regulate production, pricing, and marketing of goods by the members), but in the case of the UK, where Project Kangaroo was suggested by the BBC, a company funded by a Government Act, and therefore separate and aloof from the consequence of the commercial reality in European media (a tough market right now). That project WAS blocked, and it was the closest thing to Hulu in Europe so far ‘ all the major broadcasters, both the successful public broadcaster and the richest independents (who pay tens of $millions a year for national broadcast capability, not to mention content rights) all working together in a single online TV service.
We said at the time that this would mean an end to any new generations of online video services, and lead to stagnation and a continuation of the status quo.
There are many people who think there is not a lot wrong with the status quo. Or is there? Apple is credited with changing the way we think about mobile phones, but many of the existing handset makers had similar projects on their drawing boards when the iPhone came out. AT&T would have told Nokia to take a hike if it came out with a device like the iPhone ‘ instead it had to come from an outsider who really, really believed in what it was doing and negotiated hard for it. Nokia actually came out with a revolutionary tablet several years earlier but couldn’t get distribution for it, and when it failed, Nokia fell back to relying on its existing devices.
It’s the same on internet video. It will take decades to change the video exploitation model and we have to let existing companies have a say, but the true innovators are not existing production crews and studios, they are companies trying out whacky things on YouTube. They haven’t worked out how to insert that into conventional TV so that it becomes a threat to traditional broadcasters or studios, and so far the most popular new age videos are dumb time-wasting things like the Annoying Orange, but there is some innovation is in there somewhere and it cannot come out if all content routes to market are sewn up within the status quo.
The internet (usually) lets audiences dis-intermediate a process. It gets audience feedback to the developer quicker. It should make for instant hits in video, and the audience should even perhaps interact with creators in the development process. But the internet hasn’t touched video creation processes. Not yet.
The same US broadcasters are still those which are dominant as before the internet arrived, and the same US studios make money and dominate global movies, as before the internet arrived. It would be a shame if the creation and exploitation processes of quality video stayed entirely the same as they transition from being delivered in cinemas and on DVD, to being delivered over the internet.
If the same companies are dominant after movies and TV shows go online, it would mean that one generation of companies, the generation that had no new ideas to contribute to internet delivery, just carried on, safe and sound in a status quo, purely because financial regulators failed to step in. Politics so often gets in the way of examining these types of thing in court and when they are examined, they are so often examined against a set of laws that have not changed in 100 years.
If ALL the US broadcasters were involved in Hulu it would clearly be illegal. If all the US studios were involved in kneecapping Netflix (not just Disney and Sony via Starz), all acting together, that also would stink of concerted action. Which is why only 3 out of 4 broadcasters do anything together and 3 out of 5 (6) major studios.
You almost get the impression that the US broadcasters and studios collude in order to demonstrate that they are almost, but not quite, colluding. Is the reason that Viacom has pursued Google single-mindedly and on its own, so that Google has no basis to cry foul? Is the only omission from Hulu CBS, just so that there is one odd man out to prevent it being called a monopoly?
Anyway we digress. In Germany this wouldn’t be allowed, because they are efficient and they actually have an office with the word Cartel in the name, which would make shirking the outing of Cartels a little tough.
The office said it will investigate if plans impede competition with regards to production and licensing as well as the possible effects on viewer numbers. It also added that the ARD and ZDF offering (called Germany’s Gold) is similar to its
investigation into RTL and ProSiebenSat.1. The idea was that these two would own it, all their programs would go on it, in order to make it one of two dominant services (the other from RTL and ProSiebenSat.1) and then other production companies could use the service for distribution ‘ except it would have been in a position to dictate price and terms. We cannot see how one of these could get a license if the other is blocked.
It was however originally passed, but that was because it did not amount to a service which could control advertising, since ARD and ZDF are funded by the public license, whereas RTL and ProSiebenSat.1 would have also brought advertising dominance. RTL and ProSiebenSat1 are effectively a duopoly in German TV advertising holding between 80 to90% of the market. Despite this the example from the US market is that you can fight such a move through a court, and RTL and ProSiebenSat.1 have now taken legal action against the Bundeskartellamt’s decision. It will be interesting if a German court will believe it’s okay to overrule such a fine a German institution.