Liberty Global CEO Mike Fries flew into the heart of Germany for potentially one of the toughest panel discussions in his long career. And at Faultline we missed it, so luckily a blog from SNL Kagan reporter Michiel Willems picked up the cut and thrust of the argument, which we quote from here, with his permission.
Fries was live stage at ANGA COM, one of Europe’s largest events for the cable industry, and he lashed out at the current regulatory climate in Europe, having been on the wrong end of it in his opinion.
‘Regulators have never done anything to make the Internet great, and I don’t see how they will do that in the future,” he said bluntly. Fries was on the wrong end of a Federal Cartel Office decision about his company’s acquisitions in Germany.
Liberty Global took over German cable operator Kabel Baden-Wuerttemberg and at the time was forced into several concessions by the German Federal Cartel Office before it could complete the deal. But after the fact, last August, a German court overturned the antitrust approval for the acquisition, a decision sent shockwaves through the industry, especially since Liberty had already merged Unitymedia and Kabel BW into Unitymedia KabelBW.
Fries has said on a number of occasions that he expects the German regulatory climate to “soften overtime,” but he was not in a conciliatory mood at ANGA. He called regulatory intervention in the Net neutrality debate ‘counterproductive.” Referring to proposals that were recently adopted by the European Parliament, which introduce a range of measures that will promote Web neutrality, Fries said the whole issue of Net neutrality is “widely misunderstood and abused,” although we suspect that the biggest misunderstanding is by him, and it is rather deliberate.
But on the panel this prompted Peter Weber, corporate counsel at ZDF, public service broadcasters in Germany, to state “I am in favor of Net neutrality,” adding that the regulator should take its role “very seriously.” Weber seemed to take up the role of antagonist to Fries.
“To pretend that we do not need any regulation at all, and just let the big companies take over, we cannot afford that,” said Weber.
Fries said that customers being discriminated against was a ‘a red herring,” suggesting instead that Net neutrality is an issue between companies, not consumers. That’s fine to say until you can’t afford a Google search.
“Net neutrality has nothing to do with consumers. It is about who pays the billions of dollars to build highways and whether we pay them all by ourselves or whether we share the cost of the highway with everyone who wants to go down it at 100 miles an hour,” Fries told the crowd. Strangely though he wants to build it and charge everyone for using it, but then charge companies on it all over again.
If content providers would like to reach a deal with Liberty Global or any other cable provider “for fast lane access, then they should be free to do so,” he said.
While there were other executives from cable giants on stage, including the CEO of Vodafone Group owned Kabel Deutschland, they kept quiet. The fact that the German panelists, all but Fries, opted to speak in their native language did not help the debate.
So it became Weber consistently responding to Fries, saying a certain level of protection through regulation should exist. “Some discrimination is needed; we should not be slaughtered,” he said, although whether he was referring to broadcasters or consumers here is unclear.
Asked about Liberty Global’s mobile aspirations, Fries said he wanted to make “a more general statement” regarding the state of the telco sector in Europe.
“The mobile industry in Europe is in trouble,” he said, to the laughter of some audience members. ‘The industry is not competitive, not many people are making money here.’ By here he meant in Europe.
Comparing the European telecom industry to the US, he pointed out that there are around 120 operators currently active in Europe, while there are only five in the US. Fries obviously thinks this is good for the US economy, despite the fact that every economist bemoans the lack of competition in the US for the reason its operators are so complacent, and why they cannot work effectively outside the US ‘ because outside the US there is real competition.
‘In Europe, consumers are winning as the highly competitive climate forces prices down and gives consumers many choices. Perhaps so much choice that it is damaging the industry,’ said Fries.
Therefore, should Liberty Global decide to expand its currently small mobile operations in Europe, “we are going into mobile carefully, we want to make money,” Fries said. Liberty Global is on the verge of launching WiFi first cellular services in the Netherlands, which will crash the cellular price curve there, similarly to the way Free has crashed the market in France.
On the upside, Fries is positive about the market consolidation in Europe. M&A activity in France, Ireland and Germany is encouraging Liberty Global.
“That is a good thing,” he said.
None of the other speakers directly responded to Fries’ remarks. In fact, Kabel Deutschland CEO Manuel Cubero started a long conversation, which appeared to be with himself, in German, about how his company is in “an excellent position” to offer flat rates for the use of Internet content, followed by a statement that “there will be more fairness for the consumer with convergence, distribution of infrastructure through flat rates.”
Fries switched tack trying to charm the crowd by declaring that this is the most interesting panel he had been on for a long time. We think he meant because he was on it.
In fact, “the European industry is the most interesting industry I have been in for a long time. We are all lucky to be in this ecosystem. It is so cool,” Fries declared, this, after telling everyone that the US was a better climate for business.
The only response he got was from Weber, who expressed the hope that all market players will “observe some respectful interaction” in the future.
In a final push for less regulation, Fries urged the German panelists to embrace a rapidly changing market and not to hide behind rules and laws.
“By human nature, we tend to defend and protect our turf, worry about disrupting our own business models, we are afraid’ but the pie is growing for all of us. Every year. We are all winning,” he said.
But his somewhat passionate plea fell on deaf ears. No one stepped in; no one responded.
This led Fries to note that, among the panelists, there was not one representing the customer. And his opinion, there is only one regulator that matters: the consumer.
“It does not matter what somebody in Germany or Brussels says,” he concluded. Luckily for all of us he is not right, and it is likely that the regulators and courts will continue to be the bane of his life for some time to come.